Best Collectible Card Screwdowns of 2025

Jimmy Roof Avatar
Jimmy Roof
Last Updated: Jan 2, 2025

* We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

Collectible Card Screwdowns are a must-have for any serious collector of trading cards. These protective cases are designed to keep your most valuable cards safe from damage and deterioration over time. The screwdowns are made from high-quality materials and feature a clear, hard plastic cover that allows you to display your cards while keeping them safe from dust, dirt, and other potential hazards. They are easy to use and offer a secure fit that will keep your cards in pristine condition for years to come. Whether you collect sports cards, gaming cards, or any other type of trading card, Collectible Card Screwdowns are a smart investment that will help you preserve your collection for generations to come.

At a Glance: Our Top Picks

Ultra Pro Trading Card Holder Cover #TOP 1
Ultra Pro Trading Card Holder
ftb score rating icon 9.8
BCW 2 Card Screwdown Holder - Black Border Cover #TOP 2
BCW 2 Card Screwdown Holder - Black Border
ftb score rating icon 9.7
Ultra Pro Lucite UV 1" Screwdown Cover #TOP 3
Ultra Pro Lucite UV 1" Screwdown
ftb score rating icon 9.5

Top 10 Collectible Card Screwdowns

#TOP 1

Ultra Pro Trading Card Holder

SFRSCR
Clear
Ultra Pro Trading Card Holder Cover
Ultra Pro 1/4" Screwdown Recessed Trading Card Holder ( Packaging May Vary ),Plastic, Clear

The Ultra Pro 1/4" Screwdown Recessed Trading Card Holder is a 2-piece ultra clear holder that can hold cards of size 2-1/2" by 3-1/2" securely with its 4-screw closure. It features a recessed area to hold the cards in place, preventing them from shifting or falling out. The holder is acid-free and does not contain any PVC, ensuring your cards are protected from damage. This product is perfect for collectors looking for a safe and secure way to display their valuable trading cards.

What We Like
Securely holds standard sized trading cards
Recessed area prevents cards from shifting or falling out
Acid-free and PVC-free, ensuring cards are protected from damage
#TOP 2

BCW 2 Card Screwdown Holder - Black Border

BCW
1-2CS-B
BCW 2 Card Screwdown Holder - Black Border Cover
BCW Screwdown 2-Card Holder - Black Border | Secure 2 Standard Trading Cards | Crystal Clear Holder | Recessed Card Areas | Brass Screws Design | Card Display Case

The BCW 2 Card Screwdown Holder - Black Border is a 2 piece design holder with brass screws that can hold 2 standard trading cards. It has recessed card areas that keep your cards in place and prevent them from shifting. It is a great option for collectors who want to protect their valuable trading cards from damage and keep them in pristine condition.

What We Like
Durable 2 piece design with brass screws
Recessed card areas keep your cards in place
Protects your valuable trading cards from damage
#TOP 3

Ultra Pro Lucite UV 1" Screwdown

15660
Clear
Ultra Pro Lucite UV 1" Screwdown Cover
Ultra Pro Lucite UV 1" Screwdown

The Ultra Pro Lucite UV 1" Screwdown is a clear and durable card holder that provides UV protection for your cards. It can hold both standard and vintage-sized cards up to 3" x 4-3/8", and the top piece has a beveled edge for a professional look. This screwdown also does not contain any PVC or acid, making it safe for your cards. For additional protection, you can use Ultra PRO card sleeves.

What We Like
Durable and clear
Provides UV protection for cards
Can hold both standard and vintage-sized cards up to 3" x 4-3/8"
#TOP 4

Pro-Mold PC-5II 1-Screw Standard Trading Card Screwdown Holders

Pro-Mold
Pro-Mold PC-5II 1-Screw Standard Trading Card Screwdown Holders Cover
Display Box of 25 Pro-Mold PC-5II 1-Screw Standard 20pt Trading Card Screwdown Holders PC5II

Protect your valuable trading cards with the Pro-Mold PC-5II 1-Screw Standard Trading Card Screwdown Holders. This box of 25 holders is designed to hold standard trading cards up to 20pt. The 2-piece design with a brass screw ensures a secure fit for your cards. With exterior dimensions of 2 7/8 x 4 x 2/7 and interior dimensions of 2 1/2 x 3 1/2 x 2/87, these holders provide ample space to showcase your cards while keeping them safe from damage. Whether you're a collector or just want to protect your favorite cards, these Pro-Mold Trading Card Holders are a must-have. They offer convenience, durability, and peace of mind for your trading card collection.

What We Like
Protective and secure
Ample space for standard trading cards
Durable 2-piece design
#TOP 5

Jetec Acrylic Card Holder Set

Jetec-cases-35468
Clear
Jetec Acrylic Card Holder Set Cover
Acrylic Card Holder Screw Trading Card Protector 35 PT Clear Card Protectors for Baseball Football Sports Card Game Card Storage and Display (15 Pieces)

The Jetec Card Holder is an excellent way to protect and showcase your trading cards. This set includes 15 holders that are perfect for standard-sized cards, making it easy for you to store and display your baseball, football, or basketball cards. Each holder features a secure screw design, ensuring your cards are well-protected from damage. Made of clear, sturdy acrylic, these holders keep your cards looking vibrant and free from fading. With notches on the corners, you won’t have to worry about bending or spoiling your cards, providing you with peace of mind while enjoying your collection.

