Best Historical Mystery Books of 2025

Homecoming: A Novel by Kate Morton is an intricate and spellbinding novel that spans generations. The story begins with a shocking crime that echoes across continents and generations. Jess, a journalist, discovers a true crime book chronicling a long-buried police case, the Turner Family Tragedy of 1959, which has a shocking connection to her own family. The novel explores what we would do for those we love, how we protect the lies we tell, and what it means to come home. Morton's layered writing leaves surprises for even the keenest of detectives. This is storytelling at its finest.

The Echo of Old Books by Barbara Davis is a captivating novel that tells the story of Ashlyn Greer, a rare-book dealer whose gift allows her to feel the emotional fingerprint of the books’ previous owners. Ashlyn's obsession with a pair of beautifully bound volumes, authored by Hemi and Belle, leads her to a decades-old literary mystery. The novel is packed with twists and turns, making it a good read for fans of Kate Atkinson and Taylor Jenkins Reid. The Echo of Old Books is a beautifully written story that celebrates the transformative power of love and the redemptive nature of rewriting our stories.

"And Then There Were None" is a classic detective mystery by Agatha Christie. Ten strangers are invited to an isolated island by a mysterious host who fails to appear. The guests are cut off from the world, and one by one, they die. The survivors must figure out which one of them is the killer. The novel is a masterpiece of the genre, with a clever plot that keeps the reader guessing until the end. Agatha Christie's writing is superb, and her characters are well-drawn and intriguing. This book is a must-read for fans of detective fiction and anyone who loves a good mystery."

The White Lady is a thrilling novel that introduces readers to Elinor White, a former wartime operative and trained killer who finds herself drawn back into the dangerous world she has been trying to leave behind. Set in Post-WWII Britain in 1947, Jacqueline Winspear's novel explores corruption from Scotland Yard to the highest levels of government. The story is fast-paced and thoughtful, with a complex, endearing, and achingly flawed hero. The book is a triumph of storytelling and a must-read for fans of traditional detective mysteries.

The London Séance Society by Sarah Penner is a gripping tale about two women who join forces to solve a high-profile murder. Set in 1873, the novel follows Lenna Wickes as she accompanies acclaimed spiritualist Vaudeline D’Allaire to England to investigate a crime. As they delve into the mystery, they begin to realize that they may be in danger themselves. Penner's writing is suspenseful and atmospheric, and the story blurs the lines between truth and illusion. Overall, The London Séance Society is a captivating read that will keep readers on the edge of their seats.

Ordinary Grace by William Kent Krueger is a New York Times bestseller about a young man, Frank Drum, living in a small town in Minnesota during the summer of 1961. The story follows Frank as he navigates the challenges of adolescence while also dealing with the sudden deaths of multiple people in his community, including members of his own family. Told from Frank's perspective forty years later, the novel is a poignant coming-of-age tale that explores themes of loss, grief, and the search for meaning in the face of tragedy. Overall, Ordinary Grace is a beautifully written and deeply moving novel that will stay with readers long after the final page.

The Lost Girls of Willowbrook is a haunting novel that blends fact, fiction, and urban legend to tell the story of a young woman who was mistakenly imprisoned at Willowbrook State School, the real-life institution later shuttered for its horrendous abuses. The book is a perfect read for fans of Margaret Atwood and Girl, Interrupted. The author's writing is powerful, grounded in historical fact, and ends like a fast-paced thriller. This heartbreaking yet insightful read will open one's eyes to the evil in this world. Overall, The Lost Girls of Willowbrook is a unique and thought-provoking book that will stay with readers long after they turn the last page.

Mitch Albom's "The Stranger in the Lifeboat" is a thought-provoking novel that explores what would happen if God appeared to those in desperate need of help. Ten passengers, struggling for survival after a ship explosion, pull a strange man from the sea who claims to be "the Lord." Albom keeps readers guessing until the end, making them ponder their deepest beliefs. Narrated by one of the passengers, the story is discovered a year later in a notebook that washes up on an island, adding to the mystery. This fast-paced, compelling novel is a unique addition to Christian historical fiction books.

Mastering the Art of French Murder by Harriet Welty Rochefort is a charming historical mystery set in post-WWII Paris. The story follows Tabitha Knight, Julia Child's (fictional) best friend, as she learns to cook and navigate the city with the help of her neighbor Julia. However, their world is turned upside down when a body is found in Julia's building, and a note with Tabitha's handwriting is discovered in the victim's pocket. Tabitha sets out to clear her name and find the real killer. Fans of historical mysteries and Parisian culture will enjoy this delightful book.

Symphony of Secrets by Alex Slocumb is a thrilling literary fiction novel that follows music professor Bern Hendricks as he uncovers a shocking truth about the most famous American composer of all time. The story takes readers on a journey through two different time periods, 1920s Manhattan and present-day, as Bern and his tech-savvy acquaintance, Eboni, investigate the possibility that Frederick Delaney's music may have been stolen from a Black Jazz Age prodigy named Josephine Reed. Slocumb's writing is invigorating, and the detail in his character work makes the main characters in both time periods easy to root for. Ultimately, Symphony of Secrets is a celebration of music and a cautionary tale about legacy, privilege, and creative genius.