Best Baking Sheets of 2025

“I was looking for the right pans, and these are perfect for baking cookies. The nonstick feature works well, especially with the cooling rack included.”

“I was pleasantly surprised by these baking sheets. They feel hefty and durable, and the cooling racks add great value. They are a great size too!”

“I haven’t had the chance to bake with these yet, but they clean easily and seem to offer great quality at a lower price!”

"I'm thrilled with these pans! They're very durable, easy to clean, and I use them often for everything from cookies to roasted veggies. Excellent value for the price!"

"After using these Nordic Ware pans, I can confidently say they're the best. Even baking and no burning! I immediately ordered more after seeing the results—I wish I had found these sooner!"

"I invested in the Nordic Ware pans because I wanted something high quality and chemical-free. They exceeded my expectations with even cooking and easy cleanup. No more rusty non-stick pans!"

"I bought these for my wife last year for Christmas, and after baking Christmas cookies, I just ordered another set this year. The cookies slid off the Goodcook, but I needed a chisel for the other brand. I immediately replaced her entire set and also got a pizza pan—can't wait to try it! These are awesome!"

"I bake almost daily, and I recently made English muffin pizzas for lunch. These pans clean so easily! Some cheese melted onto the tray, but it wiped off without any effort when I washed them by hand. I'd definitely buy these again and love the lip on the trays to avoid any mess!"

"I think these trays are perfect! The three sizes have been very useful, and they don't warp even after about ten uses at temperatures between 180 and 200°C. Nothing sticks to them, and they've handled melted sugar, chocolate, and cheese without a problem. I'm impressed with the affordable price and quality—they clean perfectly with just a damp cloth!"

"I received my baking sheets quickly, and I love the three different sizes. They feel durable and heavy, with no signs of warping or scratches. I'm confident they will last for years!"

"These are the best nonstick cookie sheets I've ever had! They clean up effortlessly with no residue left behind. The sizes are a fantastic combination, and the price is great too!"

"I've been impressed with these baking sheets. They bake cookies evenly without sticking. The various sizes are perfect for all my baking needs, and they wash up quickly with just soap. Plus, the gold color helps prevent burning!"

“I find your cooking sheets to be the most beautiful addition in my brand new kitchen. My wife and I enjoy home cooking together, and these sheets have made our experience even more enjoyable. Thank you for helping us start the new year with a huge smile!”

“I appreciate the sizes and handles of these sheets! I made cookies for the first time with them, and they came out wonderfully without sticking. I'm really loving them!”

“Although I don't bake, I use these sheets for roasting meats and veggies from my meal kit service. The small and medium sizes are perfect for me. They do warp a bit in the oven but return to normal when cooled. Clean-up is a breeze, although I learned the hard way to use foil when roasting sticky items. Despite that, I prefer these sheets over any I've had before, especially because of the three size options.”

"These baking sheets are exactly what I needed! I love the silicone mats and the cooling racks. The trays are very sturdy and the no-stick mats keep them clean. They’re perfect for making Christmas cookies!"

"I bought these for my mom as she needed a new set of sheets and mentioned wanting a cooling rack. This was the best deal I could find. She told me they clean very well and she likes the three sizes for all her needs. They work as they should and haven't warped after one year. I would likely purchase again if needed."

"So far, everything seems fantastic! The mats are reinforced and high quality. The trays are thick and scratch resistant, and they fit nicely together for storing. I haven't experienced any issues with the trays warping."

"I absolutely LOVE these baking sheets. The quality is top tier, and they seem like professional baking sheets. All of my cookies bake evenly!"

"I've used these pans for roasting veggies and baking cookies. They're durable and have made cleanup a breeze. Just remember, no dishwasher!"

"I made chocolate chip cookies and snickerdoodles, and they baked perfectly. I really like their width, but they do seem to scratch easily. However, with proper care, I believe they will last a long time!"

"I absolutely love the color and the fact that they don't scratch easily. Since they're easy to clean, I prefer handwashing them to avoid any rusting. The nonstick technology is amazing, and they cook food evenly. Plus, the set comes in three different sizes, which is great value for the price!"

"These pans are exactly what I expected! After testing them by burning food, I found them to be heavy and durable. They are not only visually appealing but also very easy to clean. For the quality, they are incredibly inexpensive. I'm so pleased with my purchase!"

"I love the diamond pattern on these baking sheets, as it significantly improves heat distribution. There's no need to use extra oils, and cleanup is a breeze. These pans are surprisingly sturdy and have outperformed anything I've had before. The rich blue color is just beautiful!"

"I love these pans! The non-stick coating makes cooking a joy and they are easy to clean. My food comes out perfectly every time. They might be a bit smaller than what I'm used to, but they still work great!"

"These baking sheets are fantastic! I still adore my original one, but having different sizes is so convenient. I often use the smaller one as an eating tray to heat my meals in the oven. It’s perfect!"

"I'm really pleased with these pans. They don’t rust like stainless steel, and I appreciate having three in a set. They fit perfectly in my small oven, and I can use all three on different racks at once. Just a bit more effort is needed to remove the grease film after use."

“I absolutely love these baking sheets! They're phenomenal! After ruining my old ones, I decided to invest in these Calphalon sheets, and I couldn't be happier. Easy removal of baked goods, and they're a breeze to clean. Worth every penny!”

“I found these baking sheets to be a bit pricier than others, but their sturdiness and easy cleaning make them worth it. They do warp a little during baking, but they return to flat once cool. Just wish my oven could fit both at once!”

“I’ve had these pans for a few months now, and they quickly became my favorites. I did notice some warping when loaded unevenly, but they pop back flat when cooling. I would reorder without hesitation.”