What We Like
Easy card storage
Secure screw design
Clear, durable material
Prevents card bending
#TOP 6

Pro Mold One Screw Card Holders

Pro Mold
PM-PC5II5
Small
Pro Mold One Screw Card Holders Cover
Pro Mold One Screw Screwdown Card Holders 5-Pack

The Pro Mold Card Holders are designed to securely store your valuable trading cards. Each pack contains five holders, making it easy for you to keep multiple cards safe and organized. With a recessed arrowhead in each corner, these holders provide a snug fit for cards up to 20pt in thickness, ensuring they stay protected from damage. The user-friendly design allows for quick and simple access, so you can showcase your collection without hassle. Enjoy peace of mind knowing your cards are well-protected with these reliable screwdown holders.

What We Like
Protects valuable cards
Holds thick cards securely
Easy access to cards
Convenient 5-pack
#TOP 7

Ultra-Pro 1/4 inch 4-Screw Screwdown Holder (25 Pack)

Ultra Pro Holders
Clear
Ultra-Pro 1/4 inch 4-Screw Screwdown Holder (25 Pack) Cover
Ultra-Pro 1/4 inch 4-Screw Screwdown Holder (Quantity of 25)

The Ultra-Pro 1/4 inch 4-Screw Screwdown Holder is a set of 25 recessed holders designed to hold standard sized cards up to 3.5 x 2.5. It is free from PVC and acid, making it safe for your collectibles. The recessed card area ensures that your cards stay in place, and the holders are stackable for easy storage.

What We Like
Comes in a set of 25 holders
Free from PVC and acid, ensuring your collectibles are safe
Recessed card area keeps your cards in place
Stackable design makes for easy storage
#TOP 8

Ultra Pro 1” Thick Lucite Screwdown Trading Card Display

SF1INCH
Team Colors
Small
Ultra Pro 1” Thick Lucite Screwdown Trading Card Display Cover
Ultra Pro 1” Thick Lucite Screwdown Trading Card Display

The Ultra Pro 1” Thick Lucite Screwdown Trading Card Display is designed for standard cards or small photographs. It is made of acid-free, thick and heavy Lucite, ensuring the safety of your collectibles. The four-screw closure on each corner and beveled edges give it a premium look. It is recommended for use with Ultra Pro sleeves to maintain archival safety.

What We Like
Heavy and thick Lucite material ensures safety of collectibles
Premium look due to beveled edges and four-screw closure on each corner
Designed for standard cards or small photographs
#TOP 9

BCW 4 Card Holder

BCW
1-4CS-B
Black
4 1/2 x 12 1/2
BCW 4 Card Holder Cover
BCW 4 Screwdown Card Holder | Black Border | Holds 4 Standard Trading Cards | Brass Screws | Recessed Card Areas for Extra Protection | Durable Polypropylene Construction | Secure Display Case

The BCW Card Holder is designed to securely display and protect up to four standard trading cards. With recessed areas for each card, you can trust that your collectibles will remain in place without risk of shifting or damage. The robust two-piece construction, reinforced with brass screws, ensures durability, making it perfect for showcasing your favorite sports, Pokémon, or trading cards. Crafted from sturdy polypropylene, this holder offers reliable protection against wear and tear, preserving the quality of your valuable cards. Enjoy peace of mind knowing your cards are safe and beautifully displayed.

What We Like
Secure card protection
Durable construction
Stylish black border
Recessed card fit
#TOP 10

BCW 9 Card Screwdown Holder - Black Border

BCW
1-9CS-B
Black
1 Pack
BCW 9 Card Screwdown Holder - Black Border Cover
BCW Wall Mountable Trading Card Display Frame | 9 Card Screwdown Holder | Baseball Card Display Frame | High-Impact Crystal Clear Polystyrene | Ideal as a Baseball Card Frame Wall Display

The BCW 9 Card Screwdown Holder - Black Border is a collectible card screwdown designed to hold 9 standard trading cards. It has a wall mountable feature that allows you to display your cards at your convenience. The 2 piece design with brass screws ensures that the cards are held securely and in place. The recessed card areas add an extra layer of protection to the cards and prevent them from scratching or getting damaged.

What We Like
Can hold up to 9 standard trading cards
Wall mountable for easy display
2 piece design with brass screws ensures secure holding
Recessed card areas provide additional protection
Buying Guide Image

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Are Screwdown card holders good?

A screwdown holder puts immense pressure on the card itself, which is the exact thing to avoid when storing sports cards. While a screwdown holder might not have significant impact over a shorter period of time; as years go on, the higher the probability that the holder has caused irreversible damage.

2. Why are screw cases bad for Cards?

card is thicker than the case design, so case "squishes" the card. 2. the plastic chips that occur when the screw gets tightened can accidentally scratch the card, or make an imprint.

Editor's Notes

During our collectible card screwdown research, we found 24 collectible card screwdown products and shortlisted 10 quality products. We collected and analyzed 18,407 customer reviews through our big data system to write the collectible card screwdowns list. We found that most customers choose collectible card screwdowns with an average price of $13.34.

The collectible card screwdowns are available for purchase. We have researched hundreds of brands and picked the top brands of collectible card screwdowns, including Ultra Pro, BCW, Pro-Mold, Jetec, Ultra Pro Holders. The seller of top 1 product has received honest feedback from 385 consumers with an average rating of 4.7.

Written by
Jimmy Roof Avatar

Jimmy Roof is a toy designer who lives in Chicago with his family. He works in a big toy firm, so he is surrounded by toys every day. Throughout his career, he has developed expertise in children's toys, baby products and preschool education. Jimmy Roof often publishes articles related to toys on key websites.