Best Mystery Jigsaw Puzzles of 2026

"I really appreciated the vivid colors and the crisp, clear image on this puzzle. The pieces are sturdy and fit together perfectly, and I love the smart feature of having the backs labeled for easy sorting. For under $10, the quality is impressive—the pieces are thick, cut well, and the box is solid and colorful. It even comes with a full-size reference sheet, which is a great bonus. This puzzle can be as challenging or as easy as you want, depending on whether you use the hints. I’ve already turned my finished puzzle into a wall hanging and plan to buy more for gifts because it’s so much fun."

"As a homeschooling parent, I’m pretty picky about puzzle quality, and this one delivered. The image is sharp, the pieces are great quality, and the lettered backs made sorting easy. My 11-year-old son managed to do almost all of it by himself! I was thrilled that it wasn’t like those flimsy, cheap puzzles we’ve received in the past. I highly recommend this puzzle, especially for the price—I just wish I’d gotten the 1,000-piece version for an even longer challenge."

"This puzzle turned out to be more challenging than expected, partly because many pieces are interchangeable. The lettered quadrants on the back help check fit when you’re stuck, which is useful but can also make things a bit easier than I’d like. Overall, it’s a well-made and fun puzzle with a beautiful, vibrant picture."

"I was absolutely captivated by the gorgeous image of the Italian coastline in this puzzle. The colors are rich and vibrant, and the pieces fit together so well, making the whole process a real joy. It took me several days, but I loved every moment of assembling it. I highly recommend this puzzle to anyone who enjoys a scenic challenge!"

"This was my first 1000-piece puzzle, and it turned out to be a beautiful and engaging experience over the course of a month. Although I discovered I was missing one piece and had a duplicate, the entertainment value remained high, and I still feel satisfied with the time I invested in it."

"The Buffalo Games Peter Stewart Cinque Terre puzzle is a true visual treat—the vibrant villages, detailed artwork, and premium quality pieces make it stand out. The subtle color shifts made for a delightful challenge, and I appreciated the included poster for reference. It’s a wonderful choice for anyone looking for a rewarding and immersive puzzle experience."

"I completed this puzzle in about four hours using the lettering on the back, which made sorting easier. The colors and quality are excellent, and the pieces fit together tightly. However, I found the high-gloss finish made it hard to see the pieces under normal lighting, so I had to use extra lamps and even a flashlight sometimes. Overall, I’d say it’s a medium-difficulty puzzle best for adults or older kids, but I personally wouldn’t buy another puzzle with a glossy finish."

"My husband and I worked on this puzzle over the course of a week, and it was just the right mix of challenging and fun. The picture quality is impressive, there was no dust at all, and the pieces fit together really well. We didn’t need to use the letter grid on the back, but it’s a helpful option. The only small issue is the glare from the thick coating, but the included poster and resealable bag are nice touches. I’d definitely recommend this to anyone looking for a moderately challenging and beautiful puzzle."

"The colors in this stained glass design are absolutely gorgeous, but the pattern made it tough to find matching pieces at times. I worked on it with my daughter, and while it was challenging, the artwork made it worthwhile. It’s definitely better suited to older children or adults. Even though it’s a bit pricier than some puzzles, the quality and the challenge make it worth it if you enjoy a real puzzle experience."

"I loved how vivid and colorful this puzzle was! The pieces were sturdy and not flimsy at all, and they fit together perfectly. It was a pleasure seeing the beautiful image come together."

"This puzzle was a fantastic challenge—great quality and beautiful art, but definitely on the tougher side for a 1000-piece. The letters on the back were a clever feature and made it easier to work on different sections at the same time."

"I was disappointed when we finished the puzzle and discovered a center piece was missing after spending a week on it. Otherwise, it had a nice mix of easy and hard sections and was enjoyable to assemble."