Best Shea Butter Eye Creams of 2025

The ColourPop Daily Eye Cream is designed to deeply hydrate and refresh the delicate skin around your eyes. Infused with plant-derived Squalane, this cream helps improve moisture retention and skin elasticity, making your under-eye area look healthier. Shea Butter forms a protective barrier to lock in moisture, while Coffee Seed Extract works to diminish puffiness and dark circles. By incorporating this cream into your morning or evening routine, you can prep your skin for makeup or enjoy a soothing nighttime treatment that leaves you looking bright and rejuvenated.

Paula's Choice RESIST Anti-Aging Eye Cream is a deeply penetrating, rich hydrating eye cream that helps minimize the appearance of under-eye darkness, wrinkles, fine lines, and crow's feet. It alleviates dryness and boosts suppleness with prolonged hydration that lasts all night long. The cream contains Shea Butter peptides and antioxidants that improve the look of dull skin, while significantly boosting hydration and reinforcing a supple firm feel. It can be used as part of a daily evening skin care routine along with other Paula's Choice products. Paula's Choice Skincare products are free of fragrance, parabens, and fluff.

No7 Pure Retinol Eye Cream is a dermatologically tested anti-aging eye retinol cream that targets the appearance of seven key signs of aging around the eyes. The carefully formulated eye cream includes pure retinol and shea butter base with a unique collagen peptide technology to be gentle yet effective. It not only works as an eye wrinkle cream but also brightens dark circles, firms, lifts, and hydrates skin around the eyes. This eye cream is fragrance-free and dermatologically tested.

Keys Eye Butter Luminescent Natural Eye Cream is a vegan, chemical-free, and natural eye cream designed to brighten and enhance skin color around the eyes. The eye butter contains whole cucumber extract, exotic oils, and aloe vera to hydrate, rejuvenate, tighten, and create a soft glow around the eyes, while reducing visible signs of aging and fine lines. It contains no synthetic ingredients and is made in the USA in a certified organic and chemical-free facility.

Montana Made Bright Eyes Butter is designed to help you bid farewell to crow's feet and fine lines. This all-natural eye cream rejuvenates the delicate skin around your eyes without causing irritation or redness. The inclusion of cocoa butter helps maintain your skin's elasticity and protects against moisture loss and UV damage. Meanwhile, shea butter softens the skin and boasts anti-inflammatory properties for a soothing effect. With its rich antioxidants, this eye cream also fights free radical damage, keeping your skin looking youthful and vibrant.

No7 Eye Cream is designed to combat signs of aging around your eyes. It effectively targets fine lines, wrinkles, and puffiness, helping you achieve a more youthful appearance. Enriched with powerful ingredients like ginseng extract and hyaluronic acid, this cream provides deep hydration, ensuring your delicate skin feels refreshed and invigorated. Additionally, it works to visibly reduce dark circles and bags under your eyes, leaving you looking bright and awake. This product is suitable for sensitive skin, making it a great choice for everyone seeking eye care.

The PYUNKANG YUL Eye Cream is a deep nourishing eye moisturizer cream with healthy ingredients extracted from shea butter, saponin, and isoflavonoid. It calms angry skin and promotes healthy skin by providing vitality and elasticity. The cream forms a moisture protection barrier, enhancing the skin's defense against external harmful substances. It comes with a special film to protect the cream from external harmful substances.

V11 Hydro Boost Eye Cream is a vegan eye cream designed to provide intense lightweight hydration to your skin. With V11TM complex, 8 types of hyaluronic acid, and chamomile extract, this eye cream soothes and improves your skin barrier for a radiant look. Its special formula contains 92% natural ingredients, including 1% of shea butter, to deeply nourish your eye area skin. This cream is suitable for all skin types, with a rich texture that moisturizes your skin without leaving a heavy finish. It is perfect for those who want to have healthy and balanced skin.

Revitalize your eyes with On the Lamb Eye Cream. This lanolin-based cream contains phyto placenta, collagen, and elastin to reduce puffiness and crow's feet. The addition of royal jelly, Korean Ginseng, Fu Ling, and rosehip oil provide long term hydration, leaving your eyes looking refreshed and rejuvenated. The cream is free of harmful parabens and mineral oil and comes in an environmentally responsible packaging. Additionally, the biodegradable ingredient replaces the harmful EDTA, which is harmful to aquatic life. Try On the Lamb Eye Cream for a natural, animal-friendly solution to tired eyes.

Indigo Wild Zum Face Under Eye Butter is a rejuvenating eye cream that keeps the tender tissue under eyes toned and hydrated. It is made with natural ingredients such as evening primrose oil, essential oils, shea butter, and vitamin E, which are all vegetarian. This under eye butter is best used at night, but can also be applied in the morning if you have time to soak. Handmade in small batches, Zum products are from people for people.