Best Cosmetic Pencil Sharpeners of 2025

"This sharpener is amazing! It works effectively for every makeup brand I have. The best feature is that it takes very few turns to achieve a final result, saving me product and money in the end. I'm extremely pleased with the metal construction compared to the cheaper plastic ones I've bought over the years. I'm tossing all those out now. This is worth every penny, and the quality looks like it will last for years. An outstanding purchase that I highly recommend!"

"I've always purchased drugstore eyeliner pencil sharpeners, but after a few uses, the tip gets stuck or chewed up in the blade, making them unusable. This sharpener has an excellent design and blade. I've used it several times already, and there's been no issue at all. It sharpens to a nice tip and glides smoothly along the blade. Perfect every time!"

"I use gel eyeliner pencils, and I don't prefer the twist-up ones. The long-lasting or waterproof gel eyeliners don't sharpen to a point. I've tried multiple brands, but they all have the same problem with a piece of plastic at the top that prevents a point. This sharpener doesn't have that! The top of the sharpening hole is open, allowing the point to form without breaking off. Hands down the BEST sharpening tool and very affordable!"

"I absolutely love this sharpener! It's made with quality material and sharpens great. The color is very nice, and I highly recommend it. I even ordered two!"

"I usually dislike retractable liners because sharpening can be a hassle, but this sharpener worked perfectly on my NYX Line Loud Lip Liner! It sharpened smoothly without breaking the tip, and it didn't waste any product. I can confidently say it's well worth the price."

"I was worried at first because my Anastasia brow primers wouldn’t fit, but I discovered that I could pry the lip off the sharpener. Once I did that, it fit perfectly! I feel bad for initially giving it a one-star review."

"I'm thrilled with this sharpener! It sharpens my eye pencil perfectly without damaging the tip. It's incredibly easy to use, especially after chilling my pencil. I would definitely recommend it!"

"I just got this sharpener and it worked wonders on my lip liner. I appreciate the two different size holes for various makeup pencils. The plastic lid is a great touch for containing the shavings until I'm ready to dispose of them. I highly recommend it!"

"This sharpener surprised me with its excellent quality. It accommodates all my cosmetic pencils, even the thicker ones. I love that it collects the shavings, making disposal a breeze. It’s definitely worth the $12!"

“I absolutely adore these sharpeners! I bought two and plan to get three or four more just to be safe. They’re the only ones I’ve found in years that give me a needle-sharp point on my eyebrow pencils, allowing me to draw them on hair by hair. With my long-lasting eyebrow pencil, I can keep my brows looking great for up to three days without smudging since I sleep on my back!”

“This sharpener is perfect for my colored pencils! Its small size fits nicely in my bag, and it's incredibly easy to use. I find it very durable too.”

“I appreciate having two sizes of sharpening holes, although the smaller one isn’t as effective for thin pencils. I have to hold the thin pencil at an angle and turn it carefully. It might be due to a dull blade on the small hole. Anyway, I’ve figured out a workaround. I really miss my old stainless steel multi-hole sharpener, but I’m thankful for these affordable options from Wet ‘n Wild and Amazon. Highly recommend!”

"I absolutely love this KOKIE eye pencil sharpener! It's made of German stainless steel and sharpens gel liners effortlessly. I appreciate the two size options and the fun purple and black design with an elephant on top!"

"I was specifically looking for a sharpener for my pencil eyeliner because my previous one left jagged edges. This sharpener is gentler and more effective, maintaining the integrity of the pencil. Plus, it’s a nice small size with internal blades!"

"I've found my go-to sharpener! I’m really happy with this purchase; it does exactly what I need."

"After trying many sharpeners, I finally found one that actually works and doesn’t ruin my pencil!"

"I thought my eyeliner pencil was faulty until I used this sharpener. Now I can sharpen it properly. It's fantastic!"

"I've tested a dozen sharpeners, but this one outshines them all. The blades stay sharp for months, and the shavings are contained."

“I've owned various sharpeners, but this one is exceptional! Very sharp and I appreciate the three sizes; I just remove the insert for the extra-large hole. It's definitely the best I've tried!”

“Initially, I tried using my kid’s sharpener to save some money, but it only resulted in broken eye pencils. Eventually, I decided to purchase this sharpener, and it has been working well. After getting used to it, I can sharpen without damaging the pencils!”

“Having used Tweezerman sharpeners for years, I was on the lookout for a replacement after my last one broke. I chose this one, and it's performing even better without ruining my soft eyebrow pencils. The built-in pick for cleaning is a fantastic feature, and the cover keeps the shavings contained until I’m ready to empty it. The price was also very reasonable. I would highly recommend it!”

"I love the great color; it lasts a long time and is a fantastic price. I would definitely buy it again!"

"I used this liner for my daughter's dance performance, and it held up beautifully for the entire duration. It's a great value for the cost!"

"I was looking for a specific brown shade, and this product met my needs perfectly. It was easy to apply and lasted a decent amount of time."

"I found this sharpener to be the best for both plastic and wood pencils. It sharpens beautifully without breaking the tips."

"I appreciate the dual-sized holes for different pencil types, but the price felt a bit steep at nearly $10. The frequent need to dump shavings isn’t a hassle, though."

"This sharpener is a game changer! It has a clean, neat design that keeps everything tidy while sharpening, and it really does an excellent job on my makeup pencils."

“I've purchased these eyeliner sharpeners and have been using just one for a while now. It keeps sharpening my eyeliner pencil perfectly! Both ends are removable for easy cleaning. I even shared some with friends since I won't need them all anytime soon. These are fantastic for all my makeup pencils!”

“These sharpeners work like a charm! They give a fine tip without breaking the eyeliner tips. I’m absolutely thrilled with them—they're fabulous, fabulous, fabulous!”

“I often misplace my sharpeners, but now I've got extras! You can't beat the price, and they work really well. I've only tried them on my lip pencils so far, and they sharpen beautifully and glide around easily.”