Best Paint Buckets of 2025

Howard Chester Avatar
Howard Chester
Last Updated: Jan 16, 2025

* We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

Paint buckets are an essential tool for any DIY or professional painter. These sturdy containers come in various sizes and materials, from plastic to metal, and can hold gallons of paint. They are designed with a handle for easy carrying and often feature a tight-fitting lid to prevent spills and keep the paint fresh. Some paint buckets also come with measurement markings, making it easier to mix and measure paint accurately. Whether you're painting a small room or a large building, paint buckets are a must-have accessory for any painting project.

At a Glance: Our Top Picks

Handy Paint Pail with Magnetic Brush Holder Cover #TOP 1
Handy Paint Pail with Magnetic Brush Holder
ftb score rating icon 9.9
All-Plastic Paint Can (2 Pack) - Stock Your Home Cover #TOP 2
All-Plastic Paint Can (2 Pack) - Stock Your Home
ftb score rating icon 9.8
HANDy Paint Products PRO-GO Bucket Paint and Tool Bucket Cover #TOP 3
HANDy Paint Products PRO-GO Bucket Paint and Tool Bucket
ftb score rating icon 9.6

Top 10 Paint Buckets

#TOP 1

Handy Paint Pail with Magnetic Brush Holder

2500-CT
1 Pack
Handy Paint Pail with Magnetic Brush Holder Cover
Handy Paint Pail, Holds 32-fl oz of Paint or Stain, Efficient for Clean-ups and Quick Color Changes with Integrated Magnetic Brush Holder

The Handy Paint Pail is an adjustable strap-on bucket that holds up to a quart of paint or stain. It features a built-in magnetic brush holder and scraper, which allows for easy clean-up and quick color changes. The pail is solvent-resistant and works with any type of paint or stain. The adjustable strap can fit your hand or attach to your belt for hands-free use.

What We Like
Sturdy and adjustable handle
Effective magnetic brush holder
Easy cleanup with liners
Comfortable to hold
Great value for price
What We Don't Like
Thin plastic liners may not last
#TOP 2

All-Plastic Paint Can (2 Pack) - Stock Your Home

1986
Black
1 Gallon
All-Plastic Paint Can (2 Pack) - Stock Your Home Cover
All-Plastic Paint Can (2 Pack) - Gallon Bucket with Metal Handle - Small Bucket with Airtight Seal - Rust Proof Plastic Paint Container with Lid - Reusable Paint Storage Container - Stock Your Home

The All-Plastic Paint Can (2 Pack) by Stock Your Home is proudly made in the USA and offers a triple lock seal to keep paint fresh and odors locked in. The durable polypropylene bucket is dent, damage, and chemical resistant, and can even be used for hot fill applications up to 165°F. It is a great alternative to metal and tin cans, as it is 100% recyclable and molded entirely from recycled materials. The value pack includes two 1-gallon buckets with snap-on lids and bail handles for easy maneuvering and portability.

What We Like
Preserves paint effectively
Rust-free design
Easy to seal tightly
Strong handle
Simple and functional
What We Don't Like
Handle can be tricky
Lid may warp with oil paint
#TOP 3

HANDy Paint Products PRO-GO Bucket Paint and Tool Bucket

HANDy Paint Products PRO-GO Bucket Paint and Tool Bucket Cover
HANDy Paint Products Pro-Go Bucket Paint and Tool Bucket with Brush Holder That Attaches to Most Ladders, 1 Gallon, Red

The HANDy Paint Products PRO-GO Bucket Paint and Tool Bucket is the ultimate paint bucket and ladder caddie for the Pro or serious DIYer. It has a built-in ladder bracket that secures to most ladders and extension ladders, and can hold a full gallon of paint or stain which means less refills and more painting. The bucket can hold 9” rollers and up to a 4” brush with its built-in magnetic brush holder. It allows you to tackle any job from the ground, ladder or the palm of your hand.

What We Like
User-friendly and ergonomic design
Excellent for ladder use
Easy to clean
Lightweight and mobile
Innovative features like magnet
What We Don't Like
Bucket hangs at an angle
Roller hang point too low
#TOP 4

Purdy Dual Roll-Off 5-Gallon Bucket

140796018
Multicolor
One Size
Purdy Dual Roll-Off 5-Gallon Bucket Cover
Purdy 140796018 Dual Roll-Off 5-Gallon Bucket, Black

The Purdy Dual Roll-Off 5-Gallon Bucket, also known as the Purdy Roll-Off Bucket, is a versatile paint bucket designed to make your painting projects more convenient. With its dual roll-off feature, you can easily load two different paint colors or types into the bucket, allowing for quick color changes without the need for separate containers. This saves you time and effort, ensuring a smooth and efficient painting process. The 5-gallon capacity of the bucket means you can tackle larger painting jobs without constant refilling. Made by the trusted brand Purdy, this bucket is durable and built to withstand heavy use. Whether you are a professional painter or a DIY enthusiast, the Purdy Dual Roll-Off 5-Gallon Bucket is an essential tool for your painting needs.

