Best Baseball First Baseman's Mitts of 2025

Jason Kiser Avatar
Jason Kiser
Last Updated: Jan 14, 2025

* We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

Baseball first baseman's mitts are an essential piece of equipment for any player who takes on the position. They are designed to be larger than traditional gloves, with a deeper pocket to make it easier for the fielder to catch and hold onto the ball. The mitts are made from high-quality leather, which is both durable and comfortable to wear. They feature padding to protect the player's hand from the impact of the ball when caught. With a range of sizes and styles available, there is a first baseman's mitt to suit players of all ages and skill levels.

At a Glance: Our Top Picks

Rawlings Encore 12" First Base Glove Cover #TOP 1
Rawlings Encore 12" First Base Glove
ftb score rating icon 9.9
Rawlings R9 Series Baseball First Base Mitt Cover #TOP 2
Rawlings R9 Series Baseball First Base Mitt
ftb score rating icon 9.8
Wilson A1000 1623 First Base Mitt Cover #TOP 3
Wilson A1000 1623 First Base Mitt
ftb score rating icon 9.6

Top 10 Baseball First Baseman's Mitts

#TOP 1

Rawlings Encore 12" First Base Glove

ECFBM-10B-3/0
Black - H Web - RHT
12" | First Base
Rawlings Encore 12" First Base Glove Cover
Rawlings | ENCORE Baseball First Base Glove | Right Hand Throw | 12" - Pro H-Web

The Rawlings Encore First Base Glove is designed specifically for young players aged 8 to 14, offering a competitive edge on the field. Its unique Mod Pro H Web construction enhances your ability to catch grounders and secure throws at first base. The glove features an adjustable hand opening, allowing you to customize the fit for maximum comfort. Additionally, it has a blend of factory and player break-in, which speeds up the process while maintaining its shape. With its deep pocket, this glove ensures better ball retention, helping you make those crucial plays with confidence.

What We Like
Great quality for the price
Easy to break in
Well constructed and durable
Suitable for young players
What We Don't Like
Initial break-in can take time
#TOP 2

Rawlings R9 Series Baseball First Base Mitt

R9FM18BG-3/0
12.5" | First Base
Rawlings R9 Series Baseball First Base Mitt Cover
Rawlings | R9 Baseball First Base Mitt | 12.5" |Modified Pro H Web | Right Hand Throw

The Rawlings R9 Series Baseball First Base Mitt is designed for select youth baseball players aged 8-14. It features a soft, durable all-leather shell that is game-ready and provides impact protection with a reinforced palm pad and padded thumb loop. It is a right hand throw glove to be worn on the left hand and requires a break-in of 80% factory and 20% player.

What We Like
Good quality materials
Durable and long-lasting
Easy break-in process
Comfortable fit
Great value for money
What We Don't Like
Limited padding in certain areas
#TOP 3

Wilson A1000 1623 First Base Mitt

Wilson A1000 1623 First Base Mitt Cover
Wilson 2024 A1000 1623 13” Baseball First Base Mitt - Left Hand Throw, Black/Cool Blue/Flamingo Pink

The Wilson A1000 Mitt is designed to enhance your performance on the field. Its rolled dual welting not only improves support but also helps maintain the glove's shape over time, so you can rely on it game after game. The DriLex wrist lining ensures your hand stays dry and comfortable, allowing you to focus on the game without distractions. Made from full grain leather, this mitt is ready to use right out of the box, offering a soft feel that molds to your hand without the need for extensive break-in. Handcrafted in the Wilson Pro Stock Factory, you can trust the quality and attention to detail in every glove.

What We Like
Enhanced glove support
Comfortable, dry fit
Game-ready leather
High-quality craftsmanship
#TOP 4

Rawlings R9 CONTOUR Baseball Glove

R9FMU-17BT-0/3
12" | First Base
Rawlings R9 CONTOUR Baseball Glove Cover
Rawlings | R9 CONTOUR Baseball Glove | 12" | Modified Pro H-Web | Left Hand Throw

The Rawlings R9 Contour Glove is a top choice for baseball players. Its game-ready all-leather shell allows you to start playing immediately. With pro patterns trusted by MLB stars, you can feel like a pro on the field. The reinforced palm pad and padded thumb loop provide impact protection for your hand. Additionally, the padded fingerback lining ensures a soft and comfortable fit. The Contour fit is specially designed for smaller hands, giving you more control and a better feel while playing.

