Best Shingles & Shakes of 2025

Howard Chester Avatar
Howard Chester
Last Updated: Jan 2, 2025

* We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

Shingles and shakes are two traditional roofing materials that have been used for centuries. Shingles are typically made from wood and are cut into small, rectangular pieces that are layered on top of each other to create a waterproof barrier. Shakes, on the other hand, are made from hand-split logs and have a more rustic, natural look. Both shingles and shakes are durable and long-lasting, making them an excellent choice for homeowners who want a classic, timeless look for their roofs. Additionally, they are environmentally friendly and can be easily recycled or repurposed at the end of their lifespan.

At a Glance: Our Top Picks

Miller Shingle 18" Cedar Sidewall Shingle Cover #TOP 1
Miller Shingle 18" Cedar Sidewall Shingle
ftb score rating icon 9.8
Miller Shingle R&R Cedar Sidewall Shingles Cover #TOP 2
Miller Shingle R&R Cedar Sidewall Shingles
ftb score rating icon 9.7
Western Red Cedar Straight Split Shakes Bundle Cover #TOP 3
Western Red Cedar Straight Split Shakes Bundle
ftb score rating icon 9.5

Top 10 Shingles & Shakes

#TOP 1

Miller Shingle 18" Cedar Sidewall Shingle

SUC181
Natural
Miller Shingle 18" Cedar Sidewall Shingle Cover
Miller Shingle 18" #4 Undercourse Cedar Kiln Dried Sidewall Shingle 1 Square Carton, Natural

The Miller Cedar Sidewall Shingle is designed for double-coursing sidewall applications and adds a decorative touch to your home. It efficiently covers 100 square feet when installed with a 14-inch exposure, or 50 square feet at a 7-inch exposure, allowing you to choose the look that suits your style. Made from high-quality Western Red Cedar, these shingles bring natural beauty and durability. However, it's important to note that these shingles are not suitable for roofing or as starter courses for roofs, ensuring you select the right product for your project.

What We Like
Versatile for decorative applications
Efficient coverage options
Made from durable cedar
Proudly manufactured in the USA
#TOP 2

Miller Shingle R&R Cedar Sidewall Shingles

NG1812P
Primed
1/2 Square Carton
Miller Shingle R&R Cedar Sidewall Shingles Cover
Miller Shingle 18 Inch Rebutted and Rejointed (R&R) Natural Groove Cedar Sidewall Shingles Primed 1/2 Square Carton

Miller Shingle Cedar Shingles are crafted from high-quality, kiln-dried cedar, ensuring durability and aesthetic appeal for your sidewalls. The grooved design on one side enhances the shingles' ability to shed water effectively, providing better protection for your home. Each carton covers a generous area, with options for both double and single coursing, making installation flexible and efficient. Proudly made in the USA, these shingles not only support local manufacturing but also guarantee a reliable product for your building needs.

What We Like
High-quality cedar material
Flexible coverage options
Water-shedding design
Proudly made in the USA
#TOP 3

Western Red Cedar Straight Split Shakes Bundle

JNAB
Brown
Western Red Cedar Straight Split Shakes Bundle Cover
Western Red Cedar 18" X 3/8" Straight Split BARN Shakes Bundle

This raw lumber product is a bundle of 18" long, 3/8" thick, straight split shakes that are not tapered. The bundle covers an area of 25 square feet at 14" exposure.

What We Like
Durable and long-lasting due to Western Red Cedar material
Straight split shakes provide a rustic and natural look to any building
Thick and uniform thickness throughout the shake ensures consistent quality
#TOP 4

Western Red Cedar #1 Perfections Shingles Certigrade USA

"N/A"
181PC
Yellow
Western Red Cedar #1 Perfections Shingles Certigrade USA Cover
Western Red Cedar #1 Perfections Shingles Certigrade - US Mill

Introducing the Western Red Cedar #1 Perfections Shingles Certigrade USA, the perfect choice for your roofing needs. Made in the USA, these shingles offer a length of 18 inches, with a minimum of 17-1/4 inches, ensuring ample coverage for your roof. With a thickness of 2-1/4 inches, achieved by using 5 shingles each measuring 45/100 of an inch, these shingles provide excellent durability and protection against the elements. The width ranges from 4 inches to 14 inches, offering flexibility in installation. With 25 square feet per bundle at a 5-1/2 inch exposure, these shingles are designed to cover a large area efficiently. Upgrade your roof with the Western Red Cedar Shingles and enjoy reliable performance and long-lasting beauty.

