Best Softball Mitts of 2026

"I purchased this for my sister's softball journey and she absolutely loves it. The fit is perfect, and she adores the pink and black color. She finds the stiffness ideal and keeps saying the quality is just right for her."

"I was searching for a glove for my vegetarian daughter who didn't want leather and was pleasantly surprised by this one. It feels just like leather, breaks in really well, and my 10-year-old is so happy with it."

"My only issue is the overpowering smell—it really does smell strongly of spices, to the point where it fills up the car and her room. We're trying odor sprays and airing it out, but it's still very noticeable."

"I was honestly unsure about this glove at first, but after using it, I’m impressed by the durability and quality of the material. My son uses it for recreational softball, and it’s holding up well. I’d definitely recommend it for anyone who wants a solid glove without spending too much."

"I needed a reliable glove quickly for coaching softball, and this one worked out great. It was flexible and comfortable right out of the box, though a bit big for my hand. Still, I’m happy with how it performs during practice."

"After some effort breaking it in, the glove turned out to be a great choice and solid value. The pocket is well-padded, and the design works nicely for senior slowpitch players. It does take some time to loosen up, but it’s worth it in the end."

"I bought this glove as a present for my 11-year-old niece, and she immediately loved it. The break-in was quick, the fit felt natural, and the grip was excellent. The overall design is classic, and the leather feels both durable and soft. Great comfort, flexibility, and style—perfect for any young softball player."

"This glove was exactly what my daughter required! It's well constructed and fits comfortably, so she's been able to use it right out of the box."

"The glove is a good value and has a nice pocket, but it can be a bit tough to close for my child's smaller hands. Still, the quality and usability are impressive overall."

"I needed an affordable, functional glove for my recreational softball league, and this one was perfect. Comfortable right away, no long break-in needed, and I love that it's actually cute for sporting gear. For beginners or casual players, this glove is great value and looks good on the field."

"I got this glove for practicing softball with my daughter, and I’m really impressed. It’s super comfortable, easy to adjust, and game-ready out of the box. The quality is excellent for the price, and my daughter especially likes the stylish pink details. I highly recommend it for any parent or young player just starting out!"

"As someone who wanted a glove to coach and join in on practice, this was exactly what I needed. Great quality, quick to break in, and didn’t break the bank. Perfect for newer players and casual use!"

"I absolutely love this mitt—it quickly became my favorite once broken in. I own several others, but this one stands out for comfort and fit."

"My daughter is thrilled with this glove, saying it's the best she's ever had. It broke in fast, feels soft, and fits her perfectly for her league."

"I was expecting two balls based on the listing, but only received one. Still, the quality is excellent and works great for my needs as a coach. I just wish the description was more clear."

"I bought this glove for my 13-year-old daughter who likes to try different activities. It's comfortable and was flexible right out of the box, especially after applying glove oil. She’s playing quite well with it, which makes me think it’s either a great glove or she’s a natural."

"This glove is soft, fits perfectly, and broke in with no effort at all. I absolutely love how easy it was to start using it right away."

"Compared to other brands, the quality of this glove really stands out. It’s all leather, broke in fast, and fits youth hands perfectly. I would definitely recommend it for kids aged 8 to 12."

"I've been using this mitt for my daughter's high school softball games, and I'm impressed with its outstanding durability and solid build quality. While it was quite stiff at first and took some effort to break in, it now looks and performs just as we'd hoped."

"As a parent catching for my daughter, I wanted something affordable but dependable. This mitt has been a great value for the money—it's held up to daily use and has comfortable padding and a good fit. Highly recommend for casual practice!"

"The glove itself is well constructed with a large, deep pocket, but be prepared: it arrives very stiff and not game-ready. Once it's broken in, though, it'll be a great addition to your gear for an excellent price."

"I've bought three of these over the years and continue to use each one. They're extremely well made and do an excellent job of preserving my gloves' shape. My son's glove still looks great after two years. Absolutely recommend this if you care about keeping your glove in top form."

"This tool is definitely superior to wrapping my glove with a softball. The softball always pushed the thumb and pinky in, but this product lets me keep the glove's flare just right."

"I found it challenging to get this to mold correctly with my glove, even after trying hot water methods. It became only slightly pliable, so the process was more hassle than I expected."

"I bought this glove for my daughter and it's been fantastic for her as a beginner. The glove was easy to break in and is a great size for an 11-year-old. It really helped her build confidence behind the plate. At this price point, it was absolutely worth it."

"After purchasing this mitt for my small 10-year-old, I found it was perfectly sized for her hands and she loved using it. The break-in process was simple, but unfortunately, the laces snapped after only a few games. Wilson did honor their warranty and sent us a voucher, so we'll keep this one as a backup after relacing it."

"I surprised my daughter with this mitt for her birthday, and she was thrilled with the fit and comfort. However, I noticed the laces started breaking pretty quickly, which was a bit disappointing."

"I bought this glove for my daughter and was impressed by how quickly it broke in and how comfortable it feels. She’s used it for two years, and it’s still in great shape. We even bought another of the same model because she loved it so much. Perfect fit and high quality."

"As a coach, I saw a real improvement in my catcher's performance when she switched to this glove. It fit her smaller hand perfectly, was easy to squeeze, and helped her hold onto the ball better during games. Great value for beginner and intermediate players."

"My 9-year-old was struggling with her old glove, but with this one, she was making catches left and right the very first game. The design makes it easy to close, and her confidence went way up."