Best 19th Century Literary Criticism Books of 2025

This literary criticism book by Gary Saul Morson delves into the deep philosophical questions posed by Russian writers throughout the centuries. From the debate on good and evil to the search for life's essence, Morson explores the intellectual debates that have shaped Russian literature. He also highlights the characteristic theme of Russian culture: the aspiration to relieve profound suffering can lead to either heartfelt empathy or bloodthirsty tyranny. Overall, this thought-provoking journey into inescapable questions is a wise and authoritative read for those interested in Russian literature and philosophy.

Giorgio Agamben's "Hölderlin's Madness: Chronicle of a Dwelling Life, 1806–1843" is a thought-provoking analysis of the life and work of Friedrich Hölderlin, one of Europe's greatest poets. The book examines the poet's years of purported madness and delves into texts that were once considered unreadable. Agamben's chronology of Hölderlin's life offers a unique perspective on what it means to inhabit a place or a self. This book is a must-read for anyone interested in literary criticism and the intersection of philosophy and poetry.

Three Roads Back by Robert Richardson is a powerful book that explores how three influential American writers, Emerson, Thoreau, and William James, dealt with personal tragedies and found resilience from devastating loss. Richardson provides rich biographical details and passages from the journals and letters of these writers, showing how their responses to grief helped shape American literature and philosophy. The book is an inspiring account of how new growth and creativity can stem from loss and how resilience can be practiced through study, creation, companionship, and deep reflection.

Anna Karenina, published by Oxford World's Classics, is a timeless masterpiece that tells the story of a woman who sacrifices everything for love. Tolstoy's intricate portrayal of Russian society in the 1870s takes readers on a journey from high society St. Petersburg to the countryside of Levin's estate. The novel's characters, particularly Levin, are relatable and add a deep philosophical significance to the search for happiness. Rosamund Bartlett's translation accurately captures Tolstoy's emotional depth and stylistic nuances. This classic literature and fiction book is a must-read for anyone who enjoys a complex and moving tale.

The Lost 116 Pages: Reconstructing the Book of Mormon's Missing Stories by Don Bradley is a highly anticipated work that delves into the lost pages of the Book of Mormon. Bradley presents over a decade of research to not only tell the story of the lost pages but to reconstruct many of the detailed stories written on them. This audacious attempt to make sense of the Book of Mormon is a book that rewards reading, re-reading, and re-re-reading. The Lost 116 Pages is a must-read for anyone interested in the history of Mormonism and the Book of Mormon.

Conversations with Goethe: In the Last Years of His Life is a rare insight into the mind of Johann Wolfgang von Goethe, the world's most celebrated poet, novelist, critic, and thinker. The book covers the last nine years of his life, during which he had conversations with Johann Eckermann, who recorded Goethe's thoughts, ideas, observations, and witticisms. The result is an enjoyable and important document that reveals a gentler, more human side to the great man and his thoughts on art, science, poetry, philosophy, and the minutiae of life. This new translation, the first in 150 years, is a must-read for anyone interested in the last universal genius of the West.

Penguin Books' "Why Read Moby-Dick?" by Nathaniel Philbrick is a must-read for anyone who loves American literature. Philbrick takes readers on a journey through Melville's classic, revealing the humor and unforgettable characters that make this novel a timeless masterpiece. He highlights the thread that binds Ishmael and Ahab to our own time and creates a powerful case for why this classic tale should be rediscovered. Philbrick's passion for the subject is contagious, making this slender volume a refreshing and enjoyable tribute to one of America's greatest novels.

Nana, the ninth book in the Rougon-Macquart series, tells the story of a high-class prostitute and actress named Nana who becomes a celebrity in Paris during the Second Empire. Despite her beauty and charm, she ruins all men who fall under her spell, including Count Muffat, Chamberlain to the Empress. However, Nana meets a terrible fate due to her own dissipation and extravagance. This book is a scathing denunciation of society's hypocrisy and moral corruption during the Second Empire. The translator, Helen Constantine, has done an excellent job of bringing the story to life for English readers. Overall, Nana is a must-read for anyone interested in classic literature and social commentary.

The Madwoman in the Attic by Sandra Gilbert and Susan Gubar is a feminist classic and a pathbreaking book of literary criticism that explores the works of 19th-century women novelists, presenting the first persuasive case for the existence of a distinctly female imagination. The book challenges readers to take a new look at the grandes dames of English literature and offers a bold new interpretation of their works. With a new introduction by Lisa Appignanesi, this reissued book still feels fresh and relevant some four decades later. Overall, The Madwoman in the Attic is a must-read for anyone interested in feminist literary criticism and women's literature.

"Jane Austen and the State of the Nation" by Sheryl Craig is a fascinating exploration of Austen's political and economic references in her novels. Craig convincingly argues that Austen was a liberal Tory with a consistent political agenda throughout her career. This book will be of great interest to scholars and students alike, as it provides a deep understanding of the historical background of Austen's works. Overall, Craig's research sheds light on the political dimensions of Austen's novels and offers a unique perspective on her literary legacy.