Best Throw Pillow Inserts of 2026

"When I received these pillow inserts, I was pleasantly surprised by how soft and fluffy they became after expanding. They fit my decorative pillow cases perfectly and offer just the right amount of support—not too soft or too firm. I definitely think they’re worth the money."

"I've had these 18x18 pillow inserts for a couple of years and they've held up very well. They started out super fluffy and, with regular refluffing, still look full and plush on my couch. The stitching and durability have been impressive, and they're very comfortable for lounging or napping."

"The inserts arrived vacuum-packed and looked tiny at first, but after a little fluffing, they expanded nicely and fit my pillow covers just right. For the price, getting a set of two that’s this soft and fluffy feels like a great deal."

"I was pleasantly surprised by how full, plush, and supportive these inserts made my throw pillows look. They fit my 18x18 covers perfectly, and the fabric feels smooth and durable. There was no odor when I opened the package, and for the price, I think the value is hard to beat. I’ll definitely be buying more for other rooms."

"After following the instructions and tossing the inserts in the dryer, I found they fluffed up beautifully and filled my covers nicely. The material feels high quality, and the inserts are soft yet supportive. The stitching is sturdy, and there was no weird smell. I’m really satisfied and would recommend them!"

"I’ve been using these for several months and I’m impressed—they’ve stayed full, fluffy, and comfortable the whole time. I like that they are washable and that the light color doesn’t show through my pillowcases. They’re just what I needed for both my summer and winter covers."

"I was really happy with these pillow inserts—they’re true to size, easy to fluff up, and have a soft outer cover. For the price, I think they’re a great value!"

"After following the instructions and giving the pillow some time in the dryer, it turned out much fluffier and filled out my pillow cover well. There’s a slightly weak spot, but for the money, I’m still satisfied."

"The pillows are fluffy, comfortable, and fit my covers perfectly. I like how they look and they’re holding up nicely—couldn’t ask for more."

"When I first opened the pillow, it seemed a bit flat, but after a quick spin in the dryer, it became perfectly fluffy and full. I could have chosen a larger size, but it still fits well and looks great. Definitely recommend giving it a good fluff before use—it makes a huge difference!"

"I was hesitant to open these because of some negative comments, but as soon as I did, I found them to be incredibly soft and comfortable. I did size up, and now they’re the perfect fit for my covers. Absolutely great quality for the price."

"I don’t usually write reviews, but with so many comments about expansion, I wanted to share my experience. I followed the advice to size up, and used 18" pillow inserts in 15" covers—they fit perfectly and are wonderfully soft. These are ideal if you want a soft pillow for lounging or napping, just don’t expect the firmness of a down pillow."

"I used these inserts to refresh the back cushions on my old sofas, and they worked great! The relaxed look of my furniture is restored, and my mini labradoodle can nap all she wants without flattening the cushions too much. For the price, these are a fantastic buy, and I plan to get more for other uses around the house."

"When I first received these pillows, they were vacuum packed and looked small. But after tossing them in the dryer with a damp cloth and tennis balls, they fluffed up beautifully and became incredibly soft. I highly recommend them for anyone looking for affordable, comfy pillow inserts."

"The size was perfect for my needs, but I did notice the pillows weren’t as full or fluffy as I expected. They’re still comfortable enough for me to use, and I decided not to exchange them because it’s not worth the hassle. If they were a bit fuller, they’d be perfect."

"I was impressed by the softness and comfort of these pillows. The price was excellent, and they fit my covers perfectly. After unpacking, they fluffed up quickly, and they've held up well even with my kids constantly using them. For what I paid, I'm totally satisfied!"

"When I opened the vacuum-sealed package, at first the pillows seemed really flat, but they fluffed up nicely after a quick spin in the dryer. They're not super fluffy or firm, but I wanted them for decorative purposes, and they look great on my couch. If you want something firmer, you might want to spend a bit more."

"I needed several inserts and tried both the 2-pack and 4-pack. The 2-pack felt luxurious and thick, but the 4-pack was much thinner and didn't have that down feel. Both fill out my covers, but if you care about softness, I'd stick with the 2-pack. The 4-pack is a good value if you're just looking to fill out decorative pillows."

"I was really pleased with how plush and full this insert is—it actually fills out my pillowcase completely, so there are no saggy corners or empty spots. It fluffed up really quickly after I opened it, and it manages to be both comfortable to lean on and firm enough to keep its decorative look. The sizing is spot on, and I’d definitely buy more for future projects."

"I was skeptical at first because the insert was so tightly packed in plastic and looked thin, but after following the directions and tossing it in the dryer for 20 minutes, it came out super fluffy and perfectly filled my pillow cover. It was almost a challenge to zip it up because it was so well-stuffed! I’ll be ordering other sizes for sure."

"After trying these, I ended up buying more because the fit is just right and the inserts are soft and squishy, but sturdy enough that my pillow covers don’t look floppy. The zippers are solid and I had no issues fitting the inserts in gently. I’m happy to stick with this brand now that I know what to expect."

"I was pleasantly surprised by how plush and supportive these feather pillow inserts are. They give my couch a luxurious, full look and hold the perfect 'karate chop' shape. For the price, they're an incredible value and have really elevated my home decor."

"When I received these, I noticed the covers are thick and tightly woven, so there’s no feather poking through. They feel soft but substantial, and I love being able to shape them for maximum comfort. Choosing a larger insert for my pillow covers gave me that full, dense effect I wanted, without constant fluffing."

"These pillows are high quality and comfortable, with no prickly quills or feather leakage. They stay upright and hold their crease, and I plan on buying more in various sizes. They’re definitely worth every penny."

"I'm impressed by the quality and fluffiness of these pillows. They hold their shape well and fit my couch perfectly. The fiber quality stands out compared to others I've tried. I'd definitely recommend them for anyone seeking a good throw pillow at a fair price."

"After following the instructions and running the pillows in the dryer, they came out super fluffy and retained their shape. I appreciate that the cover is 100% cotton, which feels better than synthetics. The sizing was spot on for my 18x18 covers."

"These are plush and soft, great as throw pillows. I did notice, however, that one pillow was a bit larger than the other after fluffing, but overall, they work well for decorative purposes."

"These accent pillows have the perfect feel and softness I've always wanted. I use them with various seasonal covers, and they work beautifully on my sofa. They're so comfortable that I plan on getting more for my bedrooms, especially since they offer great support for my back. For the price, getting four was absolutely worth it."

"When I received these pillows, I was pleasantly surprised at how quickly they fluffed up and held their shape. After a quick run in the dryer, they became perfectly plump and soft, yet firm. They fit my holiday pillowcases perfectly and honestly, this purchase has exceeded my expectations. I highly recommend them!"

"I absolutely love these cushion covers and inserts! The quality is top-notch—the fabric is soft, durable, and looks luxurious. The stitching and hidden zippers give a clean, stylish appearance, and the cushions provide plush support and comfort. My living room feels instantly upgraded, and I've gotten so many compliments. These are definitely worth every penny!"