Best Baseball Mitt Padding of 2025

Jason Kiser Avatar
Jason Kiser
Last Updated: Jan 6, 2025

* We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

Baseball mitt padding is an essential accessory for any serious player looking to enhance their performance on the field. Designed to provide optimal comfort and protection, these pads are crafted from high-quality materials that offer a cushioned feel without compromising on flexibility. The padding is strategically placed in key areas of the glove to absorb the impact of fastballs, reducing the risk of hand injuries and ensuring a secure grip. With its durable construction and easy installation, baseball mitt padding is a must-have for players seeking an extra layer of defense and confidence in every catch.

At a Glance: Our Top Picks

Rawlings Palm Pad Cover #TOP 1
Rawlings Palm Pad
ftb score rating icon 9.9
All-Star S7 Finger Sleeve Cover #TOP 2
All-Star S7 Finger Sleeve
ftb score rating icon 9.8
All-Star CG5001A Left Hand Glove Cover #TOP 3
All-Star CG5001A Left Hand Glove
ftb score rating icon 9.6

Top 10 Baseball Mitt Padding

#TOP 1

Rawlings Palm Pad

Blue
One Size
Rawlings Palm Pad Cover
Rawlings | Palm Pad | Baseball/Softball

The Rawlings Palm Pad is designed to enhance your baseball or softball experience. With shock-absorbing gel, this pad helps reduce the impact of the ball, protecting your hand during play. Its low-profile design allows it to fit seamlessly inside any fielding glove, ensuring comfort and convenience. Whether you throw with your left or right hand, this one-size-fits-all solution caters to all players, making it an essential accessory for anyone serious about the game.

What We Like
Shock absorption for hand protection
Low-profile for glove compatibility
Universal fit for all players
Suitable for both baseball and softball
#TOP 2

All-Star S7 Finger Sleeve

GS4000-RH
Multi
ADULT
All-Star S7 Finger Sleeve Cover
All Star S7 Protective Finger Sleeve

The All-Star Finger Sleeve offers top-notch protection for your fingers while playing baseball or softball. Its comfortable fit ensures that you can move freely, helping you focus on your game without distractions. The streamlined design fits snugly, reducing the risk of injury during catches. You’ll appreciate how this sleeve enhances your grip, making catching easier and more secure. With this gear, you can enjoy peace of mind knowing your fingers are well protected, allowing you to play your best.

What We Like
High-quality protection
Comfortable fit
Streamlined design
Enhanced grip
#TOP 3

All-Star CG5001A Left Hand Glove

White
Youth Medium
All-Star CG5001A Left Hand Glove Cover
All-Star CG5001A Protective Inner Glove (Left Hand (Glove Goes On Left Hand), Youth Medium)

The All-Star Inner Glove is designed to enhance your catching and fielding experience. Its lightweight D3o palm padding absorbs shock, protecting your hand from nerve damage during repeated impacts. This feature is especially beneficial for young players who may be prone to injury. The breathable fabric on the back keeps your hand cool, ensuring comfort during long games. Additionally, the glove's fingers are equipped with a tacky surface that provides extra grip, helping you securely hold onto the ball. This combination of comfort and protection makes the All-Star Inner Glove a great choice for youth players.

What We Like
Shock-absorbing palm padding
Breathable back fabric
Tacky grip on fingers
Lightweight design
#TOP 4

Hot Glove Sting Pad Pro Hand Protection Bundle

4336347762
Hot Glove Sting Pad Pro Hand Protection Bundle Cover
Hot Glove Baseball Sting Pad Pro Hand Protection 3 Piece Bundle with Finger Wrap

This bundle includes 1 Sting Pad, 1 Sting Pad PRO, and 1 Finger Wrap. The STING PAD gel cushion and larger gel pad absorb ball impact and protect hands from bruising. The FINGER WRAP is made of unique cotton mesh that sticks to itself and not to fingers, protecting skin from abrasion, cuts, and splits. The set is great for kids and adults, and can be used on either hand.

