Best Amish & Mennonite Fiction Books of 2025

"Women Talking" is a gripping and thought-provoking novel based on a true story about eight Mennonite women who gather secretly to decide if they should stay in their community or escape after being repeatedly violated by men in their own colony. Told through the "minutes" of their meeting, the book explores themes of feminism, free will, and forgiveness. Author Miriam Toews skillfully weaves wry humor and heartbreak into the narrative, making it a feminist manifesto that delicately unwraps the horror of the situation. This international bestseller is a must-read for fans of Margaret Atwood's "The Handmaid's Tale."

The Friendship Letters series, starting with "Letters of Trust," by Wanda E. Brunstetter, tells the story of three friends who exchange letters to cope with the challenges of life. In this first book of the series, Eleanor's husband turns to alcohol after the death of his youngest brother, putting their marriage in danger. Eleanor writes to her friend Doretta, who responds with gentle words of advice and comfort. Brunstetter, a New York Times bestselling author, accurately portrays the Amish way of life in her novels. This heartfelt book is a reminder of the power of friendship and the healing potential of a simple letter.

Breaking New Ground is the second book in Amy Clipston’s Amish Legacy series and a sweet, inspirational Amish romance. The story follows Korey Bontrager, who returns to Pennsylvania after fourteen months in Ohio, and Savannah Zook, who has no interest in dating as she prioritizes looking out for her bullied brother. When Savannah suggests they pretend to date to get their friends and family off their backs, Korey agrees, and soon he can't imagine life without her. The book's plot is unique, with a focus on redemption and growth, making it an enjoyable read.

New York Times bestselling author Shelley Shepard Gray presents Once Upon a Buggy, the second installment in The Amish of Apple Creek series. The book tells the story of May Schott, who is determined to seek forgiveness from her childhood friend, Carl Hilty, after a tragic accident left him severely burned. However, when Carl returns to Apple Creek, he seems to harbor hatred towards May, leaving her confused and heartbroken. The book is a sweet twist on the classic Beauty and the Beast tale, with a heartwarming message about the importance of forgiveness and healing. Gray's writing is rich with warmth, endearing characters, and a captivating plot that will enchant readers.

Hopefully Ever After is the third book in The Amish Bookstore Novels series, a sweet contemporary Amish romance written by bestselling author Beth Wiseman. The book follows the story of Eden and Samuel, two teenagers from different backgrounds who find themselves falling in love despite their families' disapproval. With themes of self-discovery, faith, and cultural differences, Hopefully Ever After is a heartwarming and engaging read that will leave readers feeling uplifted. Wiseman's skillful writing and attention to detail make this book a standout in the crowded genre of Amish romance.

The Heirloom by Beverly Lewis is a heartwarming prequel to The Shunning. The book follows the story of Clara Bender, a nineteen-year-old Amish girl, who visits her mother's aunt in Lancaster County's Hickory Hollow to decide where her future lies. The two women bond while restoring an heirloom wedding quilt and sharing their lives. Clara's visit provides an opportunity to meet the area's eligible young men, but when the unexpected happens, she must decide where her heart truly belongs. This book is a tender story of love, belonging, and the courage to move forward. Fans of Amish & Mennonite fiction books will enjoy this beautifully crafted novel.

Courage in the Storm by Laurel Blount is a heartwarming Amish romance that tells the story of Miriam Hochstedler, who struggles with anxiety and fear after witnessing her parents' murder. She forms a bond with a traumatized horse, which brings skilled horse whisperer Reuben Brenneman into her life. As they work together to heal the horse, an unexpected friendship blossoms into romance. However, their different backgrounds and beliefs threaten to tear them apart. The book is a beautiful portrayal of love and courage, and Laurel Blount's writing is evocative and moving.

The second book in The Friendship Letters series by Wanda E. Brunstetter, Letters of Comfort, explores the power of letter-writing as a source of comfort and hope in times of grief. The protagonist, Doretta Schwartz, struggles with depression after the death of her fiancé, but finds solace in exchanging letters with her friends. The story delves into themes of loss, friendship, and the healing power of communication. Brunstetter, a New York Times bestselling author, brings her expertise in Amish fiction to this heartwarming novel. Letters of Comfort is a unique addition to the Amish romance book genre, offering a fresh perspective on the power of community and support in times of need.

Happily Ever Amish is the first book in a new series by Shelley Shepard Gray. Set in Apple Creek, Ohio, the story revolves around Addie Byler, a shy woman who receives anonymous love letters. Although skeptical at first, Addie finds herself drawn to the author of the letters, Daniel Miller. As they exchange messages, they discover a connection that leads to something deeper. The book is perfect for fans of Amish romance novels, featuring endearing characters and a heartwarming story. Gray's writing is captivating, and the book is a delightful read from start to finish.

Secrets of Willow Springs - Book 1 (The Amish of Lawrence County) is a captivating story that revolves around Emma Byler and her family's hidden past. As Emma approaches her sixteenth birthday, she is desperate for freedom and to spend time with a special boy. However, tensions at home and her father's worsening behavior make her fear that her father will pull back the reins. The book is an enthralling tale of traditional life, complex relationships, and stunning twists. Tracy Fredrychowski's writing style is detailed and engaging, making this book a must-read for fans of Amish romance books.