Best Mechanical Pencil Eraser Refills of 2025

"As an artist for over 40 years, I've always relied on these products. They work perfectly with my Twist Erase III Pentel mechanical pencils. I use various lead sizes and the soft leads are particularly fun. My pencils have lasted two decades! I’m just now replacing some that I lost, probably hiding in my couch!"

"I was thrilled to discover these replacement erasers for my Pentel mechanical pencils. No need to carry a separate eraser anymore! They perform excellently, stand up to regular use, and this pack offers fantastic value for the price."

"These erasers are truly impressive! They fit my Pentel Twist Erase 0.7 perfectly, and I've had a tough time finding them elsewhere."

"I love that the eraser is replaceable and the pencil itself is of great quality. Having plenty of refills is a bonus!"

"I've been using Pentel click pencils for over 40 years. The design and ergonomics are fantastic, and I can't imagine switching to anything else!"

"Finding this type of eraser was tough online, but now my daughter is happy and I am too!"

"I was thrilled to find these affordable bulk replacements for my Rotring 600. They fit perfectly, although I found they don't fit the 800 series."

"Using these erasers with my Pentel mechanical pencils has been a great experience. I'm really glad they're still available, and I'd recommend them to anyone!"

"I use these with my Pentel Graphgear 1000, and they fit like a glove. They last a long time and are a great value!"

"This eraser fits just right in my mechanical pencil that I bought it for. I'm addicted to crosswords, so I really need that eraser! It works great."

"I’ve been using these for 4 years now! They work for all Pentel CLICK pencils and erase very cleanly, with not a lot of dirtiness from erasing."

"I bought these refills for my grandchildren's pencils. They fit easily into the original holder and make errors disappear cleanly without difficulty."

"I noticed many negative reviews about the erasers being too small, but I believe it's more about checking the product details. The pictures clearly show the erasers are meant for specific pencils, and they work perfectly for mine."

"Initially, I thought the erasers were too small, but my son has been using them without any issues. I was mistaken, and I stand corrected!"

"While I'm not criticizing the product, I think it would be helpful to know the sizes beforehand. These are for the itty bitty erasers, not the standard Bic 7mm mechanical pencils. However, the lead is good enough to keep me satisfied."

“It works great for my pencil, but I had to cut it a bit because it was a tad too long.”

“I really appreciate how many eraser refills I received for the price. I did some research before purchasing and although they were a bit thin, a small piece of paper made them fit perfectly. I saved a lot of money this way, and I’d definitely buy again.”

“I ordered what I thought were refills for my Mr. Pencil, but unfortunately, they were the wrong size. Now I’m left with a box of erasers that don’t fit anything.”

"These erasers fit my Pentel mechanical pencils without any issues. I appreciate that they arrived quickly and securely, although the packaging was a bit excessive."

"I bought these erasers as I couldn't find them in stores. They work just as they should, and I'm pleased with how well they function."

"While the erasers are a bit smaller than the original ones, I still find them to be very good replacements. I 100% recommend them!"

"I absolutely fell in love with the ENO line and bought ten packs of pink leads. I admire the detail of the milk-tuned red and enjoy the occasional adventure with the wild and wooly purple. The only design flaw in the Pilot ENO pencil is that I can only use half its tweeraser before it sticks permanently. I always hold an eraser pencil in my other hand, because these are the bonus erasers I'm looking for."

"After some attempts, I finally found the refill erasers that fit my Fure Fure Corone Shaker Mechanical Pencil perfectly. These are definitely the right ones!"

"These erasers fit my Bazic brand multicolor pen and pencil combo well. They are a bit long, but I can trim them to my desired length. I prefer to use them as they are without the cap."

"I find these erasers to be very durable and easy to use. They fit my pencil perfectly and erase exceptionally well."

"As a user of Pentel pencils, I appreciate their quality. These erasers fit without any hassle, and I highly recommend them over generic options."

"Honestly, they're just eraser refills. They come with the metal part for the pencil and do the job well, although they do wear a little faster than I’d like."

"I love these refill erasers for my Twist Erase mechanical pencils. They are just like the ones that come with the pencils, made by Pentel, and worth every penny. I knew I would find a bulk pack here on Amazon. Thank you!"

"As a stationery junkie, I’ve been a fan of Twist Erase pencils for about 30 years. My son, a comic artist, has been stealing them from me for ages. I finally ran out of erasers and was thrilled to find these!"

"These erasers are perfect for my Pentel Side FX pencils. While I think they are a bit pricey compared to large pink erasers, I find them to work great. They erase cleanly and are soft, making them ideal for my engineering studies. With this 36-pack, I should be set for my college years!"