Best Closed System Electric Breast Pumps of 2025

Elisa Drew Avatar
Elisa Drew
Last Updated: Jan 8, 2025

* We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

Closed system electric breast pumps are a popular choice for new mothers who are looking for a convenient and efficient way to pump breast milk. These pumps are designed with a closed system, which means that the milk is pumped directly into a separate container, ensuring that it remains hygienic and free from contamination. They are also equipped with a powerful motor that allows for quick and efficient pumping, which can be especially helpful for mothers who are short on time. Many models also come with adjustable suction settings, allowing for a more comfortable and personalized pumping experience. Overall, closed system electric breast pumps are a reliable and convenient choice for mothers who want to provide their babies with the benefits of breast milk, even when they can't be there to nurse them directly.

At a Glance: Our Top Picks

Medela Pump in Style with MaxFlow Cover #TOP 1
Medela Pump in Style with MaxFlow
ftb score rating icon 9.8
Medela Swing Maxi Double Electric Cover #TOP 2
Medela Swing Maxi Double Electric
ftb score rating icon 9.7
Medela Freestyle Flex Breast Pump Cover #TOP 3
Medela Freestyle Flex Breast Pump
ftb score rating icon 9.5

Top 10 Closed System Electric Breast Pumps

#TOP 1

Medela Pump in Style with MaxFlow

101041362
Grey
3 Count (Pack of 1)
Medela Pump in Style with MaxFlow Cover
Medela Breast Pump, Pump in Style with MaxFlow, Electric Breastpump, Closed System, Portable

The Medela Pump in Style with MaxFlow is a lightweight electric breast pump with clinically proven technology to increase milk volume by 11.8% in less time. It features an intuitive control panel, oval-shaped breast shields, and a full range of available accessories. It is ideal for working moms who need a portable, hands-free pump that is easy to assemble and clean.

What We Like
Portable
Double breast pump
Compatible with hospital-grade pump parts
Easy to assemble and clean
Comes with extra bottles and carrying bag
#TOP 2

Medela Swing Maxi Double Electric

101043614
Clear/Grey
1 Count (Pack of 1)
Medela Swing Maxi Double Electric Cover
Medela Breast Pump | Swing Maxi Double Electric | Portable Breast Pump | USB-C Rechargeable | Bluetooth | Closed System | with Carry Bag

The Medela Swing Maxi Double Electric Breast Pump is a portable and easy-to-use pump that helps increase milk output by 18% compared to traditional single pumps. With its 2-Phase Expression technology, it simulates the baby's natural sucking pattern, resulting in more efficient pumping sessions. The pump features a reliable closed system design with Overflow Protection, preventing breast milk from entering the tubing and ensuring hygiene. It is also equipped with intuitive controls and fewer parts, making it easy to use and clean. The built-in rechargeable battery allows for up to 1.5 hours of pumping without needing an outlet, and the included USB-C ensures faster charging. The Flex breast shields provide ultimate comfort and fit, molding to your shape for optimal milk extraction. The Medela Swing Maxi Double Electric Breast Pump is the perfect choice for busy moms who want convenience and efficiency in their pumping routine.

What We Like
Increased milk output
Reliable closed system
Easy to use and clean
#TOP 3

Medela Freestyle Flex Breast Pump

101037980
White
1 Count (Pack of 1)
Medela Freestyle Flex Breast Pump Cover
Medela Freestyle Flex Breast Pump, Closed System Quiet Handheld Portable Double Electric Breastpump, Mobile Connected Smart Pump with Touch Screen LED Display and USB Rechargeable Battery

The Medela Freestyle Flex Breast Pump is designed for moms on the go, with a compact and portable design that fits easily in your pocket, purse, or baby bag. Its patented, research-based 2-Phase Expression Technology produces more milk in less time for maximum efficiency. The reliable closed system prevents breast milk from entering tubing and is easy to clean. Additionally, it features a rechargeable battery that lasts up to 2 hours and Bluetooth connectivity to the Medela Family app for convenient pump operation.

