Best Cake Testers of 2025

"These are fantastic for baking. They work much better than a toothpick, and I love how easy they are to clean. Plus, they’re compact and versatile for testing doneness on various foods. The three-pack is reasonably priced, especially for someone who bakes often."

"I thought these would be unremarkable, but I was wrong. I really appreciate that I can just throw them in the dishwasher after using them. They make my baking life so much easier!"

"I was having trouble finding these in stores, so I decided to check Amazon. They are perfect for checking baked goods like cakes and muffins. I feel confident having two extras on hand, and their length is much better than toothpicks. I'm excited to put these Ateco cake testers to good use!"

"I find this cake tester to be great, especially with the cover that comes with it!"

"This product is sturdy and the bright red grip makes it easy to locate in my drawer."

"I bought this because I was tired of using toothpicks. It’s easy to find and I’m very pleased!"

"I rarely bake cakes, but when I do, these testers are perfect. They clean easily and quickly tell me if my baking time was sufficient. Just what I needed!"

"I finally bought cake testers after years of waiting. They are so cute and come in various thicknesses, making it easy to test all my baked goods. Great quality at a fantastic price!"

"I bought two sets, one for myself and one as a wedding gift. They are cute and different from what I've seen before. Perfect addition to any baking collection!"

"I received 12 cake testers, which was perfect for my needs. I ended up giving some to my Mom, who has trouble holding things, and she managed just fine. They are easy to clean by hand, and I highly recommend this product."

"I buy these for my fiancé, who is a chef, and he gets them every Christmas. He truly loves these cake testers!"

"These are reliable for checking the internal temperature of various foods. I found them to be exactly what I expected, and the bulk price makes it an economical choice for gifts to my fellow line cooks."

"I bought this little guy because I was tired of throwing away toothpicks. Much to my delight, this cake tester worked just as well! I've learned that you can choose whichever instrument makes you happy, as they both work. I usually wipe my tester clean with a soapy sponge right after using it—it keeps it safe and tidy."

"This handy tool is easier to find than a box of toothpicks and better for testing deep cakes like Bundt styles. It’s quick to rinse and reuse—definitely saves a tree!"

"I usually test my cakes with toothpicks, but they’re too short for angel food cake and Bundt cakes. This cake tester solves that problem, allowing me to stop using and throwing away toothpicks."

"I purchased this bundle for my Chef daughter, and she absolutely loved them! They work perfectly and are just so cute! The price was also perfect."

"I find these testers to be much cuter and easier to use than toothpicks for testing cakes and cupcakes."

"The pack of three was just what I needed. They work well, and I’m very happy with my purchase!"

"This tool is simply perfect—it's sturdy, easy to use, and affordable. I love how the needle part is nice and long, making it easy to clean."

"Overall, I think it's a good product with a mildly sharp point that works well."

"I find the RSVP cake tester to be a wonderful addition to my baking tools. The stainless steel design not only looks great but helps me minimize waste compared to disposable options. It's easy to clean and works perfectly for testing cakes!"

"This Granny Fork has been a staple in my kitchen for years. The grippy handle and improved chrome plating make it incredibly useful. I've used it for everything from carving meat to mashing eggs, and it still looks and works great!"

"While I loved how this tool mashed my potatoes to a light and fluffy texture, I’m a bit concerned about its durability. It feels like it could break easily, but the low price makes it worth trying out."

“The handles are comfortable to grip, and the testers are lightweight but sturdy. I really appreciate how precise they are; they help me achieve perfectly baked cakes every time. It’s a small tool, but it makes a significant difference in avoiding overbaking or underbaking. Overall, I'm very pleased with this set and would definitely recommend it to fellow baking enthusiasts.”

“These testers exceeded my expectations! I was anxious that the needle part would be too thick, but they turned out to be a fine gauge while still being sturdy. I love that they don’t have a pointed tip, making them safer for me. No more wasting bamboo skewers as cake testers! After using them once, I’m very satisfied and would highly recommend them.”

“I purchased these for my bundt cakes since toothpicks weren’t long enough. While I'm unsure how long they will last, for the price, it’s a good deal. They feel more sturdy and plain than I anticipated, but I believe they will serve me well for years.”

"This cake tester is substantial and easy to manage, even with an oven mitt on."

"I use this all the time for baking. The toothpick picks up batter but is easy to clean and reuse."

"I absolutely love these testers! They're perfect for cupcakes, cakes, and even bread!"