Best Vehicle Soft-Shell Carriers of 2025

"I want to clarify that I have NOT been compensated in any way for this review. I purchased this soft rooftop storage solution for a long trip with my friend and her kids. It exceeded my expectations! Despite the limited space in our SUV, we managed to fit so much in this carrier. I packed everything from luggage to toys and was shocked by how much room there still was. It’s incredibly durable; we experienced various rainstorms, and everything stayed completely dry. Five stars for quality and ease of use!"

"I am not a paid reviewer, and this is my first detailed review ever! This carrier was a fantastic investment. I meticulously organized my packing, using clear storage totes for stability, and it paid off. I drove over 1600 miles through challenging weather, and the bag held up beautifully. No rips or tears, just some dirt from travel. I highly recommend this product for anyone needing extra storage!"

"I was a bit anxious after reading some reviews, but after my trip, I found this roof bag to be easy to load. It held much more than I anticipated. During my 770-mile journey with some rain, everything arrived dry and secure."

"As a budget camper with an 05 Honda Accord, this roof bag was a lifesaver for our 2,500-mile wedding/honeymoon road trip. The thick waterproof vinyl and secure zippers kept everything intact through mountains and deserts. We managed to fit all our camping gear and still had room left!"

"We needed extra storage for our family trip, and this roof bag worked well. Adjusting the hooks took some time, especially on a taller vehicle. Despite some minor issues with loose straps flapping in the wind, the zippers held up well against rain, keeping our luggage dry."

"I bought this for traveling home in our SUV. The bag holds a lot, which I'm pleased with. It straps in easily, and it was simple to zip up after packing. It didn't rain during my trips, so I can't comment on the waterproof claim. Overall, it's a great value and packing solution for the cost."

"After a 1300-mile round trip, I can say this carrier held up great! We encountered three hours of rain with no issues at all. Despite not having a roof rack, it was easy to secure. I recommend using duct tape or something similar to keep the straps from flapping around."

"I used the rooftop carrier for a family vacation trip. The extra storage was fantastic, freeing up space inside the car for our 13-hour journey. Unfortunately, it rained heavily during our trip, and when we arrived, some of our items in the suitcase were wet. This was disappointing, as I expected better waterproofing."

"This was my first time using something like this and I was very impressed! It worked perfectly on my Jeep for our road trip. Very sturdy, fit a lot of stuff, and easy to install! I highly recommend this product."

"I drove 1,700 miles with this on my Toyota 4 Runner. I had a short plastic bin that fit perfectly inside. It didn't move an inch! I was a bit worried traveling alone, but it stayed secure when installed properly. I think the anti-slip mat might need improvement, but overall, it was worth the money!"

"I absolutely loved this cargo bag. I drove from Ontario to Nova Scotia and it held up without a single issue. Highly recommended!"

"Having used the RoofPax XXL 28 cft Car Rooftop Cargo Carrier Bag for two extensive road trips totaling over 80 hours, I can confidently say it has exceeded my expectations. The installation was straightforward, and the design with multiple heavy-duty straps ensured a secure fit on my vehicle. I was particularly impressed by its waterproof capabilities; even in heavy rain, my belongings were completely dry. The spacious interior easily accommodated all my luggage, making it perfect for family trips. Overall, the RoofPax carrier proved to be a reliable solution for transporting extra gear, significantly enhancing my travel experience."

"I can't contain my excitement about this rooftop cargo carrier bag! It has exceeded all my expectations and made our recent family road trip a breeze. The quality is top-notch, and the bag holds an enormous 23 cubic feet of cargo. Packing was a joy as everything fit effortlessly. We drove from Maryland to the Outer Banks under sunny skies, and the bag stayed put the entire way—didn't move an inch! On our return trip, despite a heavy downpour, everything was bone dry! This rooftop cargo carrier bag is a fantastic investment for anyone needing extra storage space without sacrificing convenience or peace of mind."

"We used this bag for a three-day road trip, and had zero drama! After a moderate rainstorm, the contents were dry and there was absolutely no shifting of the load. This is a high-quality, well-designed product. We took precautions by putting items that could be water-damaged into garbage bags, which made loading easier. The advantages compared to clam-shell units include being less expensive and having a larger capacity. In summary, it's a great solution for occasional use!"