What We Like
Protects hands from bruising and absorbs ball impact
Fits comfortably on either hand
FINGER WRAP protects skin from abrasion, cuts, and splits
#TOP 5

Hot Glove Sting Pad Hand Protector

HSP-1
Blue
Hot Glove Sting Pad Hand Protector Cover
Hot Glove Sting Pad Hand Protector, Blue

The Hot Glove Sting Pad Hand Protector is a shock-absorbing gel pad that cushions your hand and absorbs the impact of the ball. It is thin enough to fit inside your glove comfortably and slides over your index or middle finger to fit snugly against your palm. It promotes healing and helps prevent further injury. The protective pad measures 2.5" wide x 1.25" high x 6mm thick, and it can fit either your left or right hand. This product is ideal for baseball and softball mitt padding.

What We Like
Shock-absorbing gel that cushions your hand and absorbs the impact of the ball
Thin enough to fit inside your glove comfortably without getting in the way
Slides over index or middle finger and fits snugly against your palm
#TOP 6

SYH Athletics Catcher's Thumb Guard

SYH Athletics
Black
Large
SYH Athletics Catcher's Thumb Guard Cover
Catcher's Thumb Guard for Baseball & Softball in 2 Sizes (Adult/Youth) - Silicone Protective Shield Catching Training Aid Glove Padding Accessory Gear Protector for Palm Hand Injury & Sting Prevention

The SYH Thumb Guard offers excellent protection for your thumb, ensuring you stay safe during practice and games. With its comprehensive coverage, this guard absorbs shocks from hard pitches, helping to reduce pain and numbness that can occur from regular glove use. Made from high-quality silicone, it provides durability and comfort, allowing for flexibility while you play. This guard is designed for both baseball and softball catchers, giving you the support you need to perform at your best. Plus, it comes in two sizes, so you can find the perfect fit for added comfort and protection.

What We Like
Comprehensive thumb protection
Shock absorption for pain relief
Durable silicone material
Compatible with baseball and softball
Available in two sizes
#TOP 7

All-Star YG-2 Small 3.5 Inch

YG-24.5
Multi
SMALL 3.5"
All-Star YG-2 Small 3.5 Inch Cover
All-Star Pro Lace on Wrist Guard W/Strap - Small, 3.5" - Adult Baseball Mitt Accessory

The All-Star YG-2 Wrist Guard is a top-quality baseball and softball catching equipment that offers excellent protection and comfort. With its fitted and streamlined design, it ensures a secure fit and allows for unrestricted movement. The wrist guard is designed to provide maximum protection to the wrist area, reducing the risk of injuries during intense gameplay. It is made with high-quality materials that are durable and long-lasting. The All-Star YG-2 Wrist Guard is a must-have for any baseball or softball player who wants to enhance their performance and stay protected on the field.

What We Like
Top quality
Protective
Comfortable
#TOP 8

Palmgard Youth Xtra Protective Glove

PYE201-XS
X-Small
Palmgard Youth Xtra Protective Glove Cover
Palmgard Black Youth Xtra Protective Inner Glove

The Palmgard Youth Glove is designed to enhance your game experience. With added padding on the middle finger and thumb, it reduces the risk of bruises and minimizes the sting from impacts, keeping you comfortable during play. This glove is particularly beneficial in cold weather, ensuring your hands stay warm while you bat or field. Made with Astra-Soft cabretta leather and flexible spandex, it provides a snug fit that allows for easy movement, giving you confidence in your grip and performance on the field.

What We Like
Extra padding for protection
Warmth in cold weather
Flexible, snug fit
Durable leather material
#TOP 9

Unique Sports Gel Cushion Pads

Unique Sports Gel Cushion Pads Cover
Unique Sports Hot Glove Sting Pad Shock Absorbing Gel Cushion (Pack of 2)

The Unique Sports Gel Pads offer exceptional comfort and protection for your baseball mitt. With their shock-absorbing gel, these pads effectively reduce impact, allowing you to focus on your game without discomfort. Once you wear the glove, you won't even notice the pads, making them easy to use. They are designed to fit both left and right-handed players, so everyone can benefit from this innovative padding. Whether you are practicing or playing a match, these gel pads enhance your performance by providing extra cushioning where you need it most.

What We Like
Shock absorption
Comfortable fit
Universal design
#TOP 10

Hot Glove Sting Pad Pro Hand Protector

HSP-P
Multi
One Size
Hot Glove Sting Pad Pro Hand Protector Cover
Hot Glove Baseball Unisex Adults Sting Pad Pro Hand Protector Fits Left or Right Hand Multi, One Size

The Hot Glove Sting Pad Pro Hand Protector is designed to protect your hand from the impact of the ball. Made of shock absorbing gel, it cushions and dissipates the impact, promoting healing and preventing further injury. The protective pad is thin enough to fit in your glove and slides over your index or middle finger, fitting snugly against the palm. It measures 3.5" wide x 2.5" high x 6mm thick and can be used for baseball, softball, or hockey.

