Best Prophy Pastes of 2026

Brian Howie

Last Updated: Aug 30, 2023

* We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

Choosing the best prophy paste can be difficult as there are so many considerations, such as Qartz, Prophy Magic, Young Denticator. To help you find the top 4 Best Prophy Pastes that meet different needs, we have carefully researched a large amount of prophy pastes.

We spent some time researching prophy pastes with prices ranging from $25.00 all the way up to $58.00. One of our favorite is Qartz Prophy Paste. Read on to see what other prophy pastes we highly recommend, and check out our buying guide for all the information you need to know to make the best choice!

At a Glance: Our Top Picks

Qartz 58-00208 Prophylaxis Paste, Mint Parfait Flavor, Medium Grit, Green (Pack of 200) Cover

#TOP 1

Qartz 58-00208 Prophylaxis Paste, Mint Parfait Flavor, Medium Grit, Green (Pack of 200)

9.9

Buy on Amazon Read Review

Qartz 58-00208 Prophylaxis Paste, Mint Parfait Flavor, Medium Grit, Green (Pack of 200)

#TOP1

9.9

Read Review

Flavored Gluten-Free Prophy Paste by Prophy Magic, Non-Splatter Formula Perfect for Polishing and Stain Removing with Fluoride Release, Easy Rinse Off, Variety, Medium (Pack of 200), Model:265-200 Cover

#TOP 2

Flavored Gluten-Free Prophy Paste by Prophy Magic, Non-Splatter Formula Perfect for Polishing and Stain Removing with Fluoride Release, Easy Rinse Off, Variety, Medium (Pack of 200), Model:265-200

9.8

Buy on Amazon Read Review

Flavored Gluten-Free Prophy Paste by Prophy Magic, Non-Splatter Formula Perfect for Polishing and Stain Removing with Fluoride Release, Easy Rinse Off, Variety, Medium (Pack of 200), Model:265-200

#TOP2

9.8

Read Review

Prophylaxis Paste, Mint Parfait Flavor, Coarse Grit Cover

#TOP 3

Prophylaxis Paste, Mint Parfait Flavor, Coarse Grit

9.6

Buy on Amazon Read Review

Prophylaxis Paste, Mint Parfait Flavor, Coarse Grit

#TOP3

9.6

Read Review

Top 4 Prophy Pastes

#TOP 1

Qartz 58-00208 Prophylaxis Paste, Mint Parfait Flavor, Medium Grit, Green (Pack of 200)

Qartz

58-00208

Green

Qartz 58-00208 Prophylaxis Paste, Mint Parfait Flavor, Medium Grit, Green (Pack of 200) Cover

Qartz 58-00208 Prophylaxis Paste, Mint Parfait Flavor, Medium Grit, Green (Pack of 200)

9.9

FTB Score

Find on Walmart

Features

Contains Xylitol, Gluten Free

Helps Maintain An Effective Fluoride Level, Strengthening Tooth Enamel And Preventing Dental Cares

Rinses Easily And Consistently

#TOP 2

Flavored Gluten-Free Prophy Paste by Prophy Magic, Non-Splatter Formula Perfect for Polishing and Stain Removing with Fluoride Release, Easy Rinse Off, Variety, Medium (Pack of 200), Model:265-200

Prophy Magic

265-200

Flavored Gluten-Free Prophy Paste by Prophy Magic, Non-Splatter Formula Perfect for Polishing and Stain Removing with Fluoride Release, Easy Rinse Off, Variety, Medium (Pack of 200), Model:265-200 Cover

Flavored Gluten-Free Prophy Paste by Prophy Magic, Non-Splatter Formula Perfect for Polishing and Stain Removing with Fluoride Release, Easy Rinse Off, Variety, Medium (Pack of 200), Model:265-200

9.8

FTB Score

Find on Walmart

Features

PREVENT TOOTH DECAY: Gentle On Gums And Teeth Enamel, But Works Itself Into Hard-To-Reach Areas To Eliminate Bacteria That May Cause Periodontal Diseases And Tooth Decay.

GLUTEN-FREE PROPHY PASTE: Cruelty-Free Prophy Paste Designed To Make Every Dental Visit Go Smoothly. No Artificial Preservatives, No GMO's Or Other Harsh Chemicals. Gentle On The Gums And Enamel, While Providing A Refreshing Deep Clean.

NON-SPLATTER FORMULA: No Mess, No Stains And Absolutely No Splattering. This Thick Gluten-Free Prophy Paste Is Conveniently Packaged Into 2gm Unit-Doses With An Easy To Dispense Box.

GREAT TASTE AND EASY RINSE OFF: No Bitter Medicine Aftertaste. Easy Rinse Off Formula And Available In A Variety Of Flavors.

EXCEPTIONAL POLISHING FOR A SPOTLESS WHITE SMILE: This Gluten Free Prophy-Paste Is Designed To Safely Clean And Whitening Your Teeth Without Corrosive Bleaching. Packed With Fluoride Release To Keep Teeth Nourished And Strong.

Read more Read less

#TOP 3

Prophylaxis Paste, Mint Parfait Flavor, Coarse Grit

Qartz

58-00209

Green

Prophylaxis Paste, Mint Parfait Flavor, Coarse Grit Cover

Prophylaxis Paste, Mint Parfait Flavor, Coarse Grit

9.6

FTB Score

Find on Walmart

Features

Contains Xylitol, Gluten Free

Helps Maintain An Effective Fluoride Level, Strengthening Tooth Enamel And Preventing Dental Cares

Rinses Easily And Consistently

#TOP 4

YNG D-Lish Prophy Paste Coarse Mint Box/200

Young Denticator

YNG-300010

YNG D-Lish Prophy Paste Coarse Mint Box/200 Cover

YNG D-Lish Prophy Paste Coarse Mint Box/200

9.4

FTB Score

Find on Walmart

Buying Guide Image

Editor's Notes

During our prophy paste research, we found 4 prophy paste products and shortlisted 4 quality products. We collected and analyzed 2,659 customer reviews through our big data system to write the prophy pastes list. We found that most customers choose prophy pastes with an average price of $26.00.

The prophy pastes are available for purchase. We have researched hundreds of brands and picked the top brands of prophy pastes, including Qartz, Prophy Magic, Young Denticator. The seller of top 1 product has received honest feedback from 136 consumers with an average rating of 4.6.

Written by

Brian Howie

Brian Howie is a content writer and senior industrial designer. After graduation from Westminster College, he has been engaged in product design and manufacturing for 18 years. Brian Howie has always found great pleasure in designing industrial products and sharing his ideas and experience online.