What We Like
Durable construction
Efficient dual roll-off system
Holds large paint volume
Easy cleanup with liners
Comfortable handle for transport
What We Don't Like
May lack a lid
Handle connection issues reported
#TOP 5

HANDy Paint Pail Liner #2500-CT

BER-2520-CT
Clear
6 Count (Pack of 1)
HANDy Paint Pail Liner #2500-CT Cover
Handy Paint Pail Liner, Holds 32-fl oz of Paint or Stain, Efficient for Clean-ups and Quick Color Changes with Integrated Magnetic Brush Holder, 6 Liners (Pack of 1)

The HANDy Paint Pail Liner is designed to make your painting projects easier and cleaner. It can hold up to a quart of paint or stain, allowing you to tackle larger jobs without frequent refills. The liner is made from solvent-resistant plastic, making it compatible with any paint or stain you choose, so you won’t have to worry about damaging it. With six disposable liners in each package, you can quickly switch colors or clean up without the hassle of washing out traditional paint buckets. This product is a convenient solution for anyone looking to minimize mess during their painting tasks.

What We Like
Convenient for easy clean-up
Perfect fit for Handy Paint Pail
Reusable with dried paint
Great for oil-based paints
Excellent quality for the price
What We Don't Like
Thin plastic material
#TOP 6

HANDy Paint Cup

HANDy Paint Cup Cover
Handy Paint Cup Holds 16 oz. of Paint or Stain, Integrated Magnetic Brush Holder, Ideal for Trim Work, Touch-ups, 4 Pack

The HANDy Paint Cup is an ideal tool for trim work, touch-ups, and smaller paint and craft projects. It features a built-in magnetic brush holder, allowing you to conveniently store your brush when not in use. The ergonomic handle reduces hand fatigue, making your painting experience more comfortable. With a capacity of up to a pint of paint or stain, this cup is perfect for quick touch-ups or small projects. It is also solvent resistant, compatible with any type of paint or stain. The HANDy Paint Cup is a versatile and user-friendly tool that makes your painting tasks easier and more efficient.

What We Like
Convenient magnetic brush holder
Easy to clean
Comfortable to hold
Sturdy construction
Perfect size for small jobs
What We Don't Like
Flexible handle may feel unstable
Thin plastic material
#TOP 7

1-Quart Plastic Paint Bucket (6 Pack)

1992
Black
1 Quart
1-Quart Plastic Paint Bucket (6 Pack) Cover
1-Quart Plastic Paint Bucket (6 Pack) - Triple Lock Airtight Seal - Minimizes Skimming - Rust Proof - Odor & Chemical Resistant - 32 Fl Oz All-Plastic Paint Can with Snap On Lid - Stock Your Home

Stock Your Home's 1-Quart Plastic Paint Bucket (6 Pack) is proudly made in the USA and boasts a triple lock airtight seal to minimize paint skinning and lock in odors. The all-plastic bucket is rust proof, odor and chemical resistant, and is durable enough to be used for hot fill applications up to 165°F. It is also a sustainable option, made entirely from recycled materials and is 100% recyclable. The pack includes six 1-quart cans with snap-on lids, making it a great value.

What We Like
No rust or corrosion
Excellent plastic quality
Tight seal
Durable and stackable
Great value for money
What We Don't Like
Hard to close by hand
Some lids may not fit
#TOP 8

Custom Shop TCP Global Paint Mixing Cups (Pack of 12)

9174-12PK
Clear
Custom Shop TCP Global Paint Mixing Cups (Pack of 12) Cover
Custom Shop/TCP Global (Pack of 12 - Mix Cups/Buckets - 5 Quart) - (174 Ounce Volume Paint and Epoxy Mixing Cups)

Custom Shop TCP Global Paint Mixing Cups are solvent resistant and calibrated for multiple mixing ratios. Their graduated measurements make mixing easy and accurate, and they can be reused due to their durable polypropylene plastic construction. They are suitable for use with popular automotive paint brands and epoxy resin, as well as for mixing stains, acrylic pouring paint, and slime, making them versatile and convenient for a range of applications.

What We Like
Good quality for epoxy work
Durable and sturdy buckets
Easy-to-read markings
Flexible for easy resin removal
Handy for various tasks
What We Don't Like
Hard to separate at times
Misleading quantity advertised
#TOP 9

Wooster Brush 8616 4-Gallon Bucket

8616-2
Green
Wooster Brush 8616 4-Gallon Bucket Cover
Wooster Brush 8616 4-Gallon Bucket, Pack of 1, Green-New

The Wooster Brush 4-Gallon Bucket is a durable and convenient tool for any painting project. It features a built-in 10 inch wide roll-off area, which allows you to easily load your brush or roller with paint without the need for a separate tray. The no-tip design ensures stability, preventing accidental spills or messes. The heavy-duty 1/4 inch galvanized bail with comfort grip makes it easy to move the bucket, even when it's filled with paint. Made from seamless green polypropylene, this bucket is resistant to solvents and paint buildup, ensuring long-lasting use. With a large four-gallon working capacity, you can tackle big painting jobs without constantly refilling. The Wooster Brush 4-Gallon Bucket is a reliable and efficient choice for any painter or DIY enthusiast.