What We Like
Compact and portable design
Efficient 2-Phase Expression Technology
Reliable closed system prevents contamination
#TOP 4

Crane Deluxe Double Electric Cordless Breast Pump

EE-9003
White
Crane Deluxe Double Electric Cordless Breast Pump Cover
Crane Deluxe Double Electric Cordless Rechargeable Breast Pump, Portable, Closed System, Overflow Protection

The Crane Deluxe Double Electric Cordless Breast Pump is a portable, closed system with overflow protection. Its easy-to-clean closed system ensures hygiene and safety. The rechargeable battery makes it perfect for travelling or on-the-go. The soft and comfortable silicone breast shield provides a comfortable experience. With multiple operation settings and easy touch controls, it is user-friendly. The breast pump also includes BPA free Tritan bottles.

What We Like
Easy-to-clean closed system
Rechargeable battery for on-the-go use
Soft and comfortable silicone breast shield
Multiple operation settings with easy touch controls
BPA free Tritan bottles included
#TOP 5

Philips Avent Double Electric Breast Pump with Natural Motion Technology

AVENT
SCF394/62
13 Piece Set
Philips Avent Double Electric Breast Pump with Natural Motion Technology Cover
Philips AVENT Double Electric Breast Pump Advanced, with Natural Motion Technology, with Clear Natural Response Baby Bottles, White Pump, Gray Bag, Pouch, and Belt, SCF394/62

The Philips Avent Double Electric Breast Pump with Natural Motion Technology is designed to mimic a baby's unique combination of suckling and massage for quick milk flow. This pump includes a pumping belt, rechargeable battery, and travel bag for convenience and mobility. With 8 stimulation and 16 expression levels to choose from, the pump remembers your settings for your next expression session. The soft silicone flange shield adapts to fit both size and shape of the breast, while the closed system ensures hygienic expression with no milk in the tubing. In addition to the pump, this set includes 2 flanges, 2 4oz. Natural bottles with Natural Response nipple, 2 sealing discs, 1 insulated pouch, 1 plug, and 2 disposable breast pads.

What We Like
Efficient and comfortable pumping experience
Adjustable suction levels for personalized comfort
Quiet and easy to use
Durable and easy to clean
Compatible with Avent glass bottles
#TOP 6

NCVI Electric Breast Pump F1

8129
NCVI Electric Breast Pump F1 Cover
NCVI Electric Breast Pump F1, VibesFlow Dual Control Pump, Hospital-Grade Suction and Double Side Independent Rhythm, Micro-Vibration Milk Pump, Breastfeeding Kit with Storage Bags & Cooler Bags

The NCVI Breast Pump offers a powerful and comfortable pumping experience for new moms. Its hospital-grade suction helps you express milk efficiently while mimicking a baby's natural feeding pattern, enhancing your milk yield. With advanced micro-vibration technology, this pump minimizes discomfort and pain, addressing common breastfeeding issues like clogged ducts. You can also customize settings for each side independently, allowing you to adapt to different milk production levels and sensitivities. This ensures a tailored experience that maximizes comfort and efficiency during your pumping sessions.

What We Like
Hospital-grade suction
Customizable settings
Comfort-focused design
Convenient cleaning
#TOP 7

Ardo Calypso Double Plus Electric Breast Pump Set

63.00.242
Clear
Calypso Double Plus
Ardo Calypso Double Plus Electric Breast Pump Set Cover
Ardo Calypso Double Plus Electric Breast Pump Set – Quiet, Swiss Made Breast Pump with 64 Settings – Closed System Hospital Grade Breastfeeding Pump with Bottles, Breast Shells & Essentials Included

The Ardo Calypso Pump Set offers you a silent and gentle pumping experience, with 64 different settings to cater to your comfort. This lightweight and travel-friendly pump protects you, your milk, and your baby with its Vacuum Seal technology. Enjoy quiet pumping sessions without worrying about sore nipples, find the perfect suction strength and frequency, and stay protected from contamination. Whether you're at work, on the go, or at home, the Ardo Calypso Pump Set ensures a comfortable and efficient pumping experience.

What We Like
Silent Pumping
64 Settings
Lightweight & Travel-friendly
Protects Against Contamination
#TOP 8

Crane Cordless Rechargeable Breast Pump

EE--9002
Clear
1 Count (Pack of 1)
Crane Cordless Rechargeable Breast Pump Cover
Crane Double Electric Cordless Rechargeable Breast Pump, Portable, Closed System, Overflow Protection

The Crane Rechargeable Breast Pump offers powerful cordless performance for your convenience. With its portable design, you can use it on the go without being tied down by cords. The closed system ensures hygienic pumping, keeping your milk safe for your baby. Enjoy the overflow protection feature that prevents spills and messes, giving you peace of mind. This breast pump by Crane is a reliable choice for busy moms seeking efficiency and ease of use.