What We Like
Ample coverage
Durable and protective
Flexible installation
#TOP 5

Faithfull Slaters Ripper FAISR1

FAISR1
Blue
Faithfull Slaters Ripper FAISR1 Cover
Faithfull FAISR1 Slaters Ripper,Blue,5.6 cm*72.8 cm*6.8 cm

The Faithfull Slaters Ripper is an essential tool for anyone working with slates. It is designed to slide under slates effortlessly, allowing you to pull out or shear fixing nails before replacing them with new slates. The tool features a flexible steel blade that measures 23 inches, providing ample length for reaching tight spots. With its hardened and tempered spring steel construction, you can trust this tool to deliver strength and durability. Plus, the comfortable PVC grip ensures you can work for extended periods without discomfort, making your slate replacement tasks much easier.

What We Like
Effortless nail removal
Durable steel blade
Comfortable grip
Long reach
#TOP 6

Miller Shingle MasterCut Cedar Shingles

RFB18
Round
104 Pieces
Miller Shingle MasterCut Cedar Shingles Cover
Miller Shingle MasterCut Round Decorative Cedar Shingles 104 Pieces

The Miller Cedar Shingles offer a high-quality choice for your roofing needs. Each shingle is crafted from premium #1 cedar, measuring 17 inches long and 4 15/16 inches wide, which provides a sturdy and reliable covering. One side is sanded, ensuring a smooth finish that enhances the aesthetic of your home. With 104 shingles included in each carton, you can easily cover a significant area, making your project more efficient. Proudly made in the USA, these shingles ensure you are supporting local manufacturing while investing in durable roofing materials.

What We Like
High-quality cedar material
Sanded for smooth finish
104 shingles per carton
Proudly made in the USA
#TOP 7

Polaris Cedar Shake Vinyl Siding

NED7SSWI
Savannah Wicker
Polaris Cedar Shake Vinyl Siding Cover
Polaris Homeside Select Double 7in. Cedar Shake Vinyl Siding (1/2 Square) Savannah Wicker

The Polaris Homeside Select Double 7in. Cedar Shake Vinyl Siding offers a Tru-Lock locking system and random seams, providing a realistic texture from dozens of real cedar shakes. This low maintenance product comes with 10 pieces per box (50 sq. ft.), and has a height of 15-3/8in. and exposure of 17in. Overall. It is recommended to allow about 20% for waste. Suitable J Channel Color and Size: CertainTeed 3/4in. Savannah Wicker J Channel.

What We Like
Realistic texture from dozens of real cedar shakes
Low maintenance
Tru-Lock locking system and random seams
Comes with 10 pieces per box (50 sq. ft.)
Recommended J Channel Color and Size: CertainTeed 3/4in. Savannah Wicker J Channel
#TOP 8

A&R 24" Royals Cedar Shingles

A&R
241R
A&R 24" Royals Cedar Shingles Cover
24" #1 Royals Certigrade Western Red Cedar Shingles

The A&R Cedar Shingles are crafted from smooth, uniform western red cedar, ensuring a polished look for your roofing needs. With a nominal thickness of 0.50 inches, these shingles provide durability and strength, making them a reliable choice for your home. Their random widths, ranging from 4 to 14 inches, allow for a unique, customized appearance that enhances curb appeal. Each shingle measures 24 inches in length, offering ample coverage and reducing the number of shingles needed for installation, which can save you time and effort during the roofing project.

