Best Knife Sheaths of 2025

"When I first took it out of the package, I thought it was very nice and classically made. The leather is soft and subtle. I believe it will accommodate a variety of medium-sized knives. I used to just carry my knives in my pocket without a care, but I often misplace them. Now, with this small and light sheath, I don’t have to worry about losing my knife in public, which is a relief. It also frees up some space in my front pocket. I have my Case Sodbuster in it now, and it fits great!"

"I purchased this sheath for my large stockman knife, and it's perfect for protecting it. Keeping it in a belt sheath prevents lint from accumulating in my pocket. I really appreciate the side-draw style, which is efficient and keeps the knife within easy reach. I love that I can proudly display my Case knives, which are among the best American-made knives, while ensuring they are well protected."

"I want to clarify that my review is for the Case side-draw sheath, not the standard snap-top sheath. This sheath is well made and sturdy, with good stitching and leather quality. I had some specific knife fit questions before purchasing, so I tried several. For instance, my Victorinox Tinker fits perfectly, while the Victorinox Electrician is slightly loose but secure. Most of my medium Case knives fit well. However, this sheath is not suitable for larger knives like the Buck 110."

"I found a good quality sheath that fits my Original Bowie model 76R well. However, the strap around the knife grip wasn't secured to the sheath, which made it a bit inconvenient. I plan to glue or stitch it in place. Despite arriving three days late, I would rate it higher if not for that."

"This sheath was a huge disappointment for me. The leather feels like thin cardboard and the rivets were rusted. Honestly, my childhood cap gun holsters were of better quality. I wouldn't recommend wasting your money on this."

"I was really impressed with the quality of this sheath. I had a nice emergency fixed blade that needed one, and this fit perfectly and is reasonably priced. While I’m not sure how it will hold up with regular use, the stitching and snap loop seem really solid. I'm quite happy with my purchase!"

"I purchased this sheath for my filet knife after losing the original one, and I was really impressed by the quality and appearance! The added liner is a great touch to protect the leather from the knife's sharp edge. I'm very satisfied!"

"I found this sheath to be an excellent holder for my 6" Victorinox filet/boning knife. It fits snugly and stays secure, even during rough outings on the water. The price is very reasonable for the value it offers, and I couldn't be happier!"

"While the sheath is well-made, I noticed that the plastic insert tends to come out with my knife occasionally. I bought it for my 6-inch curved knife, but it seems this sheath is better suited for a straight blade. Overall, it's still a nice product."

"I found this sheath to be well made and a great fit for my trapper knife. The thick leather is impressive and not flimsy. It was easy to put on my belt, making it a fantastic value for my money."

"I ordered three sheaths but only received two. After contacting the seller, they responded promptly and shipped the missing item via priority mail the very next day! Their service is exceptional, and I highly recommend this product!"

"This sheath is perfect for my Buck 112 Ranger. The leather is a strong reddish-brown color that looks even better than in the photos. It fits snugly and has held up well over time. I suggest warming it to relax the leather for easier use."

"I purchased the 'small' sheath for my Buck 110 and was thrilled to discover it also fits my Kershaw 'Lucha' Balisong perfectly! The sheath provides a snug and secure fit that prevents the knife from falling out. It's comfortable to wear and looks fantastic. I'm really impressed!"

"When I first got the sheath, it fit my knife snugly, which I expected. After applying an alcohol and water mixture and breaking it in, it shaped perfectly to my knife. The quality is top-notch and well made!"

"This sheath is fantastic and well crafted! I bought it for my Buck 110, and although it was tight at first, after some oil and wear, it became the best holster I've found. I'm definitely planning on buying more!"

"I ordered this leather sheath for my Gerber 4 inch fixed blade knife, and it fits perfectly. The leather is well-stitched and seems durable. It's even better than the sheath that came with my knife. I appreciate the overnight delivery from Amazon!"

"I absolutely love this sheath! The quality is great, and it's made of soft leather. It fits both of my Morakniv's perfectly. The sturdy snap adds to its reliability. I highly recommend it, especially after my experience with the plastic Morakniv cases!"

"This sheath fits my old buck knife like it was custom-made for it! It's nice to find a product that meets expectations, and the quality is definitely there."

"I found this sheath to be well made with real leather that molds quickly to my knife."

"This case was perfect for one of my boys who wanted a knife case like his dad's. It fits his knife really well and looks great for the money."

"Initially, I liked this sheath, but after a week, some material started peeling and the stitching came loose. Now, my knife wobbles around in it."

"I was pleasantly surprised by the quality. It holds well, is well made, and looks great. I can't find anything cheaper that matches this."

"This holster is well constructed and fits my Buck 110 perfectly. The large openings are perfect for my western belt, and I believe it will last a lifetime."

"I appreciate the thick leather and the tooling, even though it's not custom. It fits most of my knives well, making it a great product overall."

"I used this sheath for gifts to store knives made from deer antlers, and they fit perfectly! The quality leather looks amazing and adds to the rustic appeal of the knives!"

"I was pleasantly surprised by the quality. I had to install a foam shim for a snug fit, but it’s both beautiful and functional. I showed it off to all my friends!"

"While the leather is a bit stiff and the belt loop is tight, I’m still happy with my purchase. I modified it for a neck carry, and overall it’s a solid product!"

"I find this sheath to be stylish and well-made. It fits my Buck 112 perfectly, making it a great addition to my gear. I can carry it easily, whether I'm in town or on the ranch."

"My husband is thrilled with this knife sheath. The heavy-duty leather secures his special knife perfectly. Though it’s a bit stiff at first, I’m confident it will soften with use. It’s sturdy and fits well on his belt, plus the snap is robust!"

"I'm a lifelong fan of leather goods, and this product impresses me. The thick, quality leather is exceptionally crafted. It’s rugged and holds my tools securely. I’m very pleased with the quality!"