Best Throw Pillow Inserts of 2025

"I was a bit concerned when I first received my Utopia Bedding Throw Pillow Inserts. They arrived vacuum-sealed and looked disappointingly flat. But after a vigorous shake and a few minutes of fluffing, they transformed beautifully. Now, they’re plush, supportive, and fit perfectly into my 22 x 22 pillow covers. I highly recommend these for anyone looking to upgrade their space!"

"When I ordered the two-pack of 18x18 white pillow inserts, I was nervous they’d be too squishy. After taking them out of the vacuum-sealed packages and shaking them for about 30 seconds, they puffed up nicely. I even threw them in the dryer for 15-20 minutes, and they firmed up great. I’m really happy with my purchase!"

"I had never bought decorative pillow inserts before, so I was a bit overwhelmed by the options. I decided on Utopia because of the good ratings and reasonable price. I purchased a size larger than my pillow cases, and it worked out well. The pillows are now plump and fluffy, and I’m very satisfied with my purchase!"

"I was pleasantly surprised with the quick delivery and the perfect size for my covers. They are really puffy and not thin like others I’ve tried, especially at this price!"

"At first, I thought about returning these inserts because they didn’t seem full. However, after leaving them on the guest bed for a week, I noticed they fully expanded and turned out to be great pillow inserts. They are indeed a fantastic value, but patience is key!"

"I needed pillows in a hurry for a party, and I regret purchasing these. They are almost flat and lack sufficient stuffing, making them unsuitable for my covers. I am disappointed and cannot use the fun pillow covers I bought!"

"From the moment I unwrapped them, I could tell these inserts are crafted with care. The 100% cotton cover gives the pillows a soft, luxurious feel while ensuring breathability, making them ideal for year-round use. They maintain their shape and loft, providing excellent support for both decorative and functional purposes. I appreciate their versatility, fitting perfectly into various pillow covers, and they are easy to fluff and reshape. I highly recommend these Throw Pillow Inserts for anyone looking for high-quality, comfortable options at home."

"These are absolutely the best pillows I've purchased on Amazon. Excellent quality and I love how they look. They're fluffy, and even if they get flat, I can easily fluff them back up. I got them at a great price, and they are definitely worth it!"

"I bought these for two decorative pillows on my sofa, and they are fantastic! They are plump and very soft, and they really enhance my decor. I plan to buy a couple more because they look great!"

"I found this pillow insert to be super flat and unimpressive at first. However, after following the fluffing instructions and tossing it in the dryer for about 30 minutes, it puffed up beautifully!"

"Initially, I thought the pillow was a bit thin at just 2 inches thick when expanded. But after reading the instructions, I put it in the dryer on FLUFF, and it expanded to 4 to 5 inches thick—very nice and soft!"

"While looking for an accent pillow, I noticed this one was the right size, but it didn’t have the firmness I expected. It didn’t fill the pillowcase as well as other pillows I’ve bought, so I’m not entirely convinced about its quality for the price."

"I found these pillows to be well made and comfortable. After tossing them in the dryer for about 20 minutes, they came out nice and fluffy!"

"Initially, I thought these would be stiffer, but to my pleasant surprise, they’re quite soft and easy to compact. They fit my pillow covers perfectly and are much more comfortable to use!"

"I bought these to replace older inserts, and I was amazed at how full they are. After taking them out of the vacuum pack and putting them in the dryer, they fluffed up incredibly well!"

"I absolutely love these pillows! At first, I was a bit disappointed when I took them out of the package and tried to fluff them by hand. But after reading the user manual, I tossed them in the dryer, and they fluffed up beautifully to their original size. They fit perfectly in my covers and are very soft—great even just as regular white pillows!"

"I bought these for my daughters as part of their Christmas gifts, and I was really upset because they don't look like the picture at all! They're completely flat with no fluffiness whatsoever and feel cheaply made. I wouldn't recommend trying to fluff them; the result is just horrible. You can see the difference when compared to other brands, and it's disappointing!"

"Using the dryer method worked wonders for me! I put two inserts in the dryer for 15 minutes on low heat, and they came out fluffy. I bought eight in total and repeated the process without any issues. They fit my 18-inch covers perfectly, and I’m definitely planning to buy more!"

“I found these EDOW throw pillow inserts to be exactly what I was looking for! They're lightweight but provide the perfect fluff and support for my decorative pillows. The polyester down alternative is soft and comfortable, and they fit my 18x18 pillow covers beautifully for a luxurious look. Plus, they're machine washable, which makes maintenance a breeze. Overall, these are high-quality inserts at a great price, and I plan on buying more for my other pillows!”

“I was looking for some inexpensive pillows to refresh my living room, so I bought these along with some colorful covers. After several months, I can say they remain nice and fluffy and are a great size.”

“I needed a pillow insert and was a bit unsure if it would be true to size. After opening the package and fluffing it up, I found it to be perfect.”

“I found the pillows made with a nice fabric shell, unlike the papery ones on cheaper inserts. They arrived vacuum packed, and after about 30 minutes, they plumped out nicely. While they aren't super dense, they do the job perfectly, especially for the price point.”

“Although I expected them to be firmer, they turned out a little softer. One of the pillows is a bit lumpy in the middle, but with some fluffing, they’ll be fine. Great price for two, though!”

“The pillows fit my needs and were at a great price. They came vacuum sealed, and while the filler wasn’t very fluffable, they arrived quickly and in good condition. They look nice in my pillow covers.”

"I found this rectangular pillow insert to be the perfect size for my pillow cover. It arrived well-packaged and fluffed up evenly to fill out the cover. I was initially considering using cotton batting, but I'm so glad I chose this insert instead; it was exactly as described and an excellent value."

"At first, I was worried about the size as it seemed flat, but after following the directions to put it in the dryer, it fluffed up perfectly. I'm really happy with how it turned out!"

"I made a smart choice by purchasing a pillow that was slightly smaller than my pillowcase. It's a very plump pillow, and if I'd chosen one that matched the case size, it would have looked overstuffed. Now it fits just right and adds a lovely touch to my bed!"

"My pillows arrived well-packaged and in a timely manner. I'm impressed with their soft yet substantial feel. The covers are thick and tightly woven, so nothing pokes through. I prefer a thick, firm pillow, so I bought 22" x 22" inserts for my 18" x 18" covers, creating a nice, full, dense effect without constant fluffing."

"I wanted something clean and soft-looking, and I found it! The quality is fantastic, and I used a 26x26 cover on a 26x26 goose down pillow insert, achieving a full and chic look. I'm very happy with this purchase."

"I replaced a cheaper synthetic insert with the 22x22 size for my 20” cover. They arrived compressed, but after a quick fluff and a stint in the dryer, they shaped up nicely and filled the cover well. These inserts are firm yet fluffy, providing that perfect 'chop' look, making them a fantastic value!"