Best Toaster Pastries of 2025

"I've been ordering these for a while now and I will continue to do so. I was a bit worried they wouldn't taste as good as Pop-Tarts, but they are just as flavorful. They aren't dry like many generic brands; in fact, they're good whether I eat them straight out of the box or heated in the toaster. Plus, the price is much better!"

"My kids love these pastries just as much as Pop-Tarts, and I appreciate the better pricing! We enjoy the variety of flavors, and they taste great whether cold or toasted."

"I was really impressed with these toaster pastries. They are every bit as good, if not better, than the well-known brand. The fruit flavors were outstanding and they didn't skimp on the filling or flavor! The value for the price is fantastic, and I will definitely buy these again!"

“Let me just say, these are absolutely delicious! They are so tender and full of wonderful filling. The frosting has a softness to it, and I love that when I open the package, there are no crumbs everywhere. Plus, they are inexpensive! I was blown away by the first bite. It's like a 25% toaster strudel and 75% Pop-Tart combo—so much better than regular Pop-Tarts. I’m completely hooked!”

“I think these taste better than Pop-Tarts! They have the right amount of filling and are so soft. They taste fresh and are under $2. My family loves them!”

“These are a great value! They taste just as good as the name brand at a fraction of the price. The texture and taste are perfect, and they’re so fresh with no stale taste or look.”

"I've never tasted fresher toaster pastries than these! They remind me of the Pop-Tarts I loved as a child. The filling is just right, and the dough is thick and toastable. I'm thrilled with the Amazon brand!"

"I'm usually hesitant about trying different brands of pastries, but I was pleasantly surprised by these from Amazon Fresh! The strawberry and brown sugar flavors were both delicious, and the price was much lower than expected. They’ve become a lifesaver for my late-night snacks!"

"In my opinion, these taste better than the name brand! The price is fantastic, and I couldn't be happier with them. Just a heads-up though, watch the packaging as they arrived a bit crushed on one end."

"I absolutely love the berry flavors! Eating these pastries makes me feel like a kid again, and I can't resist having one or two."

"I'm thankful I can share a piece of my childhood with my children. These pastries allow me to enjoy a treat without the fake, unhealthy ingredients found in other brands."

"I ordered a case of 12 boxes for $15, thinking they would be similar to regular Pop-Tarts. I was pleasantly surprised! The ingredients are much better, and the taste is fantastic. The cherry-pomegranate filling is divine, and I appreciate that they don't taste like a sugary fruit roll-up."

"These brought me back to my childhood! Delicious toasted or right out of the package. They arrived intact, not broken or smushed. Hard and crunchy along the edges but soft and moist filling in the middle. Super fresh, tasty and easy to prepare. Such a great value! Would buy again and again!"

"I was curious about trying this Amazon brand and was pleasantly surprised. Tastes really good—better than other leading brands like Pop Tarts. Not too sweet or gummy, and they taste great both toasted and un-toasted. My family loves the taste. I totally recommend them, especially since they cost less than other brands!"

"The Amazon Fresh Frosted Fudge Toaster Pastries are decent for a quick, affordable snack. The fudge flavor is rich, and the frosting adds a nice sweetness, but the pastry itself is a bit dry. They're convenient and tasty enough for breakfast on the go, but I’d probably only buy them again if I needed something easy and inexpensive."

"I definitely overestimated how many Pop-Tarts this would be for just me, but the price is excellent! I got basically four packs, so I can't complain about the quality. However, I wasn't a fan of the cookies and cream flavor; it tasted a bit bland to me. I really enjoy cinnamon, but I prefer blueberry or strawberry. If you struggle with acne, I’d suggest eating these in moderation!"

"For my kids, these Pop-Tarts are a great price, and they can snack on them for about two weeks. They're big kids, after all! The product is wonderful, and I experienced fast, easy shipping."

"Let me tell you, Pop-Tarts are the breakfast of champions! With this variety pack, I never know what flavor I’ll get next, and it’s always an exciting surprise! Forget boring toast; these frosted pastries are the ultimate breakfast treat. They’re super convenient—just pop them in the toaster, and within minutes, breakfast is ready. I highly recommend stocking up; you won’t have a dull breakfast again!"

"I love buying this product because of the affordable price and the fact that I don’t need to go to the store. The items are always fresh and arrive intact."

"These pastries remind me of the brand from 20 years ago. They’re perfect when toasted in the oven. I give them a 5-star rating for both freshness and flavor."

"I enjoy toaster pastries for a quick breakfast or snack. These hit the spot! They're easy to pop in the toaster, and the filling is warm and gooey. The flaky texture is nice, but I find them a bit too sweet. Still, they’re a great treat when I’m in a rush!"

"I find these to be a fantastic dessert a few nights each week. They’re inexpensive and so tasty, although I do tend to remove the edges."

"When I'm craving something sweet but don't want to bake, these are perfect. The cinnamon brown sugar flavor is my absolute favorite. They don’t have as much filling as before, and the crust seems different, but for the price and quantity, they’re worth it. Toasting them with a bit of butter is my go-to."

"I really enjoy having these around. The selection of sizes is great, and they taste just as good as I remember from school."

"These taste just like Pop-Tarts™ at a much lower cost. I enjoy them as snacks, even when they’re not toasted. My favorite are the fudge ones. Honestly, if you blindfolded me and gave me one of these and a Pop-Tart, I wouldn’t be able to tell the difference!"

"I really appreciate the price of these treats. They’re softer and more flavorful compared to traditional Pop-Tarts, which I find dry. I treat myself to these occasionally because they’re affordable and delicious. I hope they don’t change the ingredients since I have food allergies!"

"I love how these taste! The blueberry flavor is fantastic, and I appreciate that the frosting isn’t overly thick like other brands."

"I bought these for my son as a quick breakfast option he can pack in his lunchbox. They don't take up much space, and he absolutely loves the frosted brown sugar flavor the most! Plus, it's a great price for bulk buying."

"There’s nothing quite like enjoying a hot brown sugar Pop-Tart with a cold glass of milk on a chilly winter morning. Gluten be damned!"

"I was in a skilled nursing facility and found myself craving something sweet one night. I spotted Pop-Tarts in the vending machine, and even though I've never liked them before, I decided to give them a try. I got the cinnamon and brown sugar flavors and was blown away by how good they tasted! I ended up buying them again the next day and realized I was hooked. Now I'm frequently visiting the snack room and watching for when they get restocked, but it’s getting a bit pricey. So, I’ve started ordering a case from Amazon. Honestly, I think I’m addicted. My waistline might not agree, but I can’t resist opening a package right now!"