What We Like
Cordless Operation
Portable Design
Hygienic Pumping
#TOP 9

MomMed S21 Wearable Breast Pump

S21-01-Gray-White
Aurora Pink
2Pack
MomMed S21 Wearable Breast Pump Cover
MomMed S21 Wearable Breast Pump - Smart Display, Leak-Proof Design, Hands-Free Double Portable Electric Breast Pump with 3 Mode &12 Levels - 24mm Shield & 6 Pairs of Flange Inserts (17mm, 19mm, 21mm)

MomMed Wearable Breast Pump is a smart solution for nursing moms. It offers 3 modes and 12 levels to mimic your baby's sucking motion, optimizing milk production efficiently and painlessly. The anti-leak design ensures a hygienic experience, preventing milk leakage. Its ergonomic design fits seamlessly under clothes, allowing you to pump hands-free while on the go. The smart display and low noise level make it discreet and user-friendly, suitable for pumping anywhere without disturbance.

What We Like
3 Modes & 12 Levels
Anti-Leak Design
Hands-Free Pumping
#TOP 10

Tommee Tippee Double Electric Breast Pump

522286
Clear White
8 Piece Set
Tommee Tippee Double Electric Breast Pump Cover
Tommee Tippee Made for Me Double Electric Breast Pump, USB Rechargeable Quiet, Portable, Lightweight

The Tommee Tippee Electric Breast Pump is designed to help you express more milk in less time with its massaging petals that stimulate breasts for strong yet gentle suction. The one-piece flanges make it easy to clean and assemble, ensuring convenience for busy moms. This lightweight and quiet pump allows you to discreetly express milk anywhere. Being USB rechargeable, it offers over 90 minutes of cord-free pump time. Whether you need to express from one side or both, this pump offers different modes to stimulate milk flow comfortably.

What We Like
Efficient Milk Expression
Easy Cleaning and Assembly
Portable and Discreet
Buying Guide Image

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Which breast pumps have a closed system?

CLOSED system pumps include:. Ameda: Elite, Platinum, Purely Yours.Ardo: Calypso, Carum.Bailey: Nurture III.Freemie: Freedom, Equality.Hygeia: EnDeare, EnJoye.Lansinoh: Signature Pro, Smartpump.Lucina: Melodi One.Medela: Lactina, Symphony.

2. Is a closed system breast pump better?

Every breast pump is designed a little differently, so you'll need to follow the cleaning instructions from your pump's manufacturer. A closed system doesn't necessarily mean better performance either. Some manufacturers have compromised their breast pumps' effectiveness to have a closed system.

3. Does Medela have a closed system?

Medela Pump In Style® maxFlow™ Technology, Closed System Quiet Portable Double Electric Breastpump, with PersonalFit Flex™ Breast Shields. Medela introduces the completely NEW Pump In Style® with innovative vacuum mechanism that combines our research-based 2-Phase Expression® technology with maxFlow ™ technology.

4. Is Medela Pump In Style open or closed?

The Medela Pump in Style Advanced is not a closed system pump so please remember to take the faceplate off periodically to check for mold. It's recommended that the faceplate be wiped down monthly. This is my main issue with Medela. They are the only major pump manufacturer with an open system breast pump.

Editor's Notes

During our closed system electric breast pump research, we found 24 closed system electric breast pump products and shortlisted 10 quality products. We collected and analyzed 37,739 customer reviews through our big data system to write the closed system electric breast pumps list. We found that most customers choose closed system electric breast pumps with an average price of $178.90.

The closed system electric breast pumps are available for purchase. We have researched hundreds of brands and picked the top brands of closed system electric breast pumps, including Medela, Crane, AVENT, NCVI, ARDO. The seller of top 1 product has received honest feedback from 385 consumers with an average rating of 4.7.

Written by
Elisa Drew Avatar

Elisa Drew is a really professional copywriter specializing in baby products with five years of experience working as a pediatrician once. She has published a series of baby books purchased by over thirty thousand people in the United States.