What We Like
Game-ready all-leather shell
Pro patterns like MLB stars
Impact protection with reinforced palm
#TOP 5

Mizuno GXF50PB4 MVP Prime Baseball First Base Mitt

313061.R902.09.1250
Black 1st Base Mitt
12.5 Inch
Mizuno GXF50PB4 MVP Prime Baseball First Base Mitt Cover
Mizuno GXF50PB4 MVP Prime Baseball First Base Mitt 12.5", 1st Base, Right Hand Throw

The Mizuno GXF50PB4 MVP Prime Baseball First Base Mitt is a 12.5" glove designed for right-handed throwers. It features Bio Soft Leather for a perfect balance of oil and softness, Professional Level Lace, and an outlined, embroidered logo for a rich, premium look. It is suitable for adult players and provides excellent protection for the pointer finger. However, some customers have reported that the pocket is not deep enough for first base and that the stitching has ripped after one game.

What We Like
Excellent durability
Feels high-quality
Easy to break in
Great for casual play
Good fit and comfort
What We Don't Like
No palm padding
Requires breaking in
#TOP 6

Rawlings Heart of The Hide Glove

PRODCTGBB (RHT)
13"'
Rawlings Heart of The Hide Glove Cover
Rawlings | Heart of The Hide Baseball First Base Glove | Right Hand Throw | 13" - Single Post Double Bar Web | Color Sync 8.0 - Brown/Black/Gold

The Rawlings Heart of Hide is designed for serious players who value both style and performance. Its ColorSync series combines aesthetics with functionality, ensuring you look good while playing at your best. Made from premium steerhide leather, this glove offers exceptional durability and a great feel, enhancing your game. You'll appreciate the padded thumb sleeve and soft cowhide lining, which provide a custom fit for maximum comfort during play. With a break-in ratio of 40% factory and 60% player, this glove molds to your hand over time, improving your overall experience on the field.

What We Like
High-quality materials
Easy break-in process
Stylish design
Great for multiple positions
Compliments on the field
What We Don't Like
Stiff at first
Returned for different size
#TOP 7

SSK Z5 Craftsman Baseball Mitt

SSK
Camel
SSK Z5 Craftsman Baseball Mitt Cover
SSK Z5 Craftsman Baseball First Base Mitt – 12” – 12.25” – 12.5” – 13" – Right & Left Hand Throw (Camel, 13" - Right Hand Throw)

The SSK Z5 Mitt is designed for baseball players seeking a top-quality first base glove. Made from premium cowhide leather, it feels soft and is easy to shape, allowing you to quickly adapt it to your style. With its game-ready feature, you can start using the glove right out of the box, minimizing the break-in period. The innovative Dimple Sensor Technology enhances your grip on the ball, making catches and transfers smoother. Additionally, the top grain leather lacing ensures that the mitt is durable and strong, providing long-lasting performance on the field.

What We Like
Soft, easy-to-shape leather
Minimal break-in required
Enhanced grip technology
Durable leather lacing
What We Don't Like
Small size for some players
Needs some breaking in
#TOP 8

Marucci Ascension M Type 37S1 12.50 First Base MITT RHT

015MC112 125 CMWH
Standard
FIRST BASE
Marucci Ascension M Type 37S1 12.50 First Base MITT RHT Cover
Marucci - Ascension M Type 37S1 12.50 First Base MITT RHT (MFG2AS37S1-CM/W-RH)

The Marucci Ascension First Base Mitt is a top-notch baseball mitt designed specifically for first basemen. Made with a full-grain cowhide leather shell, this mitt offers durability and long-lasting performance. The supple leather palm lining with added cushioning provides a comfortable fit and excellent shock absorption. The tapered hand stall sizing ensures an ideal fit for players of different hand sizes. The smooth microfiber wrist lining and finger lining enhance comfort and reduce irritation during long games. With professional-grade rawhide laces, this mitt is built to withstand the rigors of intense play. The Marucci Ascension First Base Mitt is a reliable and high-quality choice for first basemen looking for a mitt that offers both performance and comfort.

