Best After Shave Balms of 2026

"I've been using this product for years because it's never oily or greasy, and it always leaves my skin feeling comfortable after shaving."

"Recently switched to shaving with a safety razor, and this balm keeps my skin hydrated without stinging. It’s much lighter than regular lotion, and the scent is very subtle so it doesn't clash with my cologne."

"I use this as a primer under my makeup, and honestly, it works even better than most expensive primers I've tried—plus, I love the subtle masculine scent!"

"I've been using this post-shave balm and the cooling sensation is fantastic, especially after shaving my head. A tiny amount goes a long way, and it keeps my skin feeling smooth and fresh without being greasy. The light scent is a nice bonus. It’s quickly become a staple in my routine."

"I was impressed with the Cremo men's grooming products, starting with their shower soap, and now this balm. It’s soothing, non-drying, and makes my skin look great after shaving. I love that it’s affordable and high quality. I honestly can’t recommend it enough—it just works."

"As someone who is picky about post-shave products, I found this balm to calm my skin effectively. The cooling effect is noticeable and refreshing. The only thing I’d change is the initial medicinal scent, but it fades quickly, so it’s not a dealbreaker for me."

"For me, Bee Bald HEAL Aftershave Balm is a true game-changer. Every time I shave, this balm quickly relieves burning and redness, leaving my skin comfortable instead of irritated. I like that it absorbs fast, doesn't feel greasy, and my skin stays soft and smooth. Just a small amount is enough, so the bottle lasts a long time. Shaving feels much less harsh now—it's really improved my routine."

"I've tried countless aftershave products, but this one stands out, especially for head shavers like me. The creamy texture spreads easily, absorbs quickly, and instantly calms razor burn, bumps, and nicks. I use it on my entire scalp and face, and it never clogs pores or feels greasy. The scent is light and clean, and my scalp looks and feels healthier over time. Honestly, it's become essential in my post-shave routine."

"My husband swears by this balm for his sensitive skin. It soothes his face after straight razor shaves and he hasn't found anything better. The cream is just the right consistency—not too thick or watery—and a little goes a long way. He really notices the difference with less irritation and smoother skin."

"I've been using this aftershave balm for years, and it's a game changer for my daily routine. My skin feels incredibly soft after every shave, and the scent is wonderful without being overpowering. Plus, it's so convenient to get it on Amazon!"

"I shave my head regularly and this balm keeps my scalp moisturized and greatly reduces razor burn. It absorbs well with no oily residue, and even though it may sting a little on small cuts, that fades fast."

"Harry's Post Shave Balm is absolutely essential in my shaving routine. It calms any irritation, hydrates my skin, and never leaves a greasy feeling. I highly recommend it for anyone looking for smooth, refreshed skin."

"I've used this post-shave balm for years and it always soothes my sensitive skin and keeps it hydrated without any greasy residue. The scent is subtle and pleasant, and I appreciate that it comes in a value 3-pack. I haven’t had any issues with irritation or ingrown hairs since I started using it."

"This balm is a must-have for anyone with sensitive skin. It’s moisturizing, absorbs quickly, and doesn’t leave any sticky feeling. I also like the glass bottle and find the price for three bottles to be very reasonable. I plan to buy it again."

"I really like how this balm calms my skin after shaving and helps reduce redness. It also has a pleasant, not overpowering scent. My only minor complaint is the bottle sometimes dispenses more than I need, so a pump would be nice."

"Because my wife has fragrance allergies, I really appreciate that this balm has no added fragrances. It's become our go-to because it's very soothing and gentle on her skin."

"What I like most is that it soothes my skin without leaving any after-burn. It's got a mild aroma and feels lightweight yet moisturizing. During summer, I don't even need an extra cream after using it."

"The balm goes on smoothly and has a pleasant scent that's not overwhelming, which is exactly what I was hoping for."

"I've tried a lot of aftershave balms, and I appreciate that this one smells great, moisturizes well, and isn't greasy. The sandalwood fragrance gets plenty of compliments and really lingers nicely. I've noticed less dryness, and a little bit of product goes a long way."

"I was on the hunt for a good sandalwood aftershave, and this one really helps me with razor burn and post-shave irritation. While there's a bit of an odd odor when you first pump it out, the sandalwood aroma soon takes over. It's effective enough for me to use daily, despite my sensitive skin."

"The texture is rich and easy to lather, and the scent is clean and masculine—just what I want for my traditional wet shaving routine. It performs on par with much pricier creams and leaves my skin feeling protected and refreshed. Plus, the company truly cares about customer satisfaction, which makes a big difference to me."

"I've struggled with razor burn and sensitive skin on my neck, and most aftershave products have either failed or made things worse. But this Cremo sensitive skin balm really surprised me—it works just as well as the pricey Musgo Real I used to buy, but it's much more affordable. I love that it's fragrance free and doesn't leave an oily residue, just a slight 'waxy' feel that's not bothersome. The only downside is the thick consistency makes it tough to squeeze out of the bottle, but that's minor compared to the results. For me, it's a 5-star product that genuinely soothes irritation."

"As someone with very sensitive skin, I've found the unscented version of this balm to be incredibly gentle and soothing. I can even use it around my eyes and as a hand cream without any irritation. A tiny drop goes a long way, especially on damp skin. My only gripe is that it's too thick to easily dispense from the current bottle, and I sometimes get more than I need."

"While I know many people like this product, for me, it actually caused stinging and itching instead of soothing my skin, and I found the scent unpleasant, kind of like a musty old boat. I’ve tried a lot of aftershaves, and unfortunately, I can’t recommend this one based on my experience."

"I've tried many aftershave products, but Nivea Men Maximum Hydration Balm keeps my skin soft and moisturized for hours—even into the next day. As someone who shaves with a straight razor, I appreciate how well it restores moisture and soothes irritation."

"This has become my go-to aftershave, especially since I have sensitive skin. I love the pleasant scent and the smooth, calming feel. It keeps my face hydrated all day—I even set up a subscription so I never run out."

"I've used this balm for years and really enjoy its light texture and fragrance. It’s not like a lotion, but a true balm that applies smoothly and makes my face feel great."

"I've tried a lot of aftershaves, but this one really stands out. The minty scent is refreshing, and it keeps my skin soft and bump-free after shaving. A little bit is all I need, so the tube lasts a long time. I highly recommend it!"

"This balm has become my daily go-to. It moisturizes well without leaving any greasy residue, and the cooling effect is a great wake-up in the morning. I like that the scent is more mint than menthol. It's gentle around the eyes and never stings."

"After trying this product, I was impressed by how quickly it soothed my irritated skin. It absorbs nicely, isn’t greasy at all, and the fresh feeling lasts. I would definitely buy it again!"