What We Like
Smooth, uniform finish
Durable 0.50-inch thickness
Customizable random widths
Efficient 24-inch length
#TOP 9

TWP 205 Cedar Shake Sealant

TWP
TWP 205 Cedar Shake Sealant Cover
TWP 205 California Cedar Shake & Shingle Sealant - Professional Strength, Deep Penetrating Wood Protectant, UV & Water Resistant, Easy Apply - 5 Gallon

The TWP Cedar Shake Sealant provides exceptional protection for your wood surfaces. Its professional-grade formula defends against water and harmful UV rays, keeping your wood looking great and lasting longer. You’ll appreciate how easy it is to apply, allowing you to save time and effort. With its deep-penetrating properties, this sealant works from the inside out, ensuring thorough coverage and durability. Whether you’re protecting wood shakes, shingles, or log homes, this versatile solution is designed to meet your needs.

What We Like
Professional-grade protection
Easy to apply
Deep penetration
Versatile for various wood types
Long-lasting durability
#TOP 10

TWP 201 Cedartone Wood Protectant

TWP
CEDAR201
TWP 201 Cedartone Wood Protectant Cover
TWP 201 Cedartone Shake and Shingle Sealant - Professional Strength, Deep Penetrating Wood Protectant, UV & Water Resistant, Easy Apply - 5 Gallon

TWP Wood Protectant offers professional-grade defense for your wood surfaces. Its robust formulation protects against water damage and harmful UV rays, ensuring your wood remains in top condition. The easy application process saves you time and effort, making it simple to use. With its deep-penetrating formula, it safeguards your wood from the inside out, providing thorough protection. This versatile product is perfect for a variety of wood types, including shakes, shingles, and log homes, giving you confidence in your wood maintenance efforts.

What We Like
Professional-grade protection
Easy to apply
Deep penetration formula
Versatile for various wood types
Buying Guide Image

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. What do shaker shingles look like?

Shaker shingles are made of natural cedar and have a rough-hewn, rustic appearance. They are individually cut from logs and shaped into square or rectangular tiles. This gives them a unique and attractive look that complements various home aesthetics, from vinyl siding to stone or brick.

2. How long are shake shingles?

When properly installed and maintained, cedar shake shingles can last for around 30 years. With high-quality materials and favorable conditions, it's possible to get up to 50 years of life out of them. This durability makes shake shingles a long-lasting roofing option.

3. Are shake shingles good?

Shake shingles offer durability and resistance to insects and wind. However, they are less resistant to moisture, which can weaken the wood and make it brittle. It's important to protect shake shingles from excessive moisture to ensure their longevity and prevent breakage.

4. Is shake roof more expensive than shingles?

Yes, a cedar shake roof is generally more expensive compared to an asphalt shingle roof. The average price for a cedar shake roof can range from $8.00 to $15.00 per square foot, while asphalt shingles typically cost between $3.50 and $5.50 per square foot for installation.

5. Are shakes more expensive than siding?

Yes, shakes are generally more expensive than vinyl siding. While vinyl siding is a more affordable option, cedar shake is considered a higher-end choice. In addition to higher purchasing costs, the installation and maintenance of cedar shake can also be more expensive compared to vinyl siding.

Editor's Notes

During our shingles & shake research, we found 25 shingles & shake products and shortlisted 10 quality products. We collected and analyzed 3,827 customer reviews through our big data system to write the shingles & shakes list. We found that most customers choose shingles & shakes with an average price of $155.94.

The shingles & shakes are available for purchase. We have researched hundreds of brands and picked the top brands of shingles & shakes, including Miller Shingle, JNAB, "N/A", Faithfull, Polaris. The seller of top 1 product has received honest feedback from 14 consumers with an average rating of 4.8.

Written by
Howard Chester Avatar

Howard Chester is an architect from New York who holds a master's degree in architectural design, his passions for interior design and home improvement contribute to his extensive knowledge of all things furniture and home goods. Howard Chester Specializes in various architectural and interior design projects. He often publishes articles related to decoration on key websites and interior design magazines.