Best Collar Stays for Men of 2025

"Over time, I needed collar stays for my dress shirts, and these plastic stays have proven to be substantial and versatile. They fit well in all my shirts, regardless of the collar style. I prefer these to metal ones, as I’d rather replace them than risk damaging my shirts."

"This set is fantastic! It has the perfect weight to keep my collar down, and even though I only use two sizes, it’s reassuring to have a full range at my disposal."

"I appreciate the durability of these collar stays, much better than the plastic ones provided with shirts. While I have 23 shirts, and it’s a bit tricky to remember which size goes where, they do a great job with my unruly collars."

"I appreciate the great variety of sizes for all my collars. The sturdy plastic keeps the collar points in place, and the holder keeps everything neat."

"I've found these stays to be really useful. I'm prone to losing or bending them, so having different lengths is great. They have just the right amount of flexibility and are a good value for what I paid."

"I initially bought this pack after losing a collar stay in the wash. I thought I’d only need one, but I ended up replacing all my collar stays. Now, I feel like I'm truly well dressed!"

"I love this product for my shirts with collar stay slots. This is my second order after misplacing many from the first pack. I use 'power button' style magnets along with these to ensure my ties and collar always look perfect. I would HIGHLY recommend!"

"I was surprised by how thick and sturdy the stays are, much thicker than I expected. The different lengths accommodate all my dress shirt brands, and I'm very happy with my purchase."

"Well packaged and delivered quickly. They look great in their case and are well organized. I had lost my only pair of size X collar stiffeners, but since purchasing these, I haven't lost a single set. The range of sizes should cover any collar I plan to use in the future."

"I love the look of button-down collars! These magnetic collar stays are such a brilliant solution. They keep my collars from flying away, especially when I'm not wearing a tie. They make for a great polished yet casual look, and I'm even getting some for the guys in my family this Christmas!"

"I've been using these stays for four months, and they work great! I can move around a lot, and my collar has never disconnected. The only tricky part is slipping them in, but once I figured it out, it was a breeze. I did buy a $15 backup pack just in case I lost any, which has been worth it!"

"These magnetic stays are a fantastic invention! They keep my collars perfectly in place without sagging. Just be careful at airport security because the magnets might get flagged. Overall, they are a wonderful addition to my wardrobe!"

"I love how affordable this set is, especially with the variety of sizes. It's perfect for my boyfriend's business casual shirts!"

"I appreciate the discreet packaging and how easy it is to bring these along. They really save the day when I accidentally wash the originals!"

"These inserts do their job well! They keep my collars looking sharp and clean, and I couldn't be happier with my purchase!"

"These metal collar stays are absolutely fantastic! Unlike the plastic ones, they haven’t bent over time. I use the various sizes from Monday to Friday, and I’ve even forgotten to take them out during washes—they come out safe and straight. I even bought a second set as a stocking stuffer for my dad, and he loved them too. They're a thoughtful and useful gift for any working man!"

"I find these collar stays to be very nice and durable. They come in every size I need. The only small issue I've encountered is that they can be a bit heavy for lower-quality shirts, causing the collar to sag. But honestly, that's just for the cheapest shirts that probably don’t need stays at all."

"I absolutely love these! No more broken stays for me. They fit all my dress shirts perfectly and form the collar better than any plastic stays I've tried."

"I love that these are one size fits all. It's hard to find such a product, and my husband is really happy with the quality."

"I appreciate the variety of sizes that make these perfect for any shirt. Definitely a good value!"

"I bought these as a gift, and my friend really appreciated them. They were exactly what I was looking for!"

"I was skeptical at first, but after a few weeks, I absolutely love these collar stays. They perform exactly as promised and keep my collar looking perfect. They're also hardly noticeable, which is a definite plus!"

"Having used Workin Stiffs for years, I can say that although the price is a bit high, the product's quality is exceptional. They really elevate how I present myself."

"These collar stays are a must-have for dress shirts! They are sturdy and effective, though I wish they included extra magnets since they can easily be misplaced. Overall, they’re very easy to use."

"I initially bought these to replace flimsy plastic stays that came with my dress shirts. They fit fairly well, but I found them a little skinny, so I had to ensure my collar was flipped down to keep them in place. I think they do the job for what I paid, but a magnet would help!"

"I was worried I’d ruined my favorite old dress shirts until I discovered these collar stays. They come in various sizes, allowing me to find the perfect fit for each collar. This product has saved me a lot of money from buying new shirts or overpriced stays!"

"These collar stays are fantastic! I didn’t even know what they were until I found a flimsy plastic one in my shirt collar. Metal stays are so much more durable, and I appreciate the mixed sizes available. I’m on my second order now and have learned my lesson about being careful with them!"

"I find these to work great; they're heavy enough to avoid bending like cheaper plastic ones."

"I appreciate the decent quality and packaging. They hold straight without being overly thick, and I likely won't need to buy more unless I lose them."

"These collar stays are exactly what I needed. The magnets are small but powerful, keeping my collars in place perfectly."