Best Pewter Candlestick Holders of 2025

Rebecca Cantu Avatar
Rebecca Cantu
Last Updated: Jan 3, 2025

* We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

Pewter candlestick holders are a classic addition to any home decor. Made of a durable alloy of tin, copper, and antimony, these candlesticks have a distinctive silver-like appearance with a soft, matte finish. They come in a variety of styles, from simple and elegant to ornate and decorative. Pewter candlestick holders can be used for both traditional and modern settings, adding a touch of sophistication and warmth to any space. They also make great gifts for weddings, housewarmings, and other special occasions.

At a Glance: Our Top Picks

Northern Lights Candles Simplicity Taper Holder, 4", Pewter Cover #TOP 1
Northern Lights Candles Simplicity Taper Holder, 4", Pewter
ftb score rating icon 9.9
Schooner Bay Co. Pewter Candlestick Cover #TOP 2
Schooner Bay Co. Pewter Candlestick
ftb score rating icon 9.8
DANFORTH Autumn Leaves Candleholder Cover #TOP 3
DANFORTH Autumn Leaves Candleholder
ftb score rating icon 9.6

Top 10 Pewter Candlestick Holders

#TOP 1

Northern Lights Candles Simplicity Taper Holder, 4", Pewter

Northern Lights Candles Simplicity Taper Holder, 4", Pewter Cover
Northern Lights Candles Simplicity Pewter Taper Candle Holder, 4"

The Northern Lights Candles Simplicity Taper Holder, also known as the Northern Lights Taper Holder, is a versatile and elegant addition to any home decor. Designed to hold all standard sized tapers, this taper holder is perfect for creating a simple and sophisticated table setting. Whether you're hosting a dinner party or enjoying a quiet evening at home, this taper holder adds a touch of charm and ambiance to any occasion. Made in the United States, it is crafted with attention to detail and quality. Enhance the atmosphere of your home with the Northern Lights Taper Holder.

What We Like
Versatile
Elegant
High-quality
#TOP 2

Schooner Bay Co. Pewter Candlestick

Schooner Bay Co.
4032
Pewter
Schooner Bay Co. Pewter Candlestick Cover
Schooner Bay Co. 3-3/4" Pewter Plated Candlestick Holder, Antique Style, Colonial, Primitive, Dining Room, Living Room, Decor

The Schooner Bay Candlestick Holder stands at 3-3/4 inches tall, making it an ideal accent piece for various settings in your home. Crafted from pewter-plated solid brass, it combines durability with an attractive antique style. The base, measuring 3 inches in diameter, offers stability, ensuring your candles are secure. This holder is perfect for enhancing the ambiance in your living room, dining room, or even your entryway. You can place it on a mantle or table to create a warm, inviting atmosphere for gatherings or quiet evenings at home.

What We Like
Durable pewter-plated brass
Sturdy base for stability
Versatile decorative piece
Antique style enhances decor
#TOP 3

DANFORTH Autumn Leaves Candleholder

78-029-2740
Pewter
DANFORTH Autumn Leaves Candleholder Cover
DANFORTH - Autumn Leaves Candleholder - Pewter - Product Measures: 3 3/4 Inches x 3 1/8 Inches x1 1/2 Inches Tall - Handcrafted - Made in USA - Sold Individually

The DANFORTH Autumn Leaves Candleholder is a handcrafted pewter candle holder with intricate maple leaf and acorn designs surrounding the base. It is a functional item that provides a sturdy base for lighted candles to keep them secure. This festive accessory is perfect for adding a touch of elegance to Thanksgiving or Christmas table decorations. It also makes for a great gift to share the holiday spirit with friends and family.

What We Like
Handcrafted with intricate designs
Functional and sturdy base for lighted candles
Festive accessory for holiday table decorations
Makes for a great gift
#TOP 4

Schooner Bay Pewter Candle Holder

Schooner Bay Co.
5775
Pewter Gray
Schooner Bay Pewter Candle Holder Cover
Schooner Bay Co. Pewter-Plated Chamberstick Candle Holder- Antique Vintage Style, Pewter Gray

The Schooner Bay Candle Holder offers a charming antique look, crafted from pewter-plated brass. This elegant design not only enhances your home decor but also fits standard taper candles, making it versatile for various settings. With a base diameter of 4 inches and a height of 3.5 inches, it provides stability while adding a touch of sophistication. The overall length of 4.75 inches, including the handle, allows for easy handling, making it convenient to move around your home or during special occasions. This candle holder is perfect for creating a warm and inviting atmosphere.

What We Like
Antique vintage appearance
Fits standard taper candles
Stable base design
Easy to handle
#TOP 5

Pewter Chamberstick by Brass & Silver Traditions

Brass & Silver Traditions
1204P

The Pewter Chamberstick by Brass & Silver offers a stylish way to illuminate your space. Made from solid brass and featuring a durable pewter finish, it adds elegance to any room. The lacquered surface ensures that you won’t have to worry about constant upkeep, keeping it looking polished effortlessly. Plus, the felted base protects your furniture from scratches, allowing you to place it anywhere without concern. This combination of form and function makes the Pewter Chamberstick an excellent choice for enhancing your home decor.

