Secondipity's eBay shop is a useful place for US buyers who want Sony's premium headphones below the current new price and are comfortable buying refurbished. We'd start with its Certified Refurbished offers, where the specific listing includes an Allstate warranty. The catch is the size of the real saving: a discounted new pair can be close enough that we'd pay the difference.
Start at Secondipity's eBay store, then compare the complete model code and color with Sony's current price. “XM5” alone isn't enough: WH models are over-ear headphones; WF models are earbuds.
The XM5 deal is smaller than the original-price discount suggests
Our November 20, 2026 comparison found these US offers before sales tax:
| Exact headphones | Secondipity on eBay, refurbished | Sony US, new | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| WH-1000XM5, Silver | $152 | $198 | $46, about 23% |
| WH-1000XM6/G, Olive Gray | $269.99 | $348 | $78.01, about 22% |
Both eBay offers displayed Certified Refurbished condition, free US shipping, 30-day seller-paid returns, and two-year Allstate coverage. These are examples from two listings, not terms for everything Secondipity sells. Stock and prices can change between colors.
At that XM5 gap, we'd buy new if another $46 fits the budget. You avoid uncertainty about a previous owner's wear and the battery's history. If $160 is the ceiling, the refurbished Silver offer is a more realistic route to this model. The XM6's $78 gap gives refurbished a stronger case, particularly for someone who specifically wants that model and color.
This is why we wouldn't describe either offer as half off today's new price. A crossed-out launch price makes a poor shopping companion during a Sony sale.
Why choose its eBay checkout over Secondipity's website?
The seller's own Olive Gray XM6 page also showed $269.99. At the same sticker price, the eligible eBay listing has a meaningful channel advantage: its stated Allstate protection. Secondipity's Sony collection page describes refurbished products with a 90-day warranty. Don't carry the eBay plan across to a website order.
There are three separate things to keep straight:
- The seller and refurbishment: eBay identifies Secondipity as a Sony authorized seller on these offers. That doesn't establish that a Sony employee repaired your particular pair. Secondipity's refurbishment explanation says a manufacturer or another refurbisher may have performed the work.
- The initial return: use the eBay order's return process for the stated return window. A return is the practical answer to an unacceptable arrival, not a reason to wait for a later repair claim.
- The longer warranty: the two-year plan on these listings is serviced by Allstate. It isn't a two-year Sony factory warranty. eBay says the plan starts on purchase, is automatically registered, and excludes such things as accidental damage, cosmetic damage, and normal wear. Keep the receipt, listing link, and confirmation email. See the program's warranty terms.
Ask about the case before spending the saving

Seller listing photograph of the Olive Gray XM6. It identifies the model and folding construction; it is not a photograph of the unit you will receive or proof of included accessories. Source listing.
A case matters if the headphones are going in a work bag. The eBay XM5 description mentions the model's redesigned case but doesn't provide a clear, separate packing list. We'd ask Secondipity through eBay to confirm the carrying case, charging cable, and wired audio cable for the exact listing before paying.
Even the seller's direct XM6 product page needs careful reading: it shows “Case and cable” and then says package contents haven't been confirmed for that offer. That is a reason to get a written answer, not permission to assume the full retail accessory set. An extra case purchase could eat most of the XM5's $46 saving.
Buyer reports make the return window worth using
In a 2023 Reddit thread, buyers identified Secondipity as their source and described pristine-looking XM5s, but also a Bluetooth name left over from a previous setup. That's a useful reminder that excellent appearance doesn't make an item new. The thread's speculation about Sony selling new stock as refurbished isn't established evidence.
A different buyer report describes an invalid serial number during Sony registration after an eBay purchase. The post does not establish why registration failed. We'd take a registration problem to the seller promptly rather than treat registration alone as an authenticity verdict. These individual accounts don't tell us the seller's defect rate.
On arrival, we'd inspect the pads, headband, hinges, ports, and included pieces, then check charging, both channels, noise cancellation, and a call on the actual devices we use. Do that while a return is still straightforward. We have not purchased or tested these units.
The recommendation assumes US delivery and eligibility for the listed plan. Don't use a US forwarding address as a workaround for overseas delivery: eBay's Money Back Guarantee lists third-party forwarding as an exclusion. For a gift that must look factory fresh, or an XM5 buyer who can stretch to the current new price, we'd choose new. For a firm budget and an acceptable refurbished offer, Secondipity's eligible eBay listings give the saving a clearer support path.
Sources checked November 20, 2026 for the US market. Prices exclude tax; item condition, accessories, availability, shipping, returns, and coverage follow the selected offer.