Best Drum & Pail Lids of 2025

“I had some 5-gallon containers and was trying to figure out what I could use them for. I thought about using these lids to hold dog food. I found that these lids fit my containers perfectly and create a great seal. They’re very functional, easy to use, and my dog food stays fresh for months. Definitely worth the money!”

“These lids work great! They fit tightly, don’t leak, and are easy to open and close. Although I thought the price was a bit steep, they really do perform well.”

“I’ve bought at least two or three of these lids. They can be a bit of an inconvenience since it’s hard to screw the ring on and get the lid off, but they work well for us. We use them with giant ziplock bags and haven’t had any issues so far.”

"I was initially worried about bent lids based on reviews, but mine arrived in perfect condition. It fits a bit loosely, so I put a couple of bricks on top to keep it secure during windy weather. I got this to keep the rain out of my burn barrel, and I definitely recommend it!"

"I ordered this to cover my chicken dust bath. I sunk the trough into the ground and use this to protect it from rain when it's not in use. It's perfect, offers great value, and is super durable!"

"When I purchased this in December, the title didn't say it was for indoor use. Now it does. It's not suitable for outdoor use if you want to prevent rainwater from leaking in. The handle needs to be sealed with waterproof caulk. Once that’s done, it's just fine. I'm glad they updated the title but think they should clarify that the lid doesn't keep water out."

"I purchased these caps for a blue water barrel that had a corroded cap. The buyer wasn't interested in the new cap, but I found these to be a good fit at a reasonable price. Ultimately, I returned them."

"I found these caps to be decent for the money. They were sized as advertised, and I felt like I got a good value."

"I wish I had tested one of these caps before the return period ended. A standard bung wrench doesn't work with them, which rendered them useless for me."

"I needed a lid for my quench tank while heat treating knives. It clamps down solidly on the bucket and does exactly what I wanted, cutting off oxygen in case of fire."

"This lid was perfect for my project with a homemade pump from a 5-gallon bucket for our fish tank. It sealed perfectly, even under pressure, and saved me $200 on a filter!"

"Initially hesitant, I took a chance on this lid for my Berrymans carb cleaner. After a little adjustment, it fit perfectly. It keeps the cleaner from evaporating and prevents spills, which is crucial since it's expensive and dangerous."

"I'm very happy with my purchase. These buckets are heavy food grade and not the thin junk found at box stores. I use them for honey and can rely on the seals to stay intact without failures like the ones from Lowe's and Home Depot."

"I’m beyond pleased with these 5-gallon storage buckets. They are food grade, sturdy, and stack well. The lids fit tightly, and I’ve just ordered more. They arrived quickly and were packed extremely well. There’s no smell to them, making them perfect for storing wheat, beans, flours, and sugar."

"These buckets are awesome. They are durable, stackable, and seal well. I’m using them to store seeds and nuts in the deep freezer, and some oat groats in my closet. I highly recommend them for anyone looking for reliable storage options."

"This cover works well; my only issue is that it creates a pool of water when it rains."

"I found them a bit tricky to tighten and they seem less durable than I expected. They are thinner than I thought, so I was careful while tightening. I’ll see how they hold up against water and heat this summer."

"I use a drum for empty soda cans and the plastic liner bag would deteriorate in the sun. This cover has solved that problem nicely."

“I initially doubted the buckets, but they're perfectly fine. I just wasn't following the instructions. Great buy!”

“I appreciate the heavy weight of the bucket. Great value for what I paid.”

“This is a solid, thick black bucket. The lids fit tightly, and I use them as chicken feeders. The black color prevents algae growth in the water.”

“I had specific color expectations, but it appeared more orange than red. However, the product is high quality, and the customer service was excellent after my feedback.”

"I had a Vaultees dog food bin, but after it got destroyed, I decided not to spend another $60 on a single bin. Instead, I bought this product and some orange buckets from Home Depot. Now I have four buckets that hold two bags of dog food each for less than the cost of the Vaultees bin. It's worth noting that the lids are a bit challenging to install, so I recommend using a rubber mallet to make it easier."

"I've been using these lids for my five-gallon buckets and I'm quite impressed. They create a strong seal and make storage a lot simpler. Unlike traditional snap lids, these screw-on lids ensure that the contents remain spill-proof, which is perfect for items like wood pellets or bird seed. I have no complaints about their functionality!"

"Living on a farm means I have five-gallon buckets everywhere, and finding a decent lid can be a challenge. These lids have really enhanced the utility of my old buckets—we now store feed in them with the screw-off lid, making it so much more convenient. Just a tip: take out the center before trying to attach it to the bucket, as it won't fit if the lid is still inside the ring."

"This cover fits perfectly on my burn barrel and seems to be good quality!"

"I found that the cover fits well and can be tightened, which keeps it secure. However, it can hold water, causing it to cave in under too much weight. Overall, it serves its purpose and is a decent value for the money."

"I bought this lid for a 55-gallon barrel, but unfortunately, it was a bit loose. Within a couple of hours, the wind got underneath and sent it sailing away."