"I got this to ride right behind the headache rack on my flatbed, and it is absolutely perfect for that. The bag is huge and fits in an unused space between my cab and truck camper. I couldn't be more pleased with the additional weatherproof storage. Nothing inside has gotten wet, and the included straps keep it in place."

"I tested this out on a road trip of several hundred miles. I'm quite pleased with its performance. The medium-grade plastic is waterproof, and the zipper is well-protected. The handles are strong enough to carry heavy cargo, and it comes with helpful tie downs and a lock. Overall, it's been great, although it's a bit hard to handle when it's cold."

"As a field tech constantly on the road, this Mockins cargo bag has been a fantastic addition. The size is impressive, and it holds a ton of equipment without issues. The 500D PVC material is heavy-duty, and the waterproof zipper keeps everything dry even in rainstorms. Setup was simple, and it stores easily when not in use. I highly recommend it for extra cargo space!"

"I used this bag on a week-long cross-country trip, and it was a breeze to attach and secure to my cargo hauler. No extra straps were needed to keep my gear secure. I didn't encounter any issues with rain, so I can't speak to its waterproof capabilities, but it seemed sturdy overall. I did notice a bit of trouble with the zipper around the corners, but it wasn't a major issue for me. Can't wait to travel with it again!"

"We purchased this around Christmas 2018 to create more space in our SUV for gifts and luggage. It held up beautifully during a cold, rainy trip, keeping everything completely dry inside. The zippers worked well, and the flap covering them was effective. No issues with wind or water leakage at all! I'm highly impressed with the quality and expect it to last a long time for us."

"This bag is a fantastic find! It fits two 18-gallon totes horizontally with room for more items. Stayed dry during wet travels and was easy to attach and detach from the carrier basket. Finally, my kids can help with loading and unloading, which is a huge plus! Eureka!"

"I recently purchased this rooftop cargo carrier bag for a long road trip, and it was a game-changer! The bag is spacious, easy to install, and incredibly sturdy. I fit everything I needed without crowding the car's interior, and it stayed in place throughout the trip — no shifting or leaks even in the rain. The high-quality, water-resistant material gave me peace of mind, and it folds down easily for storage when not in use. I highly recommend this carrier for anyone needing extra luggage space!"

"We moved from Arkansas to Florida with our cats in the car, so everything else had to go in the roof bag. I was genuinely impressed by how sturdy and stable it is. I do wish the straps were a bit wider for added stability, but overall it was perfect. It was quiet, easy to install, and we managed to fit two medium moving boxes, a small box, a carry-on, a duffle bag, and an extra bag inside. After a long 16-hour drive, it still looks brand new. If you're considering it, just go for it!"

"I took this on a 9,500-mile road trip across Route 66 and various national parks, and it performed excellently the entire time. It was water-resistant and kept everything inside dry, never ripping or tearing. Despite the heat and high speeds, it stayed securely on my car, except for one time when a strap wasn’t tightened. Yes, it did impact fuel economy, but that’s to be expected with a bag this size. It's reliable, which is crucial for long trips, and I had no issues throughout my journey."

"I recently took this cargo bag for a weekend camping trip and it was a must-buy! After considering several options, I opted for this one due to its great reviews and price. It performed amazingly well, staying securely on my car with just two rails. Despite being heavy, the straps held strong during our two-hour drive, even through rain. Nothing got wet thanks to the well-designed zippers and flaps. I highly recommend this for budget travelers!"

"As someone new to cargo bags, I wanted extra space for camping without breaking the bank. I was surprised at how well this bag performed. It’s made from thick plastic, and the eight sturdy straps kept it secure even on snowy roads. My only concern is its accessibility for theft, but I believe if you’re cautious, it’s manageable. Overall, it exceeded my expectations and made my trips more enjoyable!"

"This cargo bag has been a game-changer for our family road trips. It’s very roomy and fits all our camping gear without any hassle. The heavyweight fabric is waterproof, and the zippers are well-protected under the flap. I’m very picky about quality, and this bag impresses me with its excellent materials and craftsmanship. I would recommend it to anyone needing extra space!"

"I drove over 5000 miles with this roof bag, and nothing inside got wet despite heavy rains. It was very stable even at 80-90 miles/hour. I highly recommend it!"

"Using this on my Kia without a roof rack was a breeze. It survived heavy rains during a cross-country trip without any issues. Great quality for the price!"

"I found the bag to be well-made and solidly waterproof. My only complaint is the storage bag; getting the roof bag back into it is a bit of a challenge."