What We Like
4 gallon capacity
Tough plastic material
Reduces spills and drips
Great for storing supplies
Versatile for large and small projects
What We Don't Like
Not the desired model
#TOP 10

Leaktite 1-Gallon White Plastic Pail Paint Pail/Container

White
No Size
Leaktite 1-Gallon White Plastic Pail Paint Pail/Container Cover
Leaktite 744456 1-Gallon White Plastic Pail Paint Pail/Container

This Leaktite paint bucket has a one-gallon capacity, reinforced lip, and durable construction. It comes with a lid and is made of white plastic. Perfect for any painting project.

What We Like
High quality material
Great for multiple uses
Sturdy and durable
Perfect size for carrying
What We Don't Like
Handle material differs from photo
Not the best value for price
Buying Guide Image

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Will paint stick to a 5 gallon bucket?

Yes, you can improve the appearance of a 5-gallon bucket by spray painting it with products like Krylon or Rustoleum paint. This allows you to customize the look of the bucket to suit your needs.

2. Can you reuse 5 gallon paint buckets?

Absolutely! 5-gallon paint buckets can be repurposed for various projects. Some popular options include using them as a chicken feeder, a mini vegetable garden, or a worm farm to create compost for your garden. The heavy-duty nature of these buckets makes them suitable for repurposing.

3. How long does paint last in a 5 gallon container?

The longevity of paint in a 5-gallon container depends on the type. Latex-based paints can last 2-10 years, while oil-based paints can last 3-11 years when stored properly. Oil-based paints may take longer to dry, but they offer greater durability.

4. How much does 1 gallon of paint cost?

The cost of 1 gallon of paint varies depending on the type. Latex-based paints typically range from $15 to $50 per gallon, while oil-based paints average $20 to $60 per gallon. The choice of paint should be based on your specific needs and preferences.

5. How much does a 5 gallon bucket of Sherwin Williams paint cover?

A 5-gallon bucket of Sherwin Williams paint can cover approximately 2000 square feet of space. The coverage may vary depending on the specific type of paint and the surface being painted.

6. Is it better to store paint in metal or plastic?

To ensure paint remains viable, it is recommended to store it in a sealable container that is just large enough to hold the excess paint. Small metal cans, such as Behr's 1-qt Metal Paint Bucket and Lid, are ideal for this purpose. Plastic containers may increase the risk of off-gassing.

7. Does it matter if there is dry paint in buckets?

If you don't properly close a paint container, the water in the paint will evaporate, leaving behind solid paint residue. It is important to let the paint dry out and solidify before disposing of it. Dumping wet paint in the trash is not recommended.

Editor's Notes

During our paint bucket research, we found 24 paint bucket products and shortlisted 10 quality products. We collected and analyzed 61,257 customer reviews through our big data system to write the paint buckets list. We found that most customers choose paint buckets with an average price of $20.43.

The paint buckets are available for purchase. We have researched hundreds of brands and picked the top brands of paint buckets, including HANDy Paint Products, Stock Your Home, Handy Paint Pail, Purdy, Bercom. The seller of top 1 product has received honest feedback from 385 consumers with an average rating of 4.7.

Written by
Howard Chester Avatar

Howard Chester is an architect from New York who holds a master's degree in architectural design, his passions for interior design and home improvement contribute to his extensive knowledge of all things furniture and home goods. Howard Chester Specializes in various architectural and interior design projects. He often publishes articles related to decoration on key websites and interior design magazines.

Paint Buckets Comparison Table

#TOP1
#TOP2
#TOP3
#TOP4
#TOP5
#TOP6
#TOP7
#TOP8
#TOP9
#TOP10
Brand HANDy Paint Products Stock Your Home Handy Paint Pail Purdy Bercom HANDy Paint Products Stock Your Home Custom Shop Wooster Leaktite
Color Red Black Red Multicolor Clear Red Black Clear Green White
Material Plastic Polypropylene Plastic Blend Plastic Plastic Plastic Polypropylene, Plastic Polypropylene Plastic
Capacity 32 Fluid Ounces 1 Gallons 1 Gallons 19 Liters 1 Quarts 16 ounces 1 Quarts 174 Fluid Ounces 4 Gallons 1 Gallons
Item Weight 0.04 Pounds 1.3 Pounds 1.74 Pounds 1 Kilograms 0.15 Pounds 8 ounces - 3.56 Pounds 0.69 Kilograms 0.45 Pounds
Shape Round Round Rectangular Round Round Round Round - Round Round
With Lid -
Handle Material - Metal,Plastic,Polypropylene Plastic - - - Metal,Plastic,Polypropylene - Polypropylene (PP) Plastic
FTB Score
ftb score rating icon 9.9
ftb score rating icon 9.8
ftb score rating icon 9.6
ftb score rating icon 9.4
ftb score rating icon 9.3
ftb score rating icon 9.3
ftb score rating icon 9.1
ftb score rating icon 9.0
ftb score rating icon 8.9
ftb score rating icon 8.7
Where to Buy