What We Like
Shock absorbing gel cushions and dissipates impact
Thin design fits in glove and doesn't interfere
Promotes healing and prevents further injury
Buying Guide Image

Factors to Consider when Choosing Baseball Mitt Padding

Material

The material used for the padding in a baseball mitt is crucial for protection and comfort. Look for mitts with high-quality padding materials, such as memory foam, gel, or shock-absorbing foam. These materials provide excellent cushioning and help reduce the impact of catching a ball.

Thickness

Consider the thickness of the padding when choosing a baseball mitt. Thicker padding offers better protection against hard-hit balls, but it may also affect the feel and flexibility of the mitt. Strike a balance between thickness and flexibility to ensure both comfort and safety.

Durability

Baseball mitt padding should be durable enough to withstand regular use and the wear and tear of the game. Look for padding that maintains its shape and cushioning properties over time, even after repeated catches and impacts.

Fit and Comfort

Ensure that the padding in the baseball mitt provides a snug and comfortable fit. It should conform to the shape of your hand, allowing for easy movement and flexibility. Consider trying on different mitts to find one that feels comfortable and secure.

Performance

The padding should not hinder your performance on the field. Look for mitts with padding that allows for a good grip on the ball and easy ball release. It should enhance your catching abilities without compromising your fielding skills.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Can you add padding to a baseball glove?

Yes, it is possible to add padding to a baseball glove. Adding padding can provide additional protection for your hand and help tighten up loose leather in the palm of the glove. You may need to have a partial relace done to install new padding, which typically starts at around $15.

2. Why does a baseball catcher's mitt have more padding?

A baseball catcher's mitt has more padding to prolong the duration of the impact force from a baseball. The increased padding helps to spread out and absorb the impact, reducing the overall force exerted on the catcher's hand.

3. How many times should you oil a new baseball glove?

It is recommended to apply oil to a new baseball glove a couple to a few times throughout the season. Some players may choose to condition their glove only once a year. Additionally, it is advisable to apply oil one last time before storing the glove after the season for best storage results.

4. Can you use Vaseline to condition a baseball glove?

Yes, Vaseline can be used to condition a baseball glove. Vaseline contains mineral oils and moisturizers that effectively soften leather. It can also help seal and protect the glove from drying out in hot environments and exposure to dirt and dust.

5. Why do MLB players wear sliding mitts?

MLB players wear sliding mitts to provide crucial protection to their hands and fingers during slides. The extra padding in the sliding mitts helps absorb impact and reduces the risk of abrasions, cuts, and bruises caused by contact with the ground or bases, allowing players to slide with reduced risk of hand injuries.

6. Why do some baseball players wear an oven mitt?

Baseball players wear an oven mitt when sliding headfirst into bases to protect their hands and wrists. Sliding into a base can result in injuries to the fingers or wrists, and wearing an oven mitt provides an extra layer of protection against potential harm.

7. Why do baseball players put one finger outside their glove?

Some baseball players, especially catchers and infielders, keep their index finger outside the glove for added protection. By doing so, they create an additional layer of defense between the ball and their finger, which is positioned on the inside of the glove where the ball often makes contact.

Editor's Notes

During our baseball mitt padding research, we found 18 baseball mitt padding products and shortlisted 10 quality products. We collected and analyzed 8,121 customer reviews through our big data system to write the baseball mitt padding list. We found that most customers choose baseball mitt padding with an average price of $20.14.

The baseball mitt padding are available for purchase. We have researched hundreds of brands and picked the top brands of baseball mitt padding, including Rawlings, All-Star, Hot Glove, SYH Athletics, Palmgard. The seller of top 1 product has received honest feedback from 385 consumers with an average rating of 4.7.

Written by
Jason Kiser Avatar

Jason Kiser is an editor who lives in California, he previously worked in a travel agency for ten years, which enabled him to travel a number of interesting countries and experience several different cultures along the way. His range of job and travel experiences grant him expertise in hiking, camping, outdoors and fitness.