What We Like
Timely delivery
High quality
Suitable for sports
What We Don't Like
Durability concerns
#TOP 9

Wilson A2000 1679SS 12.5” Baseball First Base Mitt

WBW100979125
Black/Blonde
12.5"
Wilson A2000 1679SS 12.5” Baseball First Base Mitt Cover
WILSON 2023 A2000® 1679SS 12.5” Baseball First Base Mitt - Right Hand Throw

The 2023 Wilson A2000 1679SS 12.5” Baseball First Base Mitt is designed with Pro Stock Leather for its rugged durability and unmatched feel. It also features SuperSkin, a microfiber material that's half the weight of Pro Stock Leather, but twice as durable. The Comfort Pro Fit liner has a richer, softer feel against your hand, while the Flat Finger Binding gives players who prefer to play with a finger outside the glove greater comfort and control. With multiple eye-catching colors in the signature Wilson logos, this glove offers a modern appearance.

What We Like
Easy to break in
Great material
Durable and long-lasting
Good for first base
What We Don't Like
Expensive
May take longer to break in
#TOP 10

Wilson A2000 1679 First Base Mitt

WBW102097125
Blonde/Black
First Base - 12.5"
Wilson A2000 1679 First Base Mitt Cover
Wilson 2024 Baseball Classics Series A2000 1679 12.5” Baseball First Base Mitt - Right Hand Throw, Blonde/Black

The Wilson A2000 Mitt is designed for optimal performance on the field. Made from Pro Stock Leather, it offers exceptional durability and a comfortable feel, ensuring you can play your best. The Comfort Pro Fit features a softer liner that enhances comfort, while the innovative Comfort Sleeve provides a snug fit around the wrist. Additionally, the Rolled Dual Welting adds support, helping your mitt maintain its shape over time. With Flat Finger Binding, you can enjoy better control and comfort, especially if you prefer playing with your finger outside the glove.

What We Like
Durable Pro Stock Leather
Comfortable wrist fit
Shape retention
Enhanced finger control
What We Don't Like
Incorrect color description
Lack of fit information
Buying Guide Image

Tips for Choosing the Baseball First Baseman's Mitts

Introduction

First baseman's mitts are an integral part of a baseball player's equipment, and choosing the right one can greatly affect a player's performance on the field. A first baseman's mitt is larger and more heavily padded than other gloves, allowing the player to catch and field the ball with ease. In this article, we will discuss the factors to consider when choosing a first baseman's mitt, as well as some of the top brands and models available on the market.

Size and Fit

One of the most important factors to consider when choosing a first baseman's mitt is the size and fit. The mitt should be large enough to easily catch and field the ball, but not so large that it becomes unwieldy or causes the player to lose control. To determine the right size, measure the distance from the tip of the player's middle finger to the base of the palm. The mitt should be about an inch longer than this measurement to ensure a comfortable fit.

Material and Construction

Another important factor to consider is the material and construction of the mitt. High-quality first baseman's mitts are typically made from leather, which is durable and provides a good level of grip. However, some players may prefer a synthetic material, which is often lighter and easier to break in.

The construction of the mitt is also important. A well-constructed mitt will have reinforced stitching and padding, as well as a deep pocket to easily catch and field the ball. The wrist strap should also be adjustable to ensure a secure fit.

Brand and Model

There are many different brands and models of first baseman's mitts available on the market, each with its own unique features and benefits. Some of the top brands include Rawlings, Wilson, and Mizuno.

The Rawlings Heart of the Hide first baseman's mitt, for example, is made from premium steer hide leather and features a deep pocket and adjustable wrist strap for a comfortable and secure fit. The Wilson A2000 first baseman's mitt, on the other hand, is made from Pro Stock leather and has a reinforced single post web design for added durability. The Mizuno MVP Prime first baseman's mitt is made from full grain leather and has a comfortable, hand-based pattern for a snug and secure fit.

Conclusion

In conclusion, choosing the right first baseman's mitt can greatly affect a player's performance on the field. When shopping for a mitt, be sure to consider the size and fit, material and construction, and brand and model. By taking the time to research and choose the right mitt, players can ensure that they have the right equipment to excel on the field.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Why is a first baseman's glove shaped the way it is?

A first baseman's glove is designed with a longer length and a solid, curved edge. This shape makes it easier for the player to scoop wild throws and stop ground balls down the line. The larger surface area of the mitt also provides a larger target for infielders to throw to.

