Best Mystery Jigsaw Puzzles of 2025

“I just finished assembling the puzzle. It was quite challenging without knowing the final image, but that’s what I expected. The story booklet was enjoyable and well-written, adding to the experience. I could make guesses about 'who done it', but there was nothing to confirm my assumptions.”

“This puzzle was a lot of fun! It was challenging to put together since there was no guiding picture, but it was incredibly addictive. The mystery was enjoyable to read, though I should mention it has some adult themes.”

“My family and I tackled this puzzle on vacation, and we had a fantastic time completing it. It was a challenge, but the story and puzzle were excellent!”

"I purchased this for summer activities while my family visited over Christmas. Everyone loved it! Instead of being glued to our phones or the TV, we were all around the table, engaged in the puzzle. I’m online now to buy another one!"

"I really enjoyed this puzzle. While I don’t think the mystery could truly be solved as intended, it was a ton of fun reading the story, piecing it together, and discussing the possibilities. I’ve already bought another puzzle in the series!"

"My mom is a puzzle fanatic. She loves them for some quiet time away from my dad. Finding unique puzzles for her is getting tougher, but when I found this one, I knew she'd appreciate it. She enjoyed it even though she skipped reading the book."

"I really liked how these puzzles featured varied patterns and clean lines with overlapping objects. It created a challenge to identify the picture, but it wasn't overly difficult to assemble. It was genuinely more enjoyable than any other puzzle I've done. We've completed several, and the pieces fit together perfectly, allowing my 5-year-old to join in."

"I purchased this as a Christmas gift for my husband, and despite some uncertainty from other reviews, I'm thrilled I did! It was exciting and fun, bringing us closer as we pieced it together without knowing the final picture. We managed to accurately guess the outcome from the puzzle and the book."

"I had a wonderful time with this puzzle! I appreciated that the story seems to be the unabridged version from the original author. It provided a great narrative alongside an intriguing puzzle. While assembling it, I found the clues from the story and reread it, which made the solution clear to me."

"I thoroughly enjoyed this puzzle. Even without a picture, it was easy to assemble, thanks to the clear distinctions in color and texture. The mystery element was a delightful bonus, making the entire experience very satisfying and fun."

"Having completed several mystery puzzles, I can say this one was the best. The quality of the pieces and the image are commendable. Unlike others I've tried, the clues here allow for a logical resolution of the crime, which I found very satisfying."

"I really liked working on this puzzle. It was challenging but manageable, with beautiful patterns and colors throughout. The mystery itself was straightforward to solve, but it still added to the fun. No pieces were missing, which was a relief!"

"My family is thrilled about solving all the options available. Although puzzles usually aren't my thing, the mystery of the picture really has me captivated!"

"I had a great time putting the puzzle together, but unfortunately, I’m missing one piece. I searched everywhere, even the trash, and it’s nowhere to be found. While the mystery aspect wasn’t very compelling and the solution felt underwhelming, the puzzle itself was enjoyable!"

"We were genuinely impressed with the puzzle. It kept our family of five entertained for quite a while. It has become a wonderful Christmas tradition. The story requires one person to read it aloud, which some family members enjoyed while others found it a bit lengthy. Overall, it was a solid mystery that I would recommend!"

"I was hesitant to purchase this puzzle due to negative reviews. However, I own almost all of these puzzles, and this one turned out to be the hardest yet. The colors were vibrant, and all the pieces were present this time. I've had issues with missing pieces in the past, but that just added to the charm, making me focus more. I truly enjoyed this puzzle and hope for more new releases!"

"My sister really enjoyed this puzzle and is very pleased with the product."

"This is the second puzzle I've bought in this series. I thoroughly enjoyed the first one I received as a Christmas gift, so I decided to get another for a birthday present. The challenge of having a different image on the box adds to the fun of completing it! I will definitely buy more in the future."

"I absolutely love White Mountain puzzles. They fit together so easily and are really colorful. There's such a wide variety of puzzles to choose from!"

"My sister gifted us this puzzle, as we've enjoyed two other murder mystery puzzles before. While this one was gorgeous and fun to assemble, I felt a bit let down by the mystery aspect. The clues were sparse and often ambiguous, leaving room for multiple interpretations."

"We had a great time putting this together. The pieces are great quality and coloring. To avoid any confusion, we made copies of the final picture from the box. Although it made things quicker, it took away some of the mystery fun. Still looking forward to the next one!"

"I wasn't familiar with the brand, but I took a chance and was pleasantly surprised. The cardboard quality is decent, and the pieces interlock nicely, though larger sections can be a bit tricky to move around. I appreciated the minimal puzzle dust and unique cut of the pieces. The image turned out to be colorful and interesting, making it a fun puzzle experience. The story added an extra layer of interaction that enhanced my appreciation for the final image."

"We decided to use this puzzle for a family night with our adult kids. They dove right in and seemed to really enjoy the experience. Initially, I was unsure about not having a picture to reference, but I think it actually helped us work together in a fun way. We didn't finish it that night, but they're eager to come back and complete it soon!"

"I found this puzzle enjoyable, especially with the clue offered halfway through that helped me solve the mystery. It was challenging but achievable. I loved the packaging, which was completely plastic-free. The solution was easy to read without needing a mirror, which is often required for these kinds of puzzles. Overall, a very enjoyable experience, and I would definitely order from this company again."

"I found it took me about 6 hours to finish by myself, but it was really fun. At one point, I thought there were extra pieces, but in the end, everything had its place."

"Having only started jigsaw puzzles 8 months ago, I found this one challenging due to the similar color tones and unique piece shapes. I did enjoy the well-made, sturdy pieces, but I was distracted by the border connection issues. Overall, I’d recommend it, but not for beginners."

"As someone who loves murder mysteries, I found this puzzle to be a great combination of challenge and enjoyment. The oddly-shaped pieces made it more interesting, and I appreciated the quick read of the story that accompanied it!"

"I had a blast with this puzzle! The murder mystery scenario added so much fun, and solving the completed puzzle was a challenge. I really enjoyed it!"

"I wasn't sure about doing a puzzle without knowing the picture, but it turned out to be a lot of fun! I gave it five stars despite a few pieces not lying flat and one missing piece, but Amazon sent a replacement, so everything's good!"

"I really loved the challenge of this puzzle. The black and white design was tough, and it took my fiancé and me about a month to finish it. The mystery aspect was a bit disappointing, but the puzzle was totally worth it!"