Best Sugar Cookies of 2025

"I love serving these cookies with tea or coffee to my guests. They were a hit! So delicious and perfectly lemony, they are chewy and soft, especially when kept in the fridge. I plan to order more and use a cookie cutter for holiday shapes to impress everyone!"

"These Birthday Cake cookies were a delightful surprise. Not overly sweet and the flavor was just right. I was impressed with their freshness and would definitely order them again."

"I discovered these cookies by chance and they quickly became my favorite. Soft and chewy with just the right flavor! I was disappointed to find they were out of stock when I tried to order more for myself and my mom. I’ll keep checking back!"

"I found these cookies to be incredibly enjoyable! I even treated myself to some gourmet vanilla ice cream to pair with them, and I loved them so much that I won’t be sharing! After receiving my first box just three days ago, I’ve already ordered another!"

"As a fan of soft chocolate chip cookies, I was thrilled to discover these at my new job's break room. A quick 15 seconds in the microwave turned them into pure bliss! I bought the rest on the shelf and realized it’s more economical to order online. I can't wait to try the other flavors!"

"Living in Tennessee, I have a special appreciation for these cookies because they are locally made. I’ve ordered them multiple times online and they never disappoint!"

"I find the cookies to be absolutely scrumptious. My daughter even warms them in the microwave for five seconds on a paper towel, and it makes the chocolate gooey and soft throughout the entire cookie."

"I had the cookies sent to my mother's Assisted Living. They arrived sooner than I expected, but the facility placed them in her old mailbox, which caused a little confusion. I apologize for that!"

"Throughout the years, I've tried many oatmeal cookies, but this one is truly the BEST I've ever tasted. It's moist, flavorful, and just enough to satisfy my cravings."

"I first discovered Goodie Girl brown sugar cookies on a flight, and I was instantly hooked. I've been enjoying them for about three years now. They have a crunchy texture, are not overly sweet, and each pack contains just 100 calories. I do prefer the large box format, which I can no longer find since Whole Foods stopped carrying it. While the smaller packs are handy, I dislike having to dispose of an empty bag after each delicious snack."

"These cookies are absolutely delicious! They are crunchy with great flavor, and I’ll definitely be ordering them again. They make for a really nice treat that doesn’t leave you feeling guilty, especially if you're watching your weight."

"I had the chance to try these cookies on a flight, and I loved them so much that I had to find them again! Absolutely love these cookies!"

"I've ordered these cookies for an event each of the last 3 years. They are of great quality, and while some are damaged, that's expected since they serve as taste testers. Finding individually wrapped cookies at this price and quality is hard to match!"

"I bought these for my kid's cookie decorating project during the holidays. They are a bit pricey, but the 4-inch diameter is just right, and they are perfect for those with nut allergies."

"The cookies taste good, but I was disappointed to find that many were broken in the box. I handled it very carefully, yet out of 50, more than half were broken. It's sad because I probably won't be ordering again."

"I found these cookies to be quite delicious! The sleigh was a bit tricky to assemble, but it's really cute."

"I received these during the holiday rush as a gift. My family thought they were adorable and said they tasted fresh and tasty!"

"I was excited to give these as a gift, but the cookies had a stale, chemical taste. I couldn't serve them to anyone."

"I ordered 150 star cookies for our fourth-grade team, but 51 of them were broken. Overall, they were a hit!"

"I love these cookies as a sugar-free treat. They are perfect for dipping in my tea and satisfy my cravings!"

"We enjoy these cookies as a dessert with every meal. They taste amazing with coffee or chocolate, or even on their own!"

"My family recently gave up sugar, and these cookies are a great replacement for the sugary ones. We're all really happy with them!"

"I have no idea about the cookies, as I bought this as a Christmas gift for my 'big' kid! However, the tin is fantastic; it plays music, lights up, and everything was well packed and shipped promptly."

"Unfortunately, the cookies arrived all broken and crumbled in both boxes I ordered. They weren't protected from breaking, so they might as well have sent the boxes empty. On the bright side, the tin boxes are awesome! The cute Snoopy snow play day design and the music that plays, along with the lights, make it a $12 reusable treasure. Now I have two to share with my great-grandchildren after my husband and I enjoy the cookie pieces!"

"I purchased this for my boss who has small children, and it was a hit! The family absolutely loved it."

"I bought these for an event with friends who are GF, but I fell in love with these crunchy, ginger-flavored cookies. I’m not GF, but they’re definitely a keeper!"

"I always look forward to these cookies each Christmas, but this year, they were tiny little cookies, nothing like previous years. I was very saddened."

"When I tasted these cookies, I almost cried because they reminded me of the ginger snaps I shared with my Gram over 35 years ago! I'm so grateful to Jill Robbins for creating these amazing cookies that are whole grain, soy-free, and allergy-friendly."