Best Baseball Catcher's Mitts of 2026

"When my Rawlings Player Preferred Catcher's Mitt showed up, I was blown away by how game-ready it felt immediately—almost no break-in needed, which is rare. After catching more than 200 pitches, the glove felt like a natural extension of my hand. I’ve used premium brands before, and honestly, this mitt matches them in comfort and performance. Based on Rawlings’ track record, I’m confident it’ll hold up over time. Outstanding value for professional-level quality."

"I picked up the Rawlings Player Preferred glove for casual softball games, and it’s been a reliable, affordable choice. The glove was soft and nearly broken-in out of the box—just a bit of quick shaping and it was field-ready. The leather is solid for the price, and the padding keeps it comfortable, even during long sessions. For weekend players or anyone needing a backup glove, this is a great fit."

"I bought two of these Rawlings gloves for myself and my son. Breaking them in was incredibly easy, and the quality feels genuinely good. We play in different leagues, but the gloves work well for both youth and adult games. I’m really happy with this purchase."

"I got this glove for my 3-year-old for T-ball, and it's a perfect fit with some room to grow. While it was a bit firm at first, after some use and breaking in, it became much more comfortable for his small hands. Love the stylish look, especially the white color!"

"This glove was exactly what I needed for my 5-year-old left-handed daughter. The adjustable laces made it easy to fit her hand, and it arrived already softened, which was a huge plus. Lightweight, beautiful colors, and very well-made. I highly recommend it for little kids. Great price, too!"

"The mitt has held up so well for my 4-year-old son across several seasons. No signs of wear even after lots of use. The design is adorable, and I’m confident he’ll outgrow it before it wears out. Definitely worth the price for a few years of play!"

"I've been using Rawlings gloves for years, and this Sandlot model really impressed me with its top-notch leather quality and durability. It felt pretty comfortable right away, and after a short break-in, it shaped perfectly to my hand. The glove's classic look and solid construction give me confidence it'll last for many seasons."

"As someone who plays both competitively and casually, I found the Sandlot glove's vintage aesthetic and deep pocket to be outstanding. The craftsmanship is excellent, and after using a bit of mink oil and working the leather, it became incredibly comfortable. It's now my go-to glove for both practice and games."

"I needed a quality glove for my son, and this was a great choice. Fits perfectly, looks great, and is well made. The glove did take some time to break in, but once it was ready, it performed just as I hoped."

"I needed a replacement glove quickly to help coach my son's Little League team, and this Rawlings Renegade fit the bill perfectly. Right away, it was comfortable to close, and after a quick break-in with a mallet and some wrapping, it was game-ready in just a couple of practices. For the price, the value is unbeatable!"

"When my son started baseball, I wanted a new glove without spending too much. The quality of this glove really surprised me for the cost—leather where it really matters, with a sturdy, adjustable thumb loop. It's a little stiff at first but totally usable right out of the box. Perfect for teaching my son and I could even see myself using it in adult games."

"This was my first baseball glove at age 30, and I’m really happy with it. The glove is soft, comfortable, and feels like a great starter option. Even though I ordered a 12-inch and got a 12.5, it still works perfectly for just playing catch."

"I’m really happy with this glove—it was so easy to break in, and my child found it comfortable and lightweight right away. The leather feels sturdy and has held up through lots of games and practices. For the price, it’s honestly a great value!"

"After getting this glove for my young beginner, I was impressed by how soft and high-quality the leather feels. It didn’t take long at all to break in, and the fit is just right for small hands. My kid gained confidence quickly, and it’s been perfect for learning the basics."

"I’ve played and coached baseball for years, and I can say this is a solid, well-made youth glove. The velcro strap keeps it stable and the web design is excellent. My 8-year-old even used it in a game the first day."

"Buying this glove for my son was a fantastic decision. It fit him perfectly and started breaking in almost right away after a little oil and wrapping. For the price, the quality is impressive. I’d definitely recommend it to anyone looking for an affordable, well-made baseball glove."

"After trying out several gloves, this one became my favorite. It needed barely any break-in—one practice and it was ready. The durability and comfort are top-notch for softball, and I’m sure it’ll last a long time. I’m seriously happy with this purchase and would buy it again, though I probably won’t need to!"

"We got this mitt for our child starting baseball, and it made a huge difference. It’s lightweight, super easy for small hands to open and close, and the deep pocket helps them actually catch the ball. Best part: no long break-in process—just start playing! My child’s confidence soared, and I’d buy this again in a heartbeat. Highly recommend for young players."

"I tried several R9 gloves made after 2025 and noticed significant differences in quality and feel. The one I kept had a heavier weight and noticeably better leather, making it feel more durable. Break-in took just a few days, and the glove is comfortable and flexible without being floppy. I think it's a solid choice for a secondary or casual glove."

"For the price, I don't think you can beat the Rawlings R9 Series glove. The leather is excellent quality, and it was almost ready to use straight out of the box. I love the modern yet classic appearance. This glove really impressed me for the money."

"I bought this glove for my son, and he absolutely loves it. It’s beautiful, well-made, and feels like a premium product. The break-in was quick, and it’s already comfortable and durable for regular play."

"I use this for softball, and after switching to three fingers in the pinky slot, I needed more palm protection. This glove is comfortable and provides just enough extra padding to keep my hand safe from hard hits."

"My son wears this under his catcher's mitt for added palm support. It fits well, is very durable, and has made catching much more comfortable for him. I would definitely recommend this to anyone looking for extra padding."

"Our 13-year-old just started catching and used to complain about the sting from pitches. Since getting this, he’s much happier and no longer mentions hand pain. Highly recommend for new catchers!"

"I bought this catcher's mitt for my 8-year-old, and I'm impressed with the quality and how easy it is to break in. Definitely worth it for young players."

"My son is thrilled with this mitt. It was simple to break in, and for the price, I couldn't ask for more."

"I love this glove! It's beautifully made and my grandson absolutely loves it. The quality and craftsmanship really stand out—definitely a great investment."