MyPillow’s direct shop is worth considering when you want to compare its Classic and Premium pillows by size and fill level. The useful shopping feature is the choice of loft, plus clear published washing instructions. Choose the pillow you want to try before choosing a promotion, and include the cost of returning it in your budget.
Our recommendation is to start with one pillow or the smallest appropriate offer. Pillow comfort is personal, and a lower price per pillow does not help if you later need to send a whole bundle back.
Compare Classic and Premium sizes and loft options. Check the final offer and the cost of a comfort return before choosing a bundle.
Browse MyPillowSeparate pillow length from pillow height
Measure a pillowcase that you intend to keep using. Then decide what you dislike about your current pillow. Is the case too tight, does the pillow feel too tall, or does the filling move away from where you want it? Those are different questions, and buying a larger pillow answers only the first one.
The Standard Classic offer lists an 18.5-by-26-inch pillow in Medium. MyPillow’s FAQ describes two loft levels for Classic across the range, but an individual offer may present fewer choices. Use the options on the product you are actually ordering. If Medium is the only option shown, do not assume a low-loft pillow will arrive because you added a note.
The Premium pillow lists four loft levels and a two-inch gusset. Queen measures 18.5 by 28 inches and King 18.5 by 34 inches, including the gusset. That extra edge construction is part of the product design. It does not tell you which loft you will find comfortable.
Queen and King sizes with four listed loft levels and a two-inch gusset. Pick size and fill separately.
Compare Premium optionsIf you want to compare options systematically, keep the bed and pillowcase the same and change one thing at a time. Buying a new mattress topper, two new pillow types and a new case together makes it much harder to work out what you like.
Use the fill guide as a starting point
MyPillow’s FAQ identifies loft by the color of the print on the care tag. Yellow is the lower fill, black Medium, green more and blue the most. Save the selection shown on your order confirmation so you can compare it with the care tag when the pillow arrives. Loft and care FAQ
The same FAQ suggests going down a level if you currently use down or feather. Treat that as the brand’s fitting suggestion. Your existing pillow gives you another useful reference. Think about how it feels after you have been lying on it, rather than its height immediately after fluffing. If you like a pillow that can be opened so you can remove measured handfuls of fill, look for that feature explicitly when comparing other products.
This is also a reason to buy for each person separately. Two people sharing a bed may want the same case size and very different fill levels. A twin-pack offer is worth checking only after you have confirmed it lets you choose what both people need.
Read the care label before the first wash
Machine washing and drying are useful features of the Classic and Premium listings. The company’s FAQ gives specific instructions, including a regular cold or warm wash and heat for tumble drying, with no fabric softener or dryer balls. It gives different load-balancing guidance for front-loading and top-loading machines. Read the full instructions for your model and machine before you wash it. Care instructions
On arrival, check the seams and cover before using the pillow, and keep the order details. If there is a manufacturing problem, take clear photographs and ask support how to handle it before trying to repair it yourself. Follow the care label and keep that label attached while you are deciding whether to keep the purchase.
Work out the cost if the pillow does not suit you
MyPillow’s guarantee describes a 60-day money-back window from receipt, with shipping excluded and return costs paid by the customer. Its terms require a return authorization and say all items in a bundle, including bonus items, must be returned for full purchase credit. Read any product-specific terms as well.
For a plain pillow return in the contiguous 48 states, the terms list a $9.98 deduction plus applicable sales tax if you use MyPillow’s prepaid label. Check the current charge for your order and location before using it. Keep the return authorization, tracking receipt and a list of the items packed. The return window and the warranty cover different situations, so confirm which process applies to a comfort return or a fault.
MyPillow’s shop makes sense when you have a specific size and loft to try and are comfortable with those return costs. If you want to feel the filling before buying, or you need a different return arrangement, check a retailer’s exact listing and policy before choosing that channel.
US product specifications and policies reviewed November 20, 2026. Product photograph supplied by MyPillow. Cover is an editorial illustration based on the product imagery.