Best Mystery & Detective Literary Criticism Books of 2025

The Great Gatsby: Original 1925 Edition is a classic novel by F. Scott Fitzgerald, set in the Jazz Age and the Roaring Twenties. The story explores themes of decadence, idealism, social stigmas, patriarchal norms, and the negative effects of unencumbered wealth in capitalistic society. The book is a cautionary tale, revealing the darker side of the American Dream. The protagonist, Gatsby, is a compelling character, embodying the hope and romantic readiness that is rare in any other person. This novel is a must-read for anyone interested in classic literature and fiction books.

The Life of Crime: Detecting the History of Mysteries and their Creators by Martin Edwards is a comprehensive study of the evolution of crime fiction from the 18th century to the present. Edwards, a multi-award-winning crime novelist and President of the Detection Club, offers a brand-new perspective on the world’s most popular form of fiction. This magnum opus distills more than two centuries of extraordinary books and authors into one coherent history and is both authoritative and entertaining. Edwards' wide reading, good memory, and meticulous control over his material make this book a must-read for any crime fiction fan.

How to Write a Mystery is a comprehensive guide from the Mystery Writers of America, featuring essays by 70 successful mystery writers. The handbook covers everything from character development and plot to the business side of publishing, including diversity and inclusivity in all genres. The book is divided into categories, such as before writing, while writing, after writing, other than novels, and other considerations. With practical and current advice, this inclusive manual provides valuable insights for both new and established authors. Overall, How to Write a Mystery is an essential resource for anyone interested in the craft of writing a mystery novel.

Tony Hillerman's Landscape: On the Road with Chee and Leaphorn is a stunning collection of original documentary photographs of the landscapes that were integral to the writing of Tony Hillerman's novels. The book includes brief synopses of Hillerman's novels, descriptive passages from the novels, the author's own comments about the sites, and narrative information on the locations pictured. Compiled by Hillerman's eldest daughter, Anne Hillerman, with original photos from Don Strel, this book is a loving tribute to her father. The personal essay by Anne Hillerman and the introduction by Tony Hillerman add depth to this beautiful showcase of the hauntingly beautiful region that captured one man's imagination for a lifetime.

Love Me Fierce In Danger is a captivating biography that sheds light on the life of James Ellroy, one of the most renowned crime fiction authors in America. The book delves into his tumultuous past, including the unsolved murder of his mother, and how it has influenced his work. The author, Steven Powell, also reveals Ellroy's family secrets, providing a fascinating insight into the enigmatic figure. The book is well-researched, with interviews from friends, family, and collaborators, including Ellroy himself. Overall, Love Me Fierce In Danger is a must-read for fans of Ellroy and anyone interested in the life of a literary genius.

The book "Writing and Selling Your Mystery Novel Revised and Expanded Edition" by Hallie Ephron is a comprehensive guide for writers who want to craft a gripping mystery novel. The author provides valuable insights and practical tips on various aspects of writing, including creating compelling characters, constructing a plot full of twists and turns, and optimizing pace during revision. The book also offers guidance on publishing, both through traditional and indie paths. With its helpful worksheets and exercises, this book is an excellent resource for writers of mystery, suspense, and crime. Overall, this book is a must-read for aspiring mystery writers who want to hone their craft and publish their work.

The Art of the English Murder is a fascinating exploration of the history and evolution of the traditional English murder, from Jack the Ripper and Sherlock Holmes to the cozy crimes of the Golden Age. The book is a unique investigation into the English criminal soul by one of our finest historians, exploring our fascination with crimes and its impact on popular culture. This book is a must-read for anyone interested in the art of crime, and it is a great addition to the Art History Books category. Pegasus Books has done a great job publishing this masterpiece.

Amelia Peabody's Egypt is a monumental volume of Egyptian culture, history, and arcania that immerses readers in the world of the great lady's adventures. This literary criticism and theory book takes readers on a journey through the bustling streets and markets of Cairo a hundred years ago, exploring ancient tombs and temples, and marvelling at the history of this remarkable land. The book includes a hitherto unpublished journal entry and intimate biographies of the Emersons and their friends, which provide a uniquely personal view of the lives, relationships, opinions, politics, and delightful eccentricities of mystery's first family. This treasure trove overflows with Egyptological riches, making it a must-read for Peabodyphiles and Egypt aficionados alike.

Jack Reacher’s Rules is a must-read for fans of the series and those looking for a guide to living like the iconic character. The book features a compilation of Reacher’s timeless advice, tried-and-true tactics, and hard-hitting strategies that have made him one of the toughest tough guys in American crime fiction. Written by Lee Child, the author of seventeen Jack Reacher thrillers, this one-of-a-kind book provides readers with an introduction to the world of Reacher and his passion for justice. Overall, Jack Reacher’s Rules is a unique and engaging read that offers insights into the mind of one of the most beloved characters in modern fiction.

Distilling Lies, an Amazon bestseller, is a thrilling mystery set in the social tumult of the Prohibition era. The book follows seventeen-year-old Emma June who is trying to piece together the events leading to her mother's disappearance after fighting with a new friend named Betty Bedford. Emma June teams up with the town's mysterious newcomer named Frank, and together they uncover the presence of a wanted mobster who threatens the stability of their community. The book is a captivating read that keeps the reader engaged until the very end.