Best Oil Pump Gaskets of 2025

Robert Reyes Avatar
Robert Reyes
Last Updated: Jan 6, 2025

* We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

Oil pump gaskets are essential components in ensuring that the oil pump is functioning properly. These gaskets prevent oil leakage, ensuring that the engine runs smoothly and efficiently. They are typically made from high-quality materials that are resistant to heat and pressure, which are common conditions in the engine compartment. There are various types of oil pump gaskets available, including cork, rubber, and silicone gaskets, each with their own unique benefits. When replacing an oil pump, it is important to choose the right type of gasket to ensure a proper seal and prevent future leaks.

At a Glance: Our Top Picks

MAHLE B32790 Oil Pump Pickup Tube Gasket Cover #TOP 1
MAHLE B32790 Oil Pump Pickup Tube Gasket
ftb score rating icon 9.8
FEL-PRO ES 72499 Oil Pump Gasket Cover #TOP 2
FEL-PRO ES 72499 Oil Pump Gasket
ftb score rating icon 9.7
FEL-PRO 72607 Oil Pump Gasket Cover #TOP 3
FEL-PRO 72607 Oil Pump Gasket
ftb score rating icon 9.5

Top 10 Oil Pump Gaskets

#TOP 1

MAHLE B32790 Oil Pump Pickup Tube Gasket

B32790
MAHLE B32790 Oil Pump Pickup Tube Gasket Cover
MAHLE B32790 Engine Oil Pump Pickup Tube Gasket, OE

MAHLE Original gaskets are made of OE equivalent or better materials and meet or exceed the original equipment specifications. The cylinder head bolt set contains new fasteners to ensure proper sealing load, while the shrink wrapped tray packaging provides added security. This gasket is designed for oil pump and is a reliable sealing product for your engine.

What We Like
Meets or exceeds OE specifications
Uses OE equivalent or better materials
New fasteners ensure proper sealing load
#TOP 2

FEL-PRO ES 72499 Oil Pump Gasket

ES 72499
Assorted
One Size
FEL-PRO ES 72499 Oil Pump Gasket Cover
FEL-PRO ES 72499 Oil Pump Gasket

The FEL-PRO ES 72499 Oil Pump Gasket meets or exceeds original equipment specifications and has an application-specific design to ensure a perfect fit. Engineered and manufactured for the repair environment, each gasket is made to exacting standards with proprietary design, engineering, and manufacturing processes.

What We Like
Meets or exceeds original equipment specifications
Application-specific design ensures a perfect fit
Engineered and manufactured for the repair environment
#TOP 3

FEL-PRO 72607 Oil Pump Gasket

72607
Factory
FEL-PRO 72607 Oil Pump Gasket Cover
FEL-PRO 72607 Oil Pump Gasket

The FEL-PRO 72607 Oil Pump Gasket is a high-quality gasket that meets or exceeds all original equipment specifications. Its application specific design ensures a perfect fit, making it easy to install. Engineered and manufactured specifically for the repair environment, this gasket is built to last. No matter how small, each Fel-Pro gasket is engineered to exacting standards with proprietary design, engineering, and manufacturing processes. With its superior quality and precision engineering, the FEL-PRO Oil Pump Gasket provides a reliable seal, preventing oil leaks and ensuring optimal engine performance. It is the perfect choice for any oil pump repair or replacement.

What We Like
High-quality
Perfect fit
Reliable seal
#TOP 4

X AUTOHAUX High Pressure Oil Pump Gasket Kit

a22111700ux0773
Black, Silver Tone
8.46''
X AUTOHAUX High Pressure Oil Pump Gasket Kit Cover
X AUTOHAUX 1 Set HPOP High Pressure Oil Pump Gasket Kit for Ford E-150 E-250 E-350 E-450 Super Duty 2005-2010 5C3Z-9G804-C HPOP Fitting Update Kit

The X AUTOHAUX Oil Pump Kit is designed specifically for various Ford models from 2005 to 2010, ensuring a perfect fit. This kit includes high-quality oil pump gaskets made from durable rubber, which prevents oil leaks and helps maintain your engine's performance. By sealing effectively, it addresses issues like weak acceleration and engine noise, improving your driving experience. Additionally, the materials used in this kit offer resistance to wear, high temperatures, and corrosion, promising a long service life and reliable protection for your engine.

