Steel City Collectibles’ eBay store is a useful place to shop a signed card or display jersey for someone whose favorite player you already know. The selection also stretches to older sealed card boxes. We’d buy a named collectible here before choosing a mystery product—but only after reading what the authentication covers and whether the photo represents the exact piece you’ll receive.
This is the steelcitycollectibles1 storefront, shipping our inspected items from McKeesport, Pennsylvania. Don’t substitute a similarly named seller or an eBay search page full of other dealers’ Steel City promotional cards.
A signed jersey can be the right gift, with one important distinction
The Joe Montana red custom jersey we checked was $149.95 before tax, with free shipping to our sample ZIP code, 10001. The seller described the autograph as Beckett-authenticated.
“Custom” matters. The description says this jersey isn’t made by or affiliated with a professional sports league or manufacturer, and doesn’t include team logos or tags. You’re buying a signed display collectible. If the recipient wants an officially licensed jersey to wear, we’d choose that instead.
The listing also had multiples available. Its FAQ says most memorabilia buyers receive a comparable piece rather than the exact photographed example, and that individual certificate numbers or photos aren’t provided for every available item. That makes this a poor fit if signature placement, a particular inscription, or the exact fabric details are the whole point of your purchase.
When it arrives, compare the item with the description and use the actual number on its certification label in Beckett’s verification tool. A photograph of another example’s sticker cannot verify the piece delivered to you.
The “10” on a signed card may grade the autograph
Steel City’s Frank Thomas 1990 Score #663 signed rookie card was $87.95 before tax. The title said PSA/DNA 10. The slab image supplied the more important detail: AUTO GRADE.

Detail from the actual seller photo. This 10 is an autograph grade; it does not establish a Gem Mint 10 grade for the underlying card.
The seller’s full description explicitly said the autograph was graded 10. That distinction can be easy to miss when scanning a marketplace’s short condition field. PSA explains that autograph grades assess the signature; its dual grading service assigns separate grades to the card and autograph.
We’d consider this for a Frank Thomas fan who wants a signed rookie card. We wouldn’t price it against unsigned PSA 10 cards or assume two separate grades. The listing also warned that trading cards at $250 or below might be filled from remaining stock rather than the exact pictured card. If you collect specific certification numbers or need exact centering, choose an explicitly exact-item listing instead.
Older sealed boxes give the store another reason to stay on your list
The 2021–22 Upper Deck AHL Hockey Hobby Box was $23.95 before tax, listed as new and factory sealed, with free US shipping in our check. That’s a different purchase from a current NHL hobby box: the league, season, players, and checklist are the point.

Seller product photo, used to identify the AHL product. AHL and NHL boxes aren’t interchangeable simply because both say Upper Deck Hockey.
For someone who follows minor-league teams or enjoys opening older product, this kind of shelf is more interesting than another chase for the newest release. For someone who wants one player’s autograph, a specific single is the more direct route. A sealed box doesn’t promise your chosen player—or an outcome worth what you paid.
Before buying, compare the same year and box format at Steel City’s own site. Don’t compare a blaster to a hobby box, or a single box to a case. Use the delivered total rather than a crossed-out reference price. Website shipping promotions and eBay shipping terms are separate.
Buyer accounts support shopping here, not skipping comparisons
A January 27, 2026 reply described receiving a well-packaged Barry Sanders signed rookie card. In the same discussion, a September 2024 buyer reported spending thousands without an issue. But an April 9, 2025 commenter described problems and slow customer service, and another repeat buyer in June praised shipping while criticizing pricing.
An older August 29, 2022 discussion included a signed-jersey buyer who said the item arrived as advertised with a certificate. Those posters didn’t clearly identify the checkout channel. Their accounts support the dealer’s real trading history; they don’t establish the service you’ll receive on an eBay order or show that today’s price is the lowest.
Returns differ even within this store
Our Montana jersey listing offered 30-day returns with buyer-paid return shipping. The Frank Thomas card and AHL box listings said no seller returns; both displayed a three-day after-delivery window for a not-as-described claim to be eligible for eBay Money Back Guarantee. Read the actual item’s policy before paying, then inspect delivery promptly.
The direct website’s terms call unopened card boxes, cases, and autographed memorabilia final sale. That is a website policy, not a reason to erase the different return offer shown on the eBay jersey listing. If a shipment looks damaged, the dealer’s damage guidance asks buyers to report it within 48 hours and avoid opening the carton if damage is suspected inside. Photograph the damage and contact the seller through your order.
Start with Steel City’s eBay store when you can name the player, item, and type of authentication you want. Go elsewhere when the exact photographed example is essential or you need a licensed jersey. Those distinctions matter more than the size of the storefront.
Sources and sample listings checked November 20, 2026. Prices and availability can change. FTB did not place an order or authenticate these items independently.