Best Peanut-Butter Cookies of 2026

"I bought this as a Christmas gift for my two-year-old neighbor who loves snacks. She was absolutely delighted with the assortment!"

"This pack offered a great deal, and my daughter really enjoyed all the treats. I'll definitely be ordering again!"

"I used this set to make treat bags for Halloween. While I wished it included a little more for the 25 bags I was preparing, it was still a generous assortment and worked perfectly for my needs."

"I sent these to my college student and he absolutely loved the taste and the handy individual packs. They were perfect for grabbing between classes or while studying, and the portion size kept the rest fresh."

"The bite-sized cookies are so tasty and crunchy with a creamy peanut butter center. I really appreciate the just-right package size, which makes them perfect for quick snacks."

"I bought these for baking and was happy with the excellent value and individually wrapped bags. It made it easy to use what I needed and keep the rest fresh for later—super convenient!"

"I always keep these on hand because the value and quality never disappoint. The cookies are a great size, taste amazing, and I find myself buying them again and again."

"For me, Nutter Butters are like peanut butter dressed up for a party—crunchy on the outside, creamy on the inside, and bursting with bold, sweet, and salty peanut flavor. They’re not a health food, but they’re my go-to treat when I want something nostalgic and delicious."

"These cookies are simply delicious! They have the right amount of crispiness and a tasty peanut flavor. I love that they are affordable and perfect for pairing with tea or coffee. I definitely recommend them!"

"I'm absolutely hooked on these cookies—they're the only ones I want to eat. Now my daughter and granddaughter are fans too! The perfectly sized bags make them great for sharing or grabbing on the go when I'm busy. I've noticed these are often sold out at local stores, so finding them cheaper and in larger bags online was a huge win for me. I stick to the vanilla, but I appreciate that there's a chocolate option too."

"I keep buying from this seller because they're always reliable and offer a great deal. I've purchased twice now and plan to order again. The service and product quality are consistently excellent."

"These cookies are a hit with my grandkids and were perfect for filling Christmas goodie bags. The individual packs are bigger than most other cookies I've seen, and they're well-priced, making them an easy choice for sharing."

"The peanut butter flavor is absolutely delicious! While the chocolate wasn't really my favorite, I'm definitely going to buy it again."

"This snack is perfect for my sweet tooth—low in sugar and carbs, and it keeps me satisfied without overindulging."

"I'm hooked—these treats are tasty, smooth, and not too sweet. I've made them my go-to snack, and knowing they're vegan with organic ingredients makes it even better."

"I'm honestly impressed by how fresh and tasty these peanut butter crackers are. The cracker part stands out compared to others I've tried, making them my go-to snack!"

"These are my absolute favorite cookies—they arrived in perfect condition and tasted incredibly fresh. I shared a few with my uncle, but I'm definitely hiding the rest because they're just that good!"

"While the cookies took me back to my childhood, I was a bit let down by the lack of protective packaging. Many arrived broken, but the flavor is still top-notch!"

"Every time I get these, they're fresh and always a crowd favorite—I've never had a bad batch."

"The double stuffed Nutter Butters are amazing. It's honestly tough not to go through the whole package in one go because they're that good."

"These cookies are seriously addictive and one of the few snacks that still taste as delicious as ever. The extra peanut butter filling really makes a difference."

"I've loved these since I was a kid, and I'm thrilled to find them again! The crunch and creamy filling remind me why these snacks are an all-time favorite. They always seem to make a bit of a mess, but that's part of the fun for me."

"I can't get these locally, so ordering them online feels like a special treat. They're so fresh, almost like eating a candy bar, and always arrive in good condition."

"My husband really enjoys these. They're a great value for the price and come in a sturdy box. I tried to buy more, but they were out of stock—I'll definitely get more when they're available again."

"I couldn't resist these cookies—they're absolute peanut butter and chocolate heaven! The fudge is thick and luxurious, and the cookies stay fresh and perfectly textured. Honestly, they're my go-to snack now, and if you love peanut butter, you need to grab two boxes because you'll finish the first one fast."

"These are, hands down, the best chocolate-covered cookies I've ever had. The texture is both soft and crunchy, and the flavor hits all the right notes. They're perfect with a cold glass of milk or a hot cup of coffee."

"I did find them a bit pricier than expected, and my batch arrived with some chocolate bloom. While the taste is good, I felt they were a little too hard for my liking."

"I can honestly say I’m obsessed with these cookies—they’re my absolute favorite store-bought treat. The texture is spot on, they taste like they’re made from scratch, and my kids devour them too. I love that the ingredients are straightforward and natural. I always recommend trying different flavors to keep things exciting!"

"Even though I’m not a big peanut butter fan, the peanut butter flavor completely won me over! I actually hid the bag from my husband and enjoyed every single cookie myself. Now I don’t even bother trying to bake my own cookies—these are perfect right out of the bag."

"You’d never guess these are vegan because they’re so rich and full of flavor. I’m always amazed at how good they taste!"