What We Like
Perfect fit for multiple Ford models
Prevents oil leakage
Durable rubber material
High temperature resistance
#TOP 5

JEGS Oil Pump Gasket

23622
JEGS Oil Pump Gasket Cover
JEGS Oil Pump Gasket | Fits Small Block Chevy Engines | Made In USA | One-Time Use | Copper

The JEGS Oil Pump Gasket is a high-quality gasket designed to fit small block Chevrolet engines, including popular models like 283, 305, 307, 327, 350, 383 (stroker), and 400. This gasket effectively seals your vehicle's oil pump to the engine block, preventing any pressure or volume loss. Made in the USA with top-notch materials and assembly, this gasket is built to last. Its dead soft copper material expands on engine warm-up, ensuring a vacuum tight connection between the pump and main cap. With the JEGS Oil Pump Gasket, you can have peace of mind knowing that there will be no leaks and your oil pump will function optimally.

What We Like
Fits multiple small block Chevy engines
Seals oil pump to prevent pressure loss
Made in the USA
#TOP 6

Fel-Pro 72437 Oil Pump Gasket

72437
Fel-Pro 72437 Oil Pump Gasket Cover
FEL-PRO 72437 Engine Oil Pump Gasket for Toyota Pickup

The Fel-Pro 72437 Oil Pump Gasket is a high-quality gasket that meets or exceeds all original equipment specifications. Its application-specific design ensures a perfect fit, making it ideal for any repair job. Engineered and manufactured specifically for the repair environment, this gasket is built to last. Each Fel-Pro gasket, no matter how small, is made with proprietary design, engineering, and manufacturing processes to ensure top-notch quality. With this oil pump gasket, you can be confident that your engine will be properly sealed and protected. Say goodbye to leaks and enjoy a smooth and reliable performance.

What We Like
Meets or exceeds OE specifications
Application-specific design for perfect fit
Engineered and manufactured for repair environment
#TOP 7

MAHLE Original B45715 Engine Oil Pump Pickup Tube Gasket

B45715
Black
MAHLE Original B45715 Engine Oil Pump Pickup Tube Gasket Cover
MAHLE B45715 Engine Oil Pump Pickup Tube Gasket

The MAHLE Original B45715 Engine Oil Pump Pickup Tube Gasket is a high-quality gasket that meets or exceeds the original equipment specifications. Made with OE equivalent or better materials, this gasket provides superior sealing for your engine. Whether you have a domestic, Asian, or European vehicle, MAHLE Original gaskets are designed to fit perfectly. The gasket is packaged in a shrink-wrapped tray, ensuring that you have the right part before opening the package. With the MAHLE Original B45715 Engine Oil Pump Pickup Tube Gasket, you can be confident in the quality and performance of your engine's oil pump.

What We Like
High-quality sealing
Compatible with various vehicle types
Convenient packaging
#TOP 8

Crown Automotive Oil Pump Gasket

J3172332
Crown Automotive Oil Pump Gasket Cover
Crown Automotive Vintage Oil Pump Gasket

The Crown Oil Pump Gasket is designed specifically for Jeep vehicles, ensuring a perfect fit and reliable performance. With its high-quality paper construction, it offers excellent durability, allowing you to maintain your vehicle's oil pump effectively. This gasket comes in a classic brown color, which blends seamlessly with your engine components. Plus, it is backed by a 12-month warranty, giving you peace of mind with your purchase. You can trust this gasket to help prevent oil leaks, keeping your engine running smoothly and efficiently.

