Best Pewter Bottle Openers of 2025

Rebecca Cantu Avatar
Rebecca Cantu
Last Updated: Jan 4, 2025

* We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

Pewter bottle openers are a stylish and practical way to open a cold beverage. Made from a durable alloy of tin, copper, and antimony, these openers are both sturdy and visually appealing. They come in a variety of designs, from classic and simple to intricate and ornate, making them a great addition to any bar or kitchen. Additionally, pewter is a lead-free material, making these bottle openers safe for use and perfect for those who are health-conscious. Whether for personal use or as a gift, pewter bottle openers are a timeless and practical choice.

At a Glance: Our Top Picks

Fish Pewter Bottle Opener Cover #TOP 1
Fish Pewter Bottle Opener
ftb score rating icon 9.9
Chicago Skyline Pewter Bottle Opener Keychain Cover #TOP 2
Chicago Skyline Pewter Bottle Opener Keychain
ftb score rating icon 9.8
Harley-Davidson Pewter Finish Bottle Opener Cover #TOP 3
Harley-Davidson Pewter Finish Bottle Opener
ftb score rating icon 9.6

Top 7 Pewter Bottle Openers

#TOP 1

Fish Pewter Bottle Opener

Fish Pewter Bottle Opener Cover
Fish Pewter Bottle Opener By Basic Spirit

The Fish Pewter Bottle Opener by Basic Spirit is a great gift for fishing enthusiasts. It has a stainless steel opener component and is hand wash only. The opener is 5.25" long.

What We Like
Perfect gift for any fishing enthusiast
Stainless steel opener component
Easy to clean with hand wash
#TOP 2

Chicago Skyline Pewter Bottle Opener Keychain

Pewter
2 inches
Chicago Skyline Pewter Bottle Opener Keychain Cover
Chicago Skyline Pewter Bottle Opener Keychain

Introducing the Great Chicago Gifts Keychain - a metal keychain and bottle opener that showcases the iconic Chicago skyline in stunning detail. Crafted to resemble pewter, this 2-inch long keychain is a perfect gift or souvenir for any Chicago enthusiast. With the Chicago skyline beautifully depicted on both sides, this keychain is not only a practical tool but also a stylish accessory. The built-in bottle opener adds functionality, allowing you to easily open your favorite beverages wherever you go. Whether you're a Chicago local or a visitor, this keychain is a must-have item that lets you carry a piece of the Windy City with you at all times.

What We Like
Stylish Chicago skyline design
Compact and portable
Convenient built-in bottle opener
#TOP 3

Harley-Davidson Pewter Finish Bottle Opener

HDL-18573
Silver
4" x 1"
Harley-Davidson Pewter Finish Bottle Opener Cover
Harley-Davidson Engraved H-D Piston Bottle Opener, Pewter Finish HDL-18573

The Harley-Davidson Engraved H-D Piston Bottle Opener is a zinc cast opener with pewter finish that features a custom tooled Harley-Davidson handle and laser engraved Bar & Shield. The dimensions are 4" L x 1" W, making it perfect to carry around or store in your kitchen. This bottle opener not only opens your beverage but also adds an extra layer of entertainment with its unique design and custom details.

What We Like
Unique custom tooled Harley-Davidson handle and laser engraved Bar & Shield design
Pewter finish adds a touch of sophistication and durability to the opener
Compact size allows for easy storage and transport
#TOP 4

Basic Spirit Pewter Bottle Cap Opener

BO-34
Silver
Basic Spirit Pewter Bottle Cap Opener Cover
Basic Spirit Oyster Shell Pewter Bottle Cap Opener Coastal Shellfish Ocean Pearls

This bottle opener is made of hand-crafted, lead-free pewter and features an oyster shell design. The opener component is made of stainless steel, and it measures approximately 5 x 2 x 1 inches. It is recommended to hand wash and dry after use, and it is imported.

