Best Cosmetic Pencil Sharpeners of 2026

"After struggling with another brand that always broke my pencils, this sharpener worked flawlessly on the same products. I love that it has three built-in sizes and is super easy to clean—nothing gets stuck or smashed. Exactly what I needed!"

"This sharpener is so much better than a regular one. It handles both my eyeliner and larger eyebrow pencils without breaking or making a mess. I also appreciate being able to see the pencil as I sharpen and the easy-to-empty design."

"I was worried about sharpening my plastic lip liners, but this sharpener worked wonders—they came out perfectly sharpened and never broke. My lip liners look brand new every time."

"I was honestly surprised by how well this sharpener works—it outperforms pricier options I've tried before. It's very affordable and handles my pencils perfectly. The only minor issue is the cap on the back, which sometimes pops off, but it doesn't affect how well the sharpener works. Highly recommend!"

"I honestly didn't expect to care about a pencil sharpener, but this one handles both my regular eyeliners and larger lip pencils with ease—no breakage or uneven tips. It's super simple to clean, and the cover keeps everything tidy in my makeup bag. If you use eye or lip pencils, this is a must-have."

"After trying a lot of sharpeners, I keep returning to e.l.f. because it never breaks or eats up my pencils, always leaving a smooth, precise point. Its compact size makes it perfect for travel. Definitely the best one I've used!"

"I've struggled for years with sharpeners that just didn't work well, but this one is a total game changer. The razor-sharp blades cut through wood effortlessly, and my pencils always come out with a perfectly smooth, fine point. I love that the exposed wood and lead are kept short, so I don’t have to worry about breakage. After trying it on all my pencils—from lip liners to watercolors—I'm truly impressed. None of my pencil leads broke, and the results are consistently excellent."

"I’m amazed at how good this sharpener is! The dual-hole design means I can use it on both my regular and jumbo pencils, and the aluminum body with diamond grip feels so much sturdier than any plastic sharpener I’ve tried. Every time I use it, I get a clean, precise point with zero mess or waste. Plus, it’s super easy to clean and doesn’t jam. I genuinely think this is a must-have for anyone tired of ruining their makeup pencils."

"In the past, sharpening my eyeliner pencils always left me with splintered wood and unusable points. But this sharpener is on another level—Made in Germany, it combines superior cutting edges with the perfect blade angle, making my pencils easy to sharpen and comfortable to use. I immediately saved two pencils I was about to throw away after just one pass through this sharpener. It’s honestly the best I’ve ever used!"

"I’ve tried so many sharpeners, but this is by far the best for my eyeliner, lip liner, and eyeshadow pencils. It keeps the tips sharp without breaking, and I love that it fits all my Charlotte Tilbury products. Sturdy and reliable—highly recommended!"

"I struggled to sharpen my CT lip liner because of the plastic coating and thought maybe it wasn’t meant to be sharpened. But as soon as I got this, it worked perfectly on my first try. The fit is perfect and it’s so worth it!"

"This sharpener is my absolute favorite, especially for my lip liners. It’s so easy to use and clean, and it handles plastic pencils like a champ. I always get the perfect point without any breakage."

"I've struggled with sharpeners that can't handle plastic pencils or that just chew up my liners, but this one is a game-changer. It sharpens cleanly, doesn't break off the tip, and works for multiple pencil sizes. Definitely worth the investment!"

"I love that this sharpener keeps my makeup pencils precise and mess-free. It's compact, fits in my makeup bag, and works perfectly for both eyeliner and lip liner. Highly recommend it for anyone wanting a defined tip in one go!"

"At first, I thought this sharpener wouldn't fit my oversized brow primer, but once I realized the opening lip could be removed, it worked perfectly. It's a relief to finally have a sharpener that fits all my pencils, including the larger ones!"

"I've finally found a sharpener that handles all my cosmetic pencils, from regular to jumbo sizes, with ease. The blades are super sharp and never break my pencils, and I love the cover that catches all the shavings—keeps everything tidy and simple to clean. For the price, this sharpener is a fantastic deal. Highly recommend it!"

"I was searching everywhere for a sharpener that wouldn't destroy my gel and thick eyeliner pencils, and this one has truly impressed me. It works flawlessly on different pencil materials and sizes, and I haven't had a single break or jagged edge. The only minor drawback is the small chamber for shavings, but overall, I'm extremely pleased with how well it performs."

"I bought this sharpener for my wife, and she absolutely loves it! It's easy to use, keeps her makeup pencils sharp and smooth, and the built-in container makes cleanup a breeze. I'm very happy with this purchase and would definitely recommend it to anyone wanting a reliable makeup sharpener."

"I've tried several inexpensive options, but I prefer this because the shavings are neatly contained and it works better than drugstore alternatives."

"This is my ideal brown shade—it sharpens easily and goes on so smoothly, making my brows look great every time."

"I love how the pigment is rich yet natural. It glides on effortlessly and is versatile enough for both everyday wear and more dramatic looks. It's an essential part of my makeup routine!"

"After struggling with other sharpeners that broke my makeup pencils, I found this one and it works flawlessly. It sharpens to a fine tip without breaking or jamming, and the built-in sizes fit all my pencils. Super easy to clean too—exactly what I needed!"

"I bought two of these for home and my purse because they're much more convenient than expensive brands. The shavings stay contained, and it handles different pencil sizes with ease. Definitely smarter design!"

"This sharpener is a game-changer for my eyebrow and eyeliner pencils. It gives a precise point every time, never causes breakage, and the compact design makes it perfect for on-the-go."

"I'm impressed with how well this sharpener handles both plastic and wooden makeup pencils. My previous sharpeners always left jagged edges or couldn't handle plastic at all, but this one keeps my pencils intact and sharp. Plus, it's super easy to clean and the compact size is perfect for my makeup bag."

"What I love most is the versatility — I can adjust the size for different pencils by removing a small tab, which means even my thick eyeshadow pencils fit. The shavings stay inside until I'm ready to empty it, keeping things tidy. Great quality and very handy!"

"After using several inferior sharpeners that wasted my makeup, I finally found this one and it's worth every penny. The sharp blades save so much product and it's easy to maintain. I highly recommend it!"

"I've tried countless sharpeners, but this one is a game-changer for my lip and eye pencils. Every time, I get a precise, fine point—absolutely a must-have!"

"I love how effortless this sharpener is to use. The quality is outstanding, it sharpens my pencils perfectly, and cleaning it is a breeze. Great value for the price!"

"This sharpener is simply the best I've ever owned. The closed cap keeps shavings contained, and it's so easy to empty and clean. My eye pencils have never looked better!"