What We Like
High durability materials
Perfect fit for Jeep models
12-month warranty included
Effective oil leak prevention
#TOP 9

Fel-Pro 72749 Oil Pump Gasket

72749
Fel-Pro 72749 Oil Pump Gasket Cover
FEL-PRO 72749 Oil Pump Gasket

The Fel-Pro 72749 Oil Pump Gasket is a high-quality gasket designed to meet or exceed all original equipment specifications. Its application-specific design ensures a perfect fit for your oil pump. Engineered and manufactured specifically for the repair environment, this gasket is built to last. With proprietary design, engineering, and manufacturing processes, each Fel-Pro gasket, no matter how small, is made to exacting standards. The Fel-Pro 72749 Oil Pump Gasket provides a reliable and durable solution for your oil pump needs, offering convenience and peace of mind for users.

What We Like
Meets or exceeds original equipment specifications
Application-specific design for perfect fit
Engineered and manufactured for the repair environment
#TOP 10

Acura Engine Oil Pump Gasket

15115-P8A-A01
Acura Engine Oil Pump Gasket Cover
Acura 15115-P8A-A01, Engine Oil Pump Gasket

The Acura Oil Pump Gasket is a genuine Honda part designed to perfectly fit your vehicle. This gasket ensures a reliable seal for your engine oil pump, helping to prevent leaks and maintain optimal engine performance. Manufactured to meet strict specifications, it guarantees the right form and function, providing peace of mind during installation. By choosing this quality part, you can ensure that your engine operates smoothly, reducing the risk of costly repairs down the line. This gasket is an essential component for anyone looking to keep their Acura running efficiently.

What We Like
Genuine Honda part
Perfect fit for vehicles
Prevents oil leaks
Ensures optimal engine performance
Buying Guide Image

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. How much does it cost to replace oil pump seal?

The cost to replace an oil pump seal can vary depending on the make and model of the vehicle. On average, it can cost around $765, including parts and labor. However, it's important to note that this is just an estimate, and the actual cost may vary.

2. How serious is an oil pump leak?

An oil pump leak should be taken seriously as it can lead to persistently low oil levels and potentially cause serious damage to the engine. Regular vehicle maintenance is crucial to identify and repair any oil pump leaks promptly.

3. What happens when oil pump leaks?

When an oil pump seal leaks, it can result in oil soaking other parts of the engine. This can lead to oil being slung around the engine bay, causing oil to be present on the timing cover and intake manifold.

4. Can you drive with a leaking oil pump?

While it is possible to drive with a leaking oil pump in the short term, it is best to address the issue as soon as possible. Continuing to drive with a leak can result in larger oil leaks, which can lead to more serious problems.

5. Is it OK to drive with a bad oil pump?

Driving with a bad oil pump is not recommended. It can pose a risk of expensive engine damage. If you suspect your oil pump is faulty, it is advisable to have it inspected and repaired by a professional mechanic.

6. Why does my oil pump seal keep leaking?

One possible reason for the oil pump seal to keep leaking is if the seal runs dry due to lack of lubrication. This can cause extra friction and heat, leading to damage and fluid leakage. It is essential to ensure that the pump has proper lubrication to prevent the seal from leaking.

Editor's Notes

During our oil pump gasket research, we found 24 oil pump gasket products and shortlisted 10 quality products. We collected and analyzed 6,728 customer reviews through our big data system to write the oil pump gaskets list. We found that most customers choose oil pump gaskets with an average price of $5.22.

The oil pump gaskets are available for purchase. We have researched hundreds of brands and picked the top brands of oil pump gaskets, including MAHLE, Fel-Pro, X AUTOHAUX, JEGS, Crown Automotive. The seller of top 1 product has received honest feedback from 385 consumers with an average rating of 4.7.

Written by
Robert Reyes Avatar

Robert Reyes is a dedicated writer from San Francisco with a bachelor of degree in mechanics and a bachelor of degree in marketing. He focuses on making some complicated topics simple and enjoys explaining complex and technical things in an easy-to-understand way.