What We Like
Hand-crafted pewter material
Stainless steel opener component
Oyster shell design adds a coastal touch
#TOP 5

Chicago Pewter Bottle Opener Magnet

Chicago Pewter Bottle Opener Magnet Cover
Chicago Large Pewter Bottle Opener Refrigerator Magnet

This Chicago Large Pewter Bottle Opener Refrigerator Magnet is a 4 1/4" wide bottle opener made of pewter metal. It features strong magnets that provide safe, easy-access placement on your refrigerator or any magnetic surface. This bottle opener is a useful and convenient tool for opening your favorite beverages whenever you want without searching for an opener.

What We Like
Strong magnets ensure safe and easy access placement on any magnetic surface.
Made of durable pewter metal.
4 1/4" wide size is perfect for easy grip and handling.
#TOP 6

Heritage Pewter Michigan Wolverines Bottle Opener

BPR11455E
Silver
small
Heritage Pewter Michigan Wolverines Bottle Opener Cover
Heritage Pewter Michigan Wolverines 2023 CFP National Champions Bottle Opener | Bottle Opener for Beer & Soda | Expertly Crafted Pewter Metal Bottle Opener

The Heritage Pewter Bottle Opener celebrates the Michigan Wolverines' 2023 National Championship victory, making it an ideal gift for fans, graduates, or students. Crafted from high-quality Fine Pewter, this opener not only looks luxurious but also promises durability and a timeless shine. Its hand-crafted design ensures that every detail is meticulously etched, giving it a unique touch. Proudly made in America, this opener reflects traditional craftsmanship, offering you a reliable tool that stands out at any gathering.

What We Like
Unique Michigan Wolverines design
High-quality Fine Pewter material
Hand-crafted, meticulous detailing
Durable and long-lasting shine
Proudly made in the USA
#TOP 7

Chicago Skyline Pewter Bottle Opener Magnet

9854CH
Gold
One Size
Chicago Skyline Pewter Bottle Opener Magnet Cover
Chicago Skyline Bottle Opener Magnet - Pewter, 3.75 x 1.75 Inches

The Mad Mags Bottle Opener features a beautifully detailed design of Chicago's famous skyline. This multi-functional tool not only opens your favorite beverages but also serves as a stylish magnet, making it a practical addition to your kitchen or bar area. Crafted from sturdy pewter, it promises durability and longevity, ensuring you'll enjoy it for years to come. With its compact size of 3.75 x 1.75 inches, it’s perfect for display on your fridge or as a keepsake for anyone who loves the Windy City.

What We Like
Iconic skyline design
Multi-functional use
Durable pewter material
Compact size for display
Buying Guide Image

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. What material are bottle openers?

Most bottle openers are made with metal or stainless steel. Some are incorporated with plastic and wood. Material plays a factor in the bottle opener's weight, making it either light or heavy. Metal ones are mostly for heavy-duty work.

2. What was the first bottle opener?

When Was the Bottle Opener Invented? At first, there wasn't even a need for bottle openers because bottles were closed with cork or wood and opened with a corkscrew. Then, in 1892 William Painter invented the first bottle opener – the Crown Cork style bottle cap.

Editor's Notes

During our pewter bottle opener research, we found 24 pewter bottle opener products and shortlisted 7 quality products. We collected and analyzed 2,863 customer reviews through our big data system to write the pewter bottle openers list. We found that most customers choose pewter bottle openers with an average price of $12.68.

The pewter bottle openers are available for purchase. We have researched hundreds of brands and picked the top brands of pewter bottle openers, including Basic Spirit, Great Chicago Gifts, Harley-Davidson, Heritage Pewter, Mad Mags. The seller of top 1 product has received honest feedback from 19,606 consumers with an average rating of 4.9.

Written by
Rebecca Cantu Avatar

Rebecca Cantu grew up in a family-owned retail store for home and kitchen products. She worked online and gave assistance to people to buy ideal products for their sweet home after graduating from Northwestern University with a marketing degree. She has been writing content for online shopping guides since 2011 with her professional knowledge and natural sensitivity of appliances.