2. Can a catcher use a first baseman's mitt?

No, catchers are required to use a specific catcher's mitt, not a first baseman's mitt or fielder's glove. The catcher's mitt is designed to provide proper hand protection and is regulated by baseball rules.

3. Can you use a first baseman's glove in the field?

No, it is not allowed to use a first baseman's glove when playing in the outfield. The design features of a first baseman's glove, such as the open web, strong finger part, and deep pocket, are specifically suited for the needs of a first baseman in catching and fielding the ball.

4. Why do baseball players put one finger outside their glove?

Some players, particularly catchers and infielders, choose to keep their index finger outside the glove. This provides an extra layer of protection between the ball and their finger, which is positioned inside the glove where the ball often makes contact.

5. Why are so many first basemen left-handed?

Left-handed first basemen have an advantage when attempting to pick off baserunners at first. They can catch and tag in one motion, saving time compared to right-handed first basemen who have to sweep their glove across their body. This gives left-handed first basemen a slight edge in applying the tag faster.

6. Can a first baseman use the orange bag?

No, the first baseman uses the white bag inside the foul line, while the baserunner uses the orange bag outside the foul line. This arrangement helps minimize collisions between the first baseman and the runner. If runners are taking extra bases on a hit, they use the inside base.

7. What does a first baseman need?

A first baseman needs several skills to excel in the position. The most important skill is the ability to catch the ball, as inaccurate throws to first base are common. Additionally, being tall, a decent fielder, and a good hitter can also be advantageous for a first baseman.

Editor's Notes

During our baseball first baseman's mitt research, we found 24 baseball first baseman's mitt products and shortlisted 10 quality products. We collected and analyzed 7,596 customer reviews through our big data system to write the baseball first baseman's mitts list. We found that most customers choose baseball first baseman's mitts with an average price of $185.47.

The baseball first baseman's mitts are available for purchase. We have researched hundreds of brands and picked the top brands of baseball first baseman's mitts, including Rawlings, WILSON, Mizuno, SSK, Marucci. The seller of top 1 product has received honest feedback from 317 consumers with an average rating of 4.9.

Written by
Jason Kiser Avatar

Jason Kiser is an editor who lives in California, he previously worked in a travel agency for ten years, which enabled him to travel a number of interesting countries and experience several different cultures along the way. His range of job and travel experiences grant him expertise in hiking, camping, outdoors and fitness.

Baseball First Baseman's Mitts Comparison Table

#TOP1
#TOP2
#TOP3
#TOP4
#TOP5
#TOP6
#TOP7
#TOP8
#TOP9
#TOP10
Brand Rawlings Rawlings WILSON Rawlings Mizuno Rawlings SSK Marucci WILSON WILSON
Size 12" First Base 12.5" First Base 13" 12" First Base 12.5 Inch 13"' 13" - Right Hand Throw FIRST BASE - First Base - 12.5"
Material Leather Leather Leather Leather Leather Leather Leather Wood - Pro Stock Leather
Color Black - H Web - RHT Modified Pro H-Web Black / Gold Black/Cool Blue/Flamingo Pink Contour Fit - Modified Pro H Web Black / Tan Black 1st Base Mitt 13" - Single Post Double Bar Web - Brown/Black/Gold Camel Standard - Blonde/Black
Hand Orientation Right Hand Throw Right Hand Throw Left Hand Throw Left Hand Throw Right Hand Throw Right Hand Throw Right Hand Throw - - Right Hand Throw
Glove Type First Base First Base First Base First Base First Base First Base Outfield - - First Base
Age Range (Description) Youth youth/boy/men Adult Youth Adult Adult Adult - - Adult
Lining Description Leather Leather Full Grain Leather Leather Leather Leather Leather - - DriLex Wrist Lining
Year 2022 2021 2024 2019 2019 2024 2025 - - 2024
FTB Score
ftb score rating icon 9.9
ftb score rating icon 9.8
ftb score rating icon 9.6
ftb score rating icon 9.6
ftb score rating icon 9.4
ftb score rating icon 9.3
ftb score rating icon 9.2
ftb score rating icon 9.0
ftb score rating icon 9.0
ftb score rating icon 9.0
Where to Buy