Best Shaving Soaps for Men of 2025

"I had initially criticized the soap bowl, but this company really stands by their product. After using it, the soap lathers beautifully, and it holds the hair up well for a smooth shave without any irritation. While the soap sizes are smaller, I actually appreciate that because I can try different scents without wasting any. I’ll definitely be buying more."

"I've been using one of the four soap discs for about three months now, and I'm surprised it's still 'half full.' The lather is thick, the smell is subtle, and it doesn't linger, which I prefer. Honestly, this four-pack will last me over a year, so there's no point in endlessly comparing prices—just get the soap that you enjoy the most."

"Out of the four soaps, only two have a pleasant scent—Sandalwood and Clary Sage. The other two were quite disappointing, with one lacking any scent at all. I bought these for their fragrance, so I expect better quality. If I can get Clary Sage separately, I will, as it's the best of the bunch. The Hay Rum scent reminds me of mold, and I’m unsure how that passed quality checks."

"I really love the smell of this soap and the lather it creates. It provides excellent lubrication for my straight razor. After switching from disposable razors, I've experienced no more ingrown hairs or razor burn. I've gone through several bars and continue to appreciate it."

"This shaving soap puck is a great find! It lathers easily and lasts a long time. The scent is pleasant without being overpowering, and it gives me a close shave without irritation. I highly recommend making the switch from canned foam."

"I was initially surprised by the small size of the bar, but it has exceeded my expectations in longevity. The sandalwood scent is fantastic, and while it could lather a bit more, it does a good job at softening my facial hair and providing adequate lubrication for a close shave."

"I absolutely love using this soap on my face with a lather brush. It creates fantastic cream, and a single puck lasts me about a year. That's roughly $3.75 annually at the current price!"

"I just started using this for shaving, and it seems to produce a thicker lather compared to my last brand. I'm quite pleased with it so far!"

"After restocking this soap, I can confirm that the scent is not overpowering, and it lathers well enough for my everyday shaving needs. If you find it for under $10, it's a great buy!"

"I've been using this shaving cream for over a year now, and I still have plenty left in the original container. It just keeps giving and giving."

"After switching from shave pucks to this brand, I found that it creates a thick lather in just 4-5 spins of the brush. It feels refreshing and works perfectly with my razor."

"While I’m not a fan of the scent, the shaving experience is great. I might explore other scents or consider a multi-package for variety."

"I was very skeptical about switching from regular shaving gel to this soap, but I absolutely love it. It glides smoothly like my old gel did, and I've been using the same bar for months!"

"As someone who shaves my head, I appreciate the great smell and natural ingredients. However, I find myself needing to reapply lather, which can be a bit tedious during my shave. Still, it's priced well and might work better for others."

"I've tried multiple shave soaps, and this one is my favorite. I've never had lather issues and have been a loyal customer for years. Highly recommended!"

"I've been using this shaving soap for years with my brush and mug. It goes on almost like whipping cream. I highly recommend it for those who use a brush and mug."

"I have to be careful about scents due to my sensitivity. I was pleasantly surprised by Van Der Hagen's unscented product, which truly is unscented. The 'luxury scented' version has a vaguely floral smell that isn't persistent, making it suitable for people like me."

"I started using this soap recently after not finding my usual brand. It's a great replacement that lathers well and stays on the face throughout the shave. I appreciate its non-scented nature and enjoy the lather it produces."

"As someone new to traditional shaving, I found this soap to be really effective. The scent is pleasant but not overpowering, and it lathers well. I’m pleased with my purchase!"

"Initially, I was ready to give this soap a one-star rating. However, after taking my time to properly lather it, I found it works much better. It has a nice smell and provides a decent feel, although I wish it didn't dry out a bit."

"This shaving soap is fantastic! It fits perfectly in my old container, creates plenty of suds, and lasts long. I'm really happy with my purchase."

"This is my third order of this shaving soap. As a 35-year veteran of hard soap shaving, nothing else gives me a closer shave. I keep returning to my cake soap and brush because it outperforms canned foam every time."

"My wife and I absolutely love the manly yet pleasant fragrance. The lather is fantastic, and I’m so pleased to have discovered this wet lather shaving soap!"

"Using TOBS's sandalwood soap for my morning shave is a nostalgic experience. The scent takes me back to my youth, imagining the elegance of tea and crumpets served by servants. The strong sandalwood scent inspires a poetic mood, making it my exclusive choice for shaving."

"Over the last 20 years, I've tried many soaps, from high-end to budget-friendly. Van Der Hagen stands out as the best I've encountered, even surpassing some pricier options. It lathers effortlessly and offers exceptional protection from the blade. This product is truly a gem."

"I used VDH when it was available at Target. It's a great value for the quality it provides."

"I've experimented with various shave soaps, but this one is my favorite. Van Der Hagen shave soap is affordable and delivers outstanding performance—I use it every day."

"I purchased this shaving soap for travel, and I'm almost ready to ditch my other puck for good. The lather is dense and velvety, and it gives my razor a better glide without greasy residue. Plus, the scent is just right—clean without being overpowering."

"After a long day at work, I was excited to try this soap. However, I struggled with a really stuck container lid. In the end, I managed to open it myself and was rewarded with a great shave. My Helga likes it too! Five skols!"

"This was my fourth time ordering Lather & Wood Sandalwood Shaving Cream, but I was disappointed when I received a coconut-scented product instead. The company was quick to respond, and they sent me replacements. I appreciate their effort to keep my business!"