Best Grill Smoker Boxes of 2025

"I’ve found this smoker box to be a great addition to my Weber Spirit 210 grill. It fits just right and delivers reliable smoke for a long time, making my grilling experience much better. I only wish I had discovered it sooner!"

"Using this smoker box has improved my grilling significantly. I’ve smoked chicken wings and ribs with excellent results. Initially, I used too much heat, but after adjusting my technique and soaking the wood chips longer, I achieved great smoke that lasted nearly twice as long. It’s effective on my Weber gas grill, providing about an hour of good smoke."

"On my Napoleon grill, it fit perfectly and held about 200g of wood chips. I was able to smoke for about an hour, depending on the type of wood used. The smoke production was very good, and I didn’t experience any burning issues. Overall, I’m pleasantly surprised with my first use!"

"I got this to smoke my barbeques chicken, pork, fish, and beef. After soaking my wood chips, I put them in the smoker, which holds a good amount of chips. It worked out great for me, and I plan to use it again next time I grill. It's made from stainless steel and cleans up well."

"My husband needed another tray for his smoker, and this one was the same size as his previous tray. He actually likes this one better! It's really nice and sturdy, and I highly recommend it."

"We use this on our Weber charcoal grill and it works very well. After soaking wood chips for an hour, we put them in the box on the coals. The flavor it imparts is amazing and quick. We’ve experimented with various types of wood and have learned how they pair with different meats and vegetables."

"This fits perfectly between the grease deflectors over the first burner in my gas grill. It provides just the right amount of smoke for slow smoking pork or beef, making it a great alternative to buying a smoker."

"I love using this with pellets in my gas grill. It works fantastically and the steaks, chops, and ribs I’ve cooked have tasted amazing!"

"I used to use a small metal square pan for my wood chips, and while it worked well, I decided to try this product designed for smoking. Unfortunately, even after reaching 500 degrees on my grill, it wasn't producing much smoke. I ended up using the metal pan during cooking, and that produced much better results. I might keep the lid open next time to see if that helps, or I might skip this product if it doesn't perform better."

"I bought this for my dad for Father's Day, and he loves it! It's very easy to use and works great with different flavored wood chips."

"Using this smoker box on my grill has been fantastic! No excess smoke or flames, yet my chicken has a wonderful smoky aroma and taste."

"I initially followed the directions and used unsoaked wood chips, but they caught fire. After soaking them for a few hours, I got perfect BBQ smoke flavor on my roasted chicken. Overall, I'm pleased with the purchase!"

"I used this to smoke a turkey in my Weber gas grill. It worked very well, but a chunk of cast iron was broken during shipment. I believe this is an Amazon shipping issue, not a problem with Char-Broil. I plan to buy a second one locally."

"I found this smoker box to be sturdy and well-made. It's important to season it properly like cast-iron skillets to prevent rust. After a few uses, I've had a great experience with it, and I see no reason why it wouldn't last forever."

"This smoker box allows me to turn my BBQ into a smoker. I did enjoy using it, but it didn’t create the smoke ring you'd expect from a real smoker. I recommend using it on my diffusers under the grill grate for the best results."

"I bought this smoker box for my father when his old one finally gave out. It's a great size and works well!"

"After searching through countless options, I finally settled on this one for its low price and great looks. It has truly amazed me! I used it for my first smoked chicken and it turned out to be the best chicken I've ever had, even better than charcoal. I can't recommend this enough for anyone looking for a good smoker box!"

"This box is a solid choice for my electric grill. It took about 20 minutes to smoke using a small amount of chips. Just a heads up, I had to use a small file on mine due to some sharp edges."

"I used these smoker boxes in my gas grill, filling one with apple chips and the other with hickory. The result was the most delicious smoked turkey I've ever made. Cleanup was a breeze, and the boxes are sturdy and well-constructed!"

"I needed to replace the large smoker box on my vertical smoker. I decided on a two-pack of stainless boxes, and they worked out well. While they don't hold as many wood chips as my old box, they fit nicely on the wire rack and the quality seems solid. The attached lid is a nice touch!"

"I use it to enhance the smoke in my electric smoker. Although it didn't initially produce as much smoke as I wanted, adding this box significantly improved the flavor."

"I had never used a smoker before, but after watching a video on YouTube and reading reviews, I decided to try it for my Thanksgiving turkey. It was very easy to use and ended up being the star of the show!"

"I'm not typically a fan of smoked food, and I would never invest in a standalone smoker. However, these boxes have allowed me to add some real smoke flavor to our meals using my gas grill. I appreciate that they come in two different sizes, as I mostly use the smaller one for everyday cooking."

"I've used both boxes several times on ribs and brisket. They have withstood high temperatures and seem built to last for years. I receive plenty of smoke from my propane grill, and I'm super satisfied!"

"I found that it worked really well; I used to just put some chips in a small pan, but this method allowed for a much more controlled experience, imparting a nice smoky flavor to my turkey."

"This smoker box fits perfectly on my Weber grill, but I wish it could hold more chips for a longer smoke. Just a minor complaint to keep in mind."

"Using this on my Weber Genesis e-310 was a great value. I smoked a 5lb pork shoulder and the flavor was amazing! Replacing the wood chips was a bit cumbersome, but overall, it’s in great shape after 6 hours of smoking."

"The smoker box worked as I expected; however, the hinge on the top is not well made and it's a bit hard to close and open."

"I tried this smoker box hoping it would outperform the flat box I already had. It does! The way it fits in the grooves between the flavor bars on my Weber grill brings it closer to the burner and allows for greater capacity."