What We Like
Elegant design
Low maintenance
Furniture protection
Durable materials
#TOP 6

Schooner Bay Co. Pewter Chamberstick

Schooner Bay Co.
4031
Gray
Schooner Bay Co. Pewter Chamberstick Cover
Schooner Bay Co. 4-3/4" Pewter Plated Chamberstick, Antique Vintage Style, Colonial, Primitive, Dining Room, Living Room, Decor

The Schooner Bay Chamberstick features a stylish antiqued pewter finish that adds a vintage charm to any space. Made from solid brass, it ensures durability while maintaining an elegant appearance. Standing at 3-1/2 inches tall and with a 4-1/2 inch width including the handle, this piece is compact yet eye-catching. The convenient handle allows for easy carrying, making it simple for you to reposition it as needed, while the four small pedestal feet provide stability and protect your surfaces from scratches.

What We Like
Antique pewter finish
Durable solid brass
Compact size
Easy to carry
Stable pedestal feet
#TOP 7

Vagabond House Pewter Oak Leaf Candlestick

L101S
Silver
Vagabond House Pewter Oak Leaf Candlestick Cover
Vagabond House Pewter Metal Oak Leaf Candlestick Holder - 1 Taper 5 inch Tall

The Vagabond House Candlestick Holder is a beautifully crafted piece made from lead-free pewter. Its unique design brings a touch of nature and elegance to your table, making it perfect for any occasion. You can easily maintain it by hand washing, and if candle wax drips, simply soak it in hot water to clean it up effortlessly. This candlestick also comes in a lovely gift box, making it an ideal present for housewarmings or special events. With its delicate craftsmanship, it will surely impress your guests and enhance your home decor.

What We Like
Handcrafted lead-free pewter
Elegant nature-inspired design
Easy to clean
Gift-ready packaging
#TOP 8

Ptuiase Metal Pewter Candle Holder

PTUIASE
Pewter
H319
Ptuiase Metal Pewter Candle Holder Cover
Ptuiase Metal Pewter Candle Holder for Pillar Candles(10.6 inch Tall Candlestick Holders, for 1/2-1 inch Taper Candles Diameter Each)

Enhance your home décor with the elegant Ptuiase Metal Pewter Candle Holder. This premium metal candelabra can hold 3 pillar candles up to 1-inch diameter each, providing heavenly and romantic ambiance to any event. The candlestick holder is perfect for formal events, churches, temples, or as your everyday home centerpiece. It's constructed with state-of-the-art metal plating technology and comes in different colors including gold, silver, bronze, black, pewter, and copper. Gift it to your family member or friend for any special occasion.

What We Like
Premium metal construction
Can hold 3 pillar candles up to 1-inch diameter each
Comes in different colors
#TOP 9

CTW Home Collection Brass Candle Holders

840149
Brass
CTW Home Collection Brass Candle Holders Cover
Set of 2 Brass Taper Candle Holders, Centerpiece Table Decorative Vintage, Modern, Metal Candlestick Holders for Reception Candlelight Dinner Ornaments

The CTW Brass Candle Holders are a perfect blend of style and function. Their elegant design comes in a set of two, featuring a vintage yet modern brass finish that adds a touch of sophistication to any setting. With varying heights of 9 inches and 7.5 inches, they create a visually appealing centerpiece for your dining table or mantle. The sturdy construction ensures they remain stable, preventing accidental tipping from candle weight or drafts. Additionally, their taper design cleverly catches drips, protecting your surfaces from wax spills, making them practical for both everyday use and special occasions.

What We Like
Elegant design
Stable and sturdy
Protects furniture from wax
Versatile for various occasions
#TOP 10

Viscacha 3-Candle Candelabra

8541837739
Pewter
3arm
Viscacha 3-Candle Candelabra Cover
Viscacha 3-Candle Metal Candelabra Candlesticks Holder for Formal Events, Wedding, Church, Holiday Décor, Halloween – Taper Candle Holder Stand Centerpiece Elegant Decoration Piece for Table,Pewter

The Viscacha Candle Holder is an elegant addition to any formal event or home décor. It features a stunning design that can enhance the ambiance of weddings, holiday parties, or even everyday gatherings. With the capacity to hold three candles, you can create a warm and inviting atmosphere. The premium metal construction ensures durability while offering various color options to match your style. Weighing just under a pound, this candelabra is easy to place anywhere, making it a versatile centerpiece for any occasion.

What We Like
Elegant design
Holds three candles
Durable metal construction
Versatile for any occasion
Buying Guide Image

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Are pewter candlesticks valuable?

Auction estimate is $150-$300. North American Auction Company. American Pewter Candlesticks: These pewter candlesticks are unmarked but from the craftsmanship the dealer determined these to be from the mid-19th century.

2. What is the difference between candlesticks and candle holders?

As nouns the difference between candlestick and candleholder is that candlestick is a holder with a socket or spike for a candle while candleholder is a device for holding one or more lit candles.

3. What is an old candle holder called?

A candelabra (plural candelabras) or candelabrum (plural candelabra or candelabrums) is a candle holder with multiple arms.

Editor's Notes

During our pewter candlestick holder research, we found 24 pewter candlestick holder products and shortlisted 10 quality products. We collected and analyzed 16,299 customer reviews through our big data system to write the pewter candlestick holders list. We found that most customers choose pewter candlestick holders with an average price of $21.06.

The pewter candlestick holders are available for purchase. We have researched hundreds of brands and picked the top brands of pewter candlestick holders, including Northern Lights Candles, Schooner Bay Co., DANFORTH, Brass & Silver Traditions, Vagabond House. The seller of top 1 product has received honest feedback from 385 consumers with an average rating of 4.7.

Written by
Rebecca Cantu Avatar

Rebecca Cantu grew up in a family-owned retail store for home and kitchen products. She worked online and gave assistance to people to buy ideal products for their sweet home after graduating from Northwestern University with a marketing degree. She has been writing content for online shopping guides since 2011 with her professional knowledge and natural sensitivity of appliances.