Best Pegged Puzzles of 2025

“This is a great puzzle! I've bought it three times over the last 15 years, not for replacement, but because I gave it away when my child outgrew it. Melissa and Doug toys are made to last and could even be heirloom quality. My toddler laughs every time it makes animal noises when we turn off the light. It's perfect for teaching farm animal noises!”

“I’m updating my review from one star to five! It turns out it was my mistake. I thought the puzzle was activated by magnets, not light. After reading the back more clearly, I realized I was just a bit clueless. Now it works great in bright natural light, and my 14-month-old daughter is absolutely obsessed with it!”

“I love these puzzles for toddlers! Just a heads-up, the sound is light activated, so it won't work in dim areas. My child enjoys the noises of the animals and the bright colors make it visually appealing.”

"I really love the Melissa & Doug line! The puzzles are handcrafted and non-toxic, which is crucial since my son puts everything in his mouth. This puzzle has been a hit! I found it for less than $8 on Amazon, which is a steal compared to the $15 I saw elsewhere! My 18-month-old is captivated by puzzles, and the pieces are large enough to avoid choking hazards. We enjoy playing together and naming the pieces like the plane and bus, which he now recognizes in real life!"

"I got this puzzle for my one-year-old grandson. He loves taking the pieces out, but he’s still working on fitting them back in. The quality is great, easy to clean, and it’s a fantastic first puzzle for him!"

"This puzzle is perfect for my 22-month-old who adores trucks and airplanes. The parts are easy for him to pick up thanks to the little hooks. Thanks, Melissa & Doug!"

“I purchased this Doug and Melissa chunky puzzle for my grandson's second birthday, and it quickly became his favorite toy. He takes the animals everywhere, from the supermarket to playing outside. The bright colors and easy-to-handle pieces are perfect for his age. The puzzle is not just a fun activity; it also encourages imaginative play. I highly recommend it!”

“As the parent of a two-year-old who loves puzzles, I find these wooden block puzzles to be outstanding. The thick pieces are easy for him to grasp, and he enjoys naming the animals as he fits them together. Melissa and Doug consistently deliver high-quality products, and I plan to keep buying their puzzles!”

“This puzzle is colorful, educational, and a great gift for my grandchild. It's well-made, easy to use, and stores conveniently. I appreciate the brilliant colors and the joy it brings as they put it together.”

"I've loved this puzzle since my daughter was one. Now she’s three, and we still enjoy discussing animals with it. It's also great for my nine-month-old, though I prefer supervising him to prevent any chewing. I’d recommend it for ages one and up due to its sturdy, thick pieces and perfect shape fit."

"I purchased this puzzle for my one-year-old last January. The big knobs are perfect for his little hands, making it easy for him to place the pieces. It has been worth every penny, helping him learn about farm animals and their sounds!"

"This puzzle is of excellent quality, and I appreciate that it’s made of wood. We have a lot of fun singing 'Old MacDonald' using the pieces together, and I believe it will be used for many years to come!"

"I was thrilled with these puzzles for my one-year-old. They are sturdy and adorable."

"I bought this as a first birthday gift. It's a perfect variety of shapes to learn how to puzzle, and it's colorful and fun."

"This puzzle has become my granddaughter's favorite toy. At 10 months old, she finds it easy to grab the knobs to remove and replace the pieces. I absolutely love it!"

"I bought this dinosaur puzzle for my toddler daughter, and she enjoys playing with it, even if it's a bit advanced for her. The colors are vibrant and the wood is smooth and lightweight, making it easy to carry. I was looking for a small puzzle to keep her entertained on the go, and this fits perfectly."

"These puzzles are adorable and the colors are bright. They are a bit smaller than typical toddler puzzles, but I appreciate that you get four puzzles in total. My 2 1/2-year-old loved the dinosaurs, but he struggled a bit with the pieces as the openings were a bit tight, which frustrated him. I think as he grows, it will suit him better."

"I got this for my 1-year-old, and while you get a decent value, the puzzles feel a little flimsy for his age. The images are as described, and the fact that you get four puzzles for the price of one is a plus, but the thinness is a concern."

"I found the perfect size for kids aged 12 months to 6 years. The durable wooden puzzles and color options are great!"

"My kids, aged 18 months, 3 years, and 11 years, had a blast doing these puzzles together. The pieces fit easily into their spots, which made it fun and easy to play. We even used them while following the 'Potty Training in Three Days' plan!"

"My 2.5-year-old is obsessed! He loves the dinosaurs, numbers, shapes, letters, automobiles, and animals included. He wanted to play with them all night! It made for a great Christmas gift, and I was happy with the colorful designs, though the quality was just okay."

“I started using this to teach my 3-year-old shapes, and it's great. Educational value is definitely there, especially with the names included in each shape. Very high quality, easy for her to use, and fits perfectly in each spot. Great value.”

“I purchased the Dailyfunn Montessori Toy Shape Peg Puzzle for my toddler, and it’s been such a hit! The bright colors and easy-to-grip knobs really grab my little one's attention. I wholeheartedly recommend this toy because it's perfect for keeping them engaged while they practice hand-eye coordination and learn about shapes. The puzzle pieces are just the right size for tiny hands.”

“My toddler loves it! Good quality and perfect size for a two-year-old. She enjoys playing with the puzzle while learning shapes and colors at the same time.”

"I was really excited about this puzzle for my granddaughter, but I found it frustrating that the pieces only work with decent lighting. I had to search online to figure out why it wasn't working most of the time. It’s disappointing, especially for a two-year-old."

"My son absolutely adores this toy! The songs make him happy, and he has learned to put the puzzle pieces together. I do wish the pieces had a way to stick better so they don't fall out, and that the songs played when placing a piece in instead of taking it out. But overall, it's a fantastic toy!"

"I initially thought my puzzle was broken because it wasn't playing after changing the batteries. Thankfully, I read the reviews and learned that it needs good lighting to work. My almost two-year-old loves it, and I think it’s a charming little puzzle despite the sound quality being less than perfect."

“My son adores these puzzles! The colors are bright and fun, and the quality is fantastic—the wood is really sturdy. They’re also easy to store, making them perfect for little ones learning shapes, letters, and numbers.”

“I received all the puzzles with their pieces intact! The colors came out just right, and my baby absolutely loves them!”

“While the puzzles are cute, the word associations can be quite odd. For instance, 'M' is for 'milk cow' and 'W' is for 'water pistol', which are just strange choices. It's something to keep in mind when teaching letter sounds.”