Best Shaving Soaps for Men of 2026

"I've been using shaving soap for a while and wanted to try something new. The cedar scent is nice, not overpowering, and my wife describes it as 'fresh' and 'subtle.' The soap lathers easily and offers great skin protection. It does take a bit more water to rinse than Proraso, but nothing bothersome. I follow up with a moisturizer for best results."

"I switched to this soap because it was more affordable than Lather and Wood. It lathers up well, and I get smooth, nick-free shaves—just need to keep the brush loaded. So far, I'm satisfied with the value and performance."

"The soap definitely needs a lot of water to lather, and the foam disappears pretty fast on my face. The scent is extremely mild—almost unnoticeable. I found myself reapplying often during a shave. I wish the lather lasted longer, but it's still a budget-friendly product."

"I've tried plenty of shaving soaps, but this one stands out for its quick, rich lather and mild, masculine scent. It feels great on my skin and lasts forever—even a tiny piece keeps working. The price is reasonable considering the quality and longevity. I highly recommend it."

"I was hesitant to spend more on a shaving soap, but after using this, I'm glad I did. Compared to my old brand, this puck offers a superior lather and smoother shave. My razor glides effortlessly, and the subtle fragrance is a nice touch. Definitely worth the investment."

"This shaving soap is a pleasant surprise—the sandalwood scent is noticeable yet not overpowering, and the lather is thick and cushioning. My shave is always comfortable, though I do need some aftershave balm as my face feels a bit dry afterward. Overall, it's a solid choice for a close shave."

"After using up my old shaving soap stash, I gave this product a try and was pleasantly surprised. It creates a quick lather, gives a slick shave, and has a very pleasant scent. So far, I'm extremely pleased with how it performs."

"As a former Williams user, I’ve tried several alternatives since it was discontinued. Scalpmaster stands out as the best—lathers well, smells good, and lasts a long time. I finally found my new go-to shaving soap."

"I’m pretty picky with shaving products, and I appreciate that this soap is affordable, lasts a long time, and offers a light, clean scent. While the lather could last a bit longer, it’s a small trade-off for the value you get."

"I've been using this soap for almost a year and it's still going strong—incredible longevity! I use a badger brush and a double edge razor, and the lather it creates is thick, comfortable, and never dries my skin out. The scent is pleasant without being overwhelming, and even my wife loves it. For the price, I really can't beat the value."

"After trying many brands, I finally found a soap that produces a rich, nourishing lather and doesn't irritate my sensitive skin. It softens my tough beard quickly, making shaving a real pleasure. The sandalwood fragrance is subtle but masculine, and I can't recommend this enough—it's become my go-to for daily shaves."

"Proraso Red makes a wonderfully thick, slick lather that leaves my face feeling hydrated after every shave. While the scent is a bit sweet and powdery, it's grown on me, and the performance is reliable once I learned to use less water with my boar brush. If only it was a bit cheaper in the US, it would be perfect!"

"I bought the sampler pack to try out all the scents except for Almond, which I already had. The soaps provide a slick and cushioning shave, don’t dry out my skin, and work well for the price. Although the scents are generally mild, I appreciate how they don’t overpower my cologne. Each puck lasted through a week of daily shaves, and I’m happy to keep Col. Conk in my regular rotation."

"After getting the Almond and Lime pucks at a local shop, I found the 4-pack online for a great price. All the scents are enjoyable, with Almond being my favorite, and the lather is consistently excellent and long-lasting. I love how the blade glides smoothly using these soaps, and every shave feels really comfortable."

"I’ve been using these pucks for about a month and they lather up easily and smell great – maybe even a bit better than my usual TOBS. The only issue is deciding which scent to use each day! Just a heads up, microwaving the pucks can ruin them, so be careful."

"After getting caught up in the hype of artisan soaps, I finally tried Proraso and was truly impressed. The scent is incredibly fresh with a subtle menthol kick, and the lather forms quickly and easily. My razor glides effortlessly, and I can use blades for several more shaves before needing to change them. This soap lasts a long time and has become my go-to for both regular and sensitive skin shaves."

"With over three decades of shaving experience, I can confidently say that the lubrication this soap provides is unmatched. It delivers a rich lather without clogging the razor, making blades last longer. The eucalyptus and menthol offer a cool, invigorating sensation, especially on the final pass. Using Proraso has made my daily shaves more comfortable, cost-effective, and irritation-free."

"There's something truly satisfying about opening a new tub of Proraso. It creates a creamy, luxurious lather and leaves a fresh scent behind. The tub lasts for months, making it both a luxurious and budget-friendly option. My only minor gripe is that towards the end, the lather can be a bit less creamy, but it still provides a solid shave."

"I was hesitant to switch from my usual shaving gel, but after giving this soap a try, I'm genuinely impressed by how well it works. The lather is easy to build and the razor glides smoothly over my skin. I've noticed that one bar lasts for months, and the ingredient list is much cleaner than most alternatives. My only minor gripe is that it can leave my skin a little drier than gels, but overall, this is now my go-to shave product."

"As someone who shaves their head, I can say the fragrance is great and the soap lasts a long time. However, for me, the lather tends to disappear quickly, so I have to keep reapplying as I go. If you have softer facial hair, this might work perfectly, but for head shaving, it requires a bit more effort. That said, the ingredients are solid and the price is right."

"I've experimented with several shave soaps, and this one is by far my favorite. Lathering is effortless and long-lasting for me, and I've never run into the issues others mention. I've stuck with this soap for years and plan to keep buying it."

"I've been using shaving soaps for a while, mainly Proraso, and decided to try this one for a new scent. The lather is easy to build and provides great protection for my skin. The cedar scent is pleasant, though I wish it was a bit stronger. My wife really likes the fragrance, describing it as 'fresh' and 'subtle.' Overall, I'm satisfied with how well it works and that it doesn't dry out my skin."

"I tried this soap because it's much cheaper than some other brands I've used. It lathers up nicely, even if the lather isn't quite as abundant as my previous favorite. My shaves have been nick free, and the soap works well as long as I don't rinse my brush too soon. Very happy with the performance for the price."

"This soap needs a bit more water to get going, but once lathered, it feels good and offers decent cushion for shaving. However, the lather tends to dissipate quickly and the scent is almost non-existent. I was hoping for a stronger fragrance, and I find myself reapplying it several times during a shave."

"After trying several brands, I’ve settled on this shaving soap as my new go-to. The scent is pleasant, the lather is rich and enduring, and it’s comfortable for shaving. I also appreciate that it’s affordably priced and made in the USA."

"This is the best shaving soap I’ve used—and I’ve tried almost everything out there. The lather stays thick and doesn’t thin out on my skin, and the pucks really do last a long time. They’re not the cheapest, but the quality makes up for it."

"I’ve always used soap-based shaving products and decided to give this a try. The texture is enjoyable, and the scent is subtle yet pleasant. It takes a bit more effort to build a lather, but overall, I’m very satisfied."

"After switching from more expensive soaps, I found Proraso White incredibly impressive for my sensitive skin. The lather is slick and cushiony, letting my razor glide effortlessly for a close, comfortable shave. I appreciate its mild scent that doesn’t cause irritation, and the value is excellent compared to pricier brands. I’d absolutely recommend it to anyone looking for a better shave."

"As someone who shaves daily and has tried countless premium brands, I was amazed at the dense, luxurious lather and fresh scent of Proraso. The sensitive skin formula let me use an aggressive blade without a hint of irritation, and the price is almost unbeatable. This line is so good, I might stop using aftershave altogether."

"I've used both the old and new formulas, and both offer a smooth, lubricating shave. I did notice a slight tingling, likely from menthol, and sometimes there’s a thin white film left on my gear. While it works well for many, those with